Sustainability · 2024
Influence of the Long-Term Application of Management Practices (Tillage, Cover Crop and Glyphosate) on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Soil Physical Properties
Doyeni, M. O., Suproniene, S., Versuliene, A., Meskauskiene, L., Kadziene, G.
Export
Influence of the Long-Term Application of Management Practic…
Abstract
Soil treatments have a significant influence on the agricultural and environmental productivity of agricultural practices. Arable lands are one of the sources of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) that are influenced by the chemical and physical properties of the soil and are an essential contributor to climate change. We aim to evaluate the long-term management of agricultural practices, such as different tillage systems, cover crops, and glyphosate, on GHG emissions and soil physical properties. The field trial involved three tillage systems (conventional tillage (CT), reduced tillage (RT), and no-tillage (NT)), along with variations in cover cropping (with and without cover crops) and glyphosate application (with and without glyphosate). These treatments were implemented during the cultivation of oilseed rape in 2022 as part of a cropping sequence consisting of five crops: winter wheat; winter oilseed rape; spring wheat; spring barley; and field pea. Greenhouse gas emissions (carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O)) were directly measured using a closed static chamber system. Through the examination of these management techniques, the soil’s physical properties over the studied period were assessed for their impact on GHG fluxes. The findings of the study reveal that N2O emissions were relatively low during the first month of measurement, with significant differences (p < 0.05) observed in the interaction between cover crop and glyphosate treatments. Additionally, N2O emissions were notably elevated in the reduced (0.079 µg m−2 h−1) and conventional tillage (0.097 µg m−2 h−1) treatments at the second month of measurement. Regarding CH4, increased emissions were observed in the reduced tillage and cover crop treatments. CO2 emissions exhibited variability across all of the investigated treatments. Notably, GHG fluxes spiked at the second measurement, signifying the maximum uptake of nutrients by the main plants during the growth phase. Greenhouse gas emissions leveled off across all of the treatments following the harvest, marking the end of the cultivation period. The influence of the deployed techniques varied across the determined physical parameters of the soil. The incorporation of cover crops contributed to improved water content and, further, to electrical conductivity. Glyphosate use showed no direct impact on physical properties of the soil while the different tillage treatments had varying effects on the distribution of the physical properties of the soil with respect to the degree of disturbance or tillage-induced changes. Additionally, GHG emissions were strongly correlated with precipitation at one week and two weeks before sampling, except for CO2, which showed a weaker correlation at two weeks before GHG sampling. The findings indicate that reduced and conventional tillage methods might adversely affect greenhouse gas emissions and plant functionality, particularly concerning nutrient release and uptake, especially in temperate climate conditions.
Show all
Soil treatments have a significant influence on the agricultural and environmental productivity of agricultural practices. Arable lands are one of the sources of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) that are influenced by the chemical and physical properties of the soil and are an essential contributor to climate change. We aim to evaluate the long-term management of agricultural practices, such as different tillage systems, cover crops, and glyphosate, on GHG emissions and soil physical properties. The field trial involved three tillage systems (conventional tillage (CT), reduced tillage (RT), and no-tillage (NT)), along with variations in cover cropping (with and without cover crops) and glyphosate application (with and without glyphosate). These treatments were implemented during the cultivation of oilseed rape in 2022 as part of a cropping sequence consisting of five crops: winter wheat; winter oilseed rape; spring wheat; spring barley; and field pea. Greenhouse gas emissions (carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O)) were directly measured using a closed static chamber system. Through the examination of these management techniques, the soil’s physical properties over the studied period were assessed for their impact on GHG fluxes. The findings of the study reveal that N2O emissions were relatively low during the first month of measurement, with significant differences (p < 0.05) observed in the interaction between cover crop and glyphosate treatments. Additionally, N2O emissions were notably elevated in the reduced (0.079 µg m−2 h−1) and conventional tillage (0.097 µg m−2 h−1) treatments at the second month of measurement. Regarding CH4, increased emissions were observed in the reduced tillage and cover crop treatments. CO2 emissions exhibited variability across all of the investigated treatments. Notably, GHG fluxes spiked at the second measurement, signifying the maximum uptake of nutrients by the main plants during the growth phase. Greenhouse gas emissions leveled off across all of the treatments following the harvest, marking the end of the cultivation period. The influence of the deployed techniques varied across the determined physical parameters of the soil. The incorporation of cover crops contributed to improved water content and, further, to electrical conductivity. Glyphosate use showed no direct impact on physical properties of the soil while the different tillage treatments had varying effects on the distribution of the physical properties of the soil with respect to the degree of disturbance or tillage-induced changes. Additionally, GHG emissions were strongly correlated with precipitation at one week and two weeks before sampling, except for CO2, which showed a weaker correlation at two weeks before GHG sampling. The findings indicate that reduced and conventional tillage methods might adversely affect greenhouse gas emissions and plant functionality, particularly concerning nutrient release and uptake, especially in temperate climate conditions.
