Water shortages and rainfall variability lead to a decrease in grain yield. Straw mulching (SM), subsoiling (S), and combined amendments (subsoiling + straw mulching, SS) are potential solutions for maintaining crop productivity and water resource sustainability. However, short- and long-term applications of these methods appear to result in different yield and water use efficiency outcomes. In this study, we, therefore, compared short- and long-term applications of SM, S, and SS, with a control. We analyzed field experimental data of wheat and maize cultivation with control (conventional tillage), SM, S, and SS treatments to assess the impact on yield and water use efficiency, resulting from short- and long-term applications of these practices. The results show that SS treatment led to higher soil water storage (SWS) compared with other treatments during the regreening, jointing, and booting stages of wheat, and the big bellmouth and filling stages of maize in the short- and long-term experiments. However, long-term SS treatment also led to higher SWS in the growth stage of wheat in 2015–2016 and in the growth stage of maize in 2015. Additionally, SS treatment was conducive to raising the net photosynthetic rate (Pn) and leaf water use efficiency (LWUE) of wheat compared with other treatments in 2015 and 2016. Conversely, Pn and LWUE of maize under S and SS treatments were higher ( P < 0.05) compared with other treatments in the two studied years. Short-term treatment led to higher wheat yield compared with long term in 2014–2015 (ample rainfall) and of maize in 2016 (low rainfall). The yield of wheat under long-term S treatment in 2015 was 9625.-kg hm −2 , which was the highest ( P < 0.05) in 2 years, with a 17.7% increase compared with the control, followed by short-term S treatment. However, the water use efficiency (WUE) of wheat under long-term SS treatment in 2016 was the highest ( P < 0.05) compared with other treatments. The yield of maize under SM and S treatments was higher than other treatments, whereas the WUE of maize under long-term SS treatment in 2016 was still the highest ( P < 0.05). Our findings provide evidence that S and SS treatments improve both crop productivity and water resource sustainability, and long-term application resulted in higher productivity than short-term application.
Show all
Water shortages and rainfall variability lead to a decrease in grain yield. Straw mulching (SM), subsoiling (S), and combined amendments (subsoiling + straw mulching, SS) are potential solutions for maintaining crop productivity and water resource sustainability. However, short- and long-term applications of these methods appear to result in different yield and water use efficiency outcomes. In this study, we, therefore, compared short- and long-term applications of SM, S, and SS, with a control. We analyzed field experimental data of wheat and maize cultivation with control (conventional tillage), SM, S, and SS treatments to assess the impact on yield and water use efficiency, resulting from short- and long-term applications of these practices. The results show that SS treatment led to higher soil water storage (SWS) compared with other treatments during the regreening, jointing, and booting stages of wheat, and the big bellmouth and filling stages of maize in the short- and long-term experiments. However, long-term SS treatment also led to higher SWS in the growth stage of wheat in 2015–2016 and in the growth stage of maize in 2015. Additionally, SS treatment was conducive to raising the net photosynthetic rate (Pn) and leaf water use efficiency (LWUE) of wheat compared with other treatments in 2015 and 2016. Conversely, Pn and LWUE of maize under S and SS treatments were higher ( P < 0.05) compared with other treatments in the two studied years. Short-term treatment led to higher wheat yield compared with long term in 2014–2015 (ample rainfall) and of maize in 2016 (low rainfall). The yield of wheat under long-term S treatment in 2015 was 9625.-kg hm −2 , which was the highest ( P < 0.05) in 2 years, with a 17.7% increase compared with the control, followed by short-term S treatment. However, the water use efficiency (WUE) of wheat under long-term SS treatment in 2016 was the highest ( P < 0.05) compared with other treatments. The yield of maize under SM and S treatments was higher than other treatments, whereas the WUE of maize under long-term SS treatment in 2016 was still the highest ( P < 0.05). Our findings provide evidence that S and SS treatments improve both crop productivity and water resource sustainability, and long-term application resulted in higher productivity than short-term application.
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
SWS wheat
↑ 22
↑increase
SS subsoiling plus straw mulching vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 0–100 cm · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Regreening and booting stages,2014–2015 and2015–2016,both short/long experiments;Fig3 distinct LSD letters. Not allstages.
Source · p. 6
“the SWS under long-term SS treatment, ranging from 102.3 to 238.7 mm, was higher than that of other treatments.”
Source · p. 6
“it was a large degree higher under SS treatment in the short-term experiment compared with other treatments.”
↑increase
SS long-term vs. SS short-termsignificant · 0–100 cm · 2015-2016 wheat season · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Long-term2006-2016 versus short-term2014-2016 SS, subsoiling plus straw mulching; regreening, jointing, filling and harvest stages only; Fig3B disjoint LSD0.05 letters. Other stages with shared letters excluded.
Source · p. 6
“the SWS of each treatment in the long-term experiment was higher than that in the short-term experiment, especially under the SS treatment.”
Source · p. 6
“the SWS under long-term SS treatment, ranging from 102.3 to 238.7 mm, was higher than that of other treatments.”