Soil treatments have a significant influence on the agricultural and environmental productivity of agricultural practices. Arable lands are one of the sources of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) that are influenced by the chemical and physical properties of the soil and are an essential contributor to climate change. We aim to evaluate the long-term management of agricultural practices, such as different tillage systems, cover crops, and glyphosate, on GHG emissions and soil physical properties. The field trial involved three tillage systems (conventional tillage (CT), reduced tillage (RT), and no-tillage (NT)), along with variations in cover cropping (with and without cover crops) and glyphosate application (with and without glyphosate). These treatments were implemented during the cultivation of oilseed rape in 2022 as part of a cropping sequence consisting of five crops: winter wheat; winter oilseed rape; spring wheat; spring barley; and field pea. Greenhouse gas emissions (carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N2O)) were directly measured using a closed static chamber system. Through the examination of these management techniques, the soil’s physical properties over the studied period were assessed for their impact on GHG fluxes. The findings of the study reveal that N2O emissions were relatively low during the first month of measurement, with significant differences (p < 0.05) observed in the interaction between cover crop and glyphosate treatments. Additionally, N2O emissions were notably elevated in the reduced (0.079 µg m−2 h−1) and conventional tillage (0.097 µg m−2 h−1) treatments at the second month of measurement. Regarding CH4, increased emissions were observed in the reduced tillage and cover crop treatments. CO2 emissions exhibited variability across all of the investigated treatments. Notably, GHG fluxes spiked at the second measurement, signifying the maximum uptake of nutrients by the main plants during the growth phase. Greenhouse gas emissions leveled off across all of the treatments following the harvest, marking the end of the cultivation period. The influence of the deployed techniques varied across the determined physical parameters of the soil. The incorporation of cover crops contributed to improved water content and, further, to electrical conductivity. Glyphosate use showed no direct impact on physical properties of the soil while the different tillage treatments had varying effects on the distribution of the physical properties of the soil with respect to the degree of disturbance or tillage-induced changes. Additionally, GHG emissions were strongly correlated with precipitation at one week and two weeks before sampling, except for CO2, which showed a weaker correlation at two weeks before GHG sampling. The findings indicate that reduced and conventional tillage methods might adversely affect greenhouse gas emissions and plant functionality, particularly concerning nutrient release and uptake, especially in temperate climate conditions.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
BD
↑ 1= 23
- increase
NT vs. CTsignificant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Average of5–10 and15–20cm cores, represented as0–20cm arable layer. WithCC; bothG variants identical. Tukey a versusb.
Numbers
- treatment 1.59 vs. control 1.48 g/cm3 (+7.432 %)
Source · p. 8 “higher BDs observed in NT treatments”
Source · p. 8 “1.59 ± 0.01 a”
Source · p. 8 “1.48 ± 0.02 b”
- no effect
Persian clover cover crop vs. without cover cropsnot significant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Averaged5–10/15–20cm cores. CT, bothG variants;1T/1TG1.48b vs1/1G1.49b. Shared letters override conclusion decrease.
Numbers
- treatment 1.48 vs. control 1.49 g/cm3 (-0.6711 %)
Source · p. 8 “1.48 ± 0.02 b”
Source · p. 8 “1.49 ± 0.03 b”
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Averaged5–10/15–20cm cores; eachG pair identicalBD within tillage/CC.
Source · p. 12 “glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
VWC
= 22
- no effect
Persian clover cover crop vs. without cover cropsnot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022 first3GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · All matchedCC pairs share Tukey letters across CT/RT/NT andG variants; table tests override verbal water-content improvement.
Numbers
- treatment 23.57 vs. control 18.68 %vol (+26.18 %) · CT withoutG
- treatment 20.92 vs. control 18.08 %vol (+15.71 %) · RT withoutG
- treatment 21.86 vs. control 19.58 %vol (+11.64 %) · NT withoutG
Source · p. 8 “23.57 ± 1.43 a”
Source · p. 8 “18.68 ± 1.36 ab”
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022 first3GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Across CT/RT/NT,with/withoutCC; all matchedG pairs shareletters. Glyphosate applied inautumn, not duringoilseedrape growth.
Source · p. 11 “There was no direct impact of glyphosate on the soil water concentration.”
Source · p. 12 “glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
pore EC
= 22
- no effect
Persian clover cover crop vs. without cover cropsnot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022 first3GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · All matchedCC pairs share letters. CT withoutG16.16a vs11.13ab; RT12.16ab vs10.62ab; NT14.76ab vs11.69ab mS/m. WithG also shareletters.
Source · p. 8 “16.16 ± 0.68 a”
Source · p. 8 “11.13 ± 0.90 ab”
Source · p. 8 “12.16 ± 2.11 ab”
Source · p. 8 “10.62 ± 1.19 ab”
Source · p. 8 “14.76 ± 1.24 ab”
Source · p. 8 “11.69 ± 1.60 ab”
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022 first3GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · All matchedG pairs shareTukeyletters across tillages andCC.
Source · p. 12 “glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
Source · p. 8 “11.68 ± 0.96 ab”
Source · p. 8 “11.13 ± 0.90 ab”
WFPS
= 22
- no effect
Persian clover cover crop vs. without cover cropsnot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022 first3GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · WFPS usesVWC0–10cm andTP arablelayeraverage. AllmatchedCCpairs shareletters; CT55.35a vs43.87ab,RT49.14ab vs42.46ab,NT51.33ab vs45.98ab%; withGalso sharedletters.
Source · p. 8 “55.35 ± 3.37 a”
Source · p. 8 “43.87 ± 3.19 ab”
Source · p. 8 “49.14 ± 4.91 ab”
Source · p. 8 “42.46 ± 1.09 ab”
Source · p. 8 “51.33 ± 1.17 ab”
Source · p. 8 “45.98 ± 2.73 ab”
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–10 cm · 2022, first three GHG samplings · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Matched glyphosate versus no-glyphosate comparisons within each CT, RT and NT background, with and without cover crops; all six pairs share Tukey letters. WFPS uses 0-10 cm VWC and arable-layer TP averaged from 5-10 and 15-20 cm. Glyphosate applied yearly before autumn tillage.
Numbers
- treatment 44.96 vs. control 43.87 % (+2.485 %) · CT, without cover crops: 1G versus 1
- treatment 41.05 vs. control 42.46 % (-3.321 %) · RT, without cover crops: 3G versus 3
- treatment 47.52 vs. control 45.98 % (+3.349 %) · NT, without cover crops: 5G versus 5
- treatment 48.64 vs. control 55.35 % (-12.12 %) · CT, with cover crops: 1TG versus 1T
- treatment 47.93 vs. control 49.14 % (-2.462 %) · RT, with cover crops: 3TG versus 3T
- treatment 48.22 vs. control 51.33 % (-6.059 %) · NT, with cover crops: 5TG versus 5T
Source · p. 12 “At the same time, glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
Source · p. 8 “44.96 ± 0.97 ab”
Source · p. 8 “43.87 ± 3.19 ab”
TP
↓ 1= 12
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Averaged5–10/15–20cm cores; eachG pair identicalTP within tillage/CC.