SWS maize
↑ 22
↑increase
SS subsoiling plus straw mulching vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 0–100 cm · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Big bellmouth and filling,2015/2016,both short/long;Fig4 distinct LSD letters versus matchedcontrol
Source · p. 6
“the SWS under SS treatment of the two experiments was still higher during the various growth stages of maize.”
↑increase
SS long-term
wheat yield
↑ 12
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 · Yuzhou Experimental Station · SM/S/SS,bothterms;Table4 distinct lowercase letters versus owncontrol.
Numbers
treatment 8,028 vs. control 7,593 kg/ha (+5.732 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 8,704 vs. control 7,593 kg/ha (+14.63 %) · ST2015S
treatment 8,167 vs. control 7,593 kg/ha (+7.561 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 8,583 vs. control 8,181 kg/ha (+4.923 %) · LT2015SM
treatment 9,625 vs. control 8,181 kg/ha (+17.66 %) · LT2015S
treatment 8,458 vs. control 8,181 kg/ha (+3.395 %) · LT2015SS
treatment 5,243 vs. control 4,826 kg/ha (+8.634 %)
maize yield
↑ 12
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 · Yuzhou Experimental Station · SM/S/SS,bothterms;Table5 letters versus owncontrol
Numbers
treatment 7,182 vs. control 6,485 kg/ha (+10.76 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 7,466 vs. control 6,485 kg/ha (+15.14 %) · ST2015S
treatment 7,534 vs. control 6,485 kg/ha (+16.18 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 7,593 vs. control 6,902 kg/ha (+10.01 %) · LT2015SM
treatment 7,838 vs. control 6,902 kg/ha (+13.56 %) · LT2015S
treatment 7,727 vs. control 6,902 kg/ha (+11.95 %) · LT2015SS
treatment 5,218 vs. control 4,443 kg/ha (+17.44 %)
wheat WUE
↑ 12
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Table4:2015shortall,longSonly;2016allvariantsbothterms. LT2015SM/SS shareletters withcontrol andexcluded.
Numbers
treatment 19.2 vs. control 17.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+9.714 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 20.4 vs. control 17.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+16.57 %) · ST2015S
treatment 20.9 vs. control 17.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+19.43 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 20.8 vs. control 18.3 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+13.66 %) · LT2015S
treatment 20.1 vs. control 19.7 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+2.03 %) · ST2016SM
treatment 20.9 vs. control 19.7 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+6.091 %) · ST2016S
maize WUE
↑ 12
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Table5:2015SM/S/SSbothterms,2016SM/SSbothterms,Slongonly;ST2016S15.1c/control14.5c excluded
Numbers
treatment 20.8 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+8.901 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 21.5 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.57 %) · ST2015S
treatment 20.5 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+7.33 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 21.6 vs. control 20.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+6.931 %) · LT2015SM
treatment 21.3 vs. control 20.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+5.446 %) · LT2015S
treatment 22.7 vs. control 20.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.38 %) · LT2015SS
annual total yield wheat and maize
↑ 22
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015/2016,bothterms,allSM/S/SS;Table6 lower-case letters versuscontrol;pooled agreeing individuallytested variants
Numbers
treatment 15,210 vs. control 14,080 kg/ha (+8.048 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 16,170 vs. control 14,080 kg/ha (+14.87 %) · ST2015S
treatment 15,700 vs. control 14,080 kg/ha (+11.53 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 16,180 vs. control 15,080 kg/ha (+7.249 %) · LT2015SM
treatment 17,460 vs. control 15,080 kg/ha (+15.78 %) · LT2015S
treatment 16,180 vs. control 15,080 kg/ha (+7.308 %) · LT2015SS
annual total WUE
↑ 22
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015/2016,bothterms,allSM/S/SS;Table6 lower-case letters versuscontrol
Numbers
treatment 19.9 vs. control 18.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+9.341 %) · ST2015SM
treatment 20.9 vs. control 18.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+14.84 %) · ST2015S
treatment 20.7 vs. control 18.2 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+13.74 %) · ST2015SS
treatment 19.9 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+4.188 %) · LT2015SM
treatment 21 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+9.948 %) · LT2015S
treatment 19.9 vs. control 19.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+4.188 %) · LT2015SS
wheat whole-season water consumption
↑ 1↓ 12
↓decrease
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 wheat seasons · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Whole-season wheat water consumption:2015short-term SM/S/SS and2016long-term SS; within-duration Table4 LSD0.05. Agreeing practice variants merged; shared-letter pairs excluded.
Numbers
treatment 418.1 vs. control 433.4 mm (-3.53 %) · 2015ST SM/control
treatment 426.1 vs. control 433.4 mm (-1.684 %) · 2015ST S/control
treatment 389.8 vs. control 433.4 mm (-10.06 %) · 2015ST SS/control
treatment 247.4 vs. control 256.1 mm (-3.397 %)
maize whole-season water consumption
↑ 1↓ 12
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 maize seasons · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