Source · p. 12 “glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
- decrease
NT vs. CTsignificant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · Average5–10/15–20cm;withCC,bothGvariants identical. NT0.40b vsCT0.44a.
Numbers
- treatment 0.4 vs. control 0.44 m3/m3 (-9.091 %)
Source · p. 8 “0.40 ± 0.005 b”
Source · p. 8 “0.44 ± 0.007 a”
WSA (1–0.25mm)
↑ 1= 12
- no effect
with glyphosate vs. without glyphosatenot significant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · 1–0.25mm water-stable aggregates; Gpairs identical within tillage/CC, exceptrounding78.21/78.2.
Source · p. 12 “glyphosate use did not influence soil physical properties significantly.”
- increase
NT vs. CTsignificant · 0–20 cm · spring2020/2021 · Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry · WithoutCC,bothGvariants identical.1–0.25mm waterstableaggregates:NTa vsCTb.
Numbers
- treatment 81.4 vs. control 69.63 % (+16.9 %)
Source · p. 8 “81.4 ± 2.92 a”
Source · p. 8 “69.63 ± 1.63 b”
Set-up
Treatments
- tillageTillage system
- CTConventional tillageNTZero tillageRTReduced tillageCT and RTTillage system
- cover crops
- Persian clover cover cropLegume cover cropwithout cover cropsNo cover crop
- glyphosateHerbicide
- with glyphosateHerbicidewithout glyphosateNo herbicide
Measured
- CO2 fluxCO2 flux/Carbon Dioxide flux
- Unit
- mg/m2/h
- Method
- closed static chamber, gas chromatography
- N2O fluxN2O/Nitrous oxide
- Unit
- µg/m2/h
- Method
- closed static chamber, gas chromatography
- CH4 fluxCH4 flux/Methane flux
- Unit
- µg/m2/h
- Method
- closed static chamber, gas chromatography
- GWPGlobal warming potential
- Unit
- kg CO2-equivalent/ha/year
- Method
- 100-year N2O298,CH425
- precipitation
- Unit
- mm
- BDBulk density
- Unit
- g/cm3
- Method
- oven-dried undisturbed cores
- VWCVolumetric water content
- Unit
- % vol
- Method
- FDR HH2 WET sensor
- pore ECElectrical conductivity
- Unit
- mS/m
- Method
- FDR HH2 WET sensor
- WFPSWater-filled pore space
- Unit
- %
- TPTotal porosity
- Unit
- m3/m3
- WSA (1–0.25mm)Water-stable macroaggregates
- Unit
- %
- Method
- N.Savinov
Sites
Institute of Agriculture, Lithuanian Research Centre for Agriculture and Forestry
- Location
- Central Lithuania55.40° N, 23.86° E
- Soil
- Cambisol (Endocalcari, Epihypogleyic) · WRB
- Land use
- five-member crop rotationArable land
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| site soil (baseline depth not stated) | loam | – | 7 pH | 1.4 % | – |
Similar papers
Agricultural Greenhouse Gas Fluxes Under Different Cover Crop Systems
Wang et al. · 2022 · Frontiers in Climate
8 shared concepts
5 findings1 site
Different responses of agroecosystem greenhouse gas emissions to tillage practices in a Chinese wheat–maize cropping system
Li et al. · 2023 · Carbon Research
9 shared concepts
18 findings1 site
Long-term interactions of reduced tillage and different amounts of residue retaining improved soil environment in a semi-arid tropical climate
Zhong & Zeng · 2020 · Chilean journal of agricultural research
9 shared concepts
29 findings1 site
On-Farm Assessment of No-Till Onion Production and Cover Crop Effects on Soil Physical and Chemical Properties and Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Câmara et al. · 2026 · Agronomy
9 shared concepts
35 findings1 site
Effects of cover crops on soil hydraulic properties and yield in a persimmon orchard
Demir & Işık · 2019 · Bragantia
7 shared concepts
12 findings1 site
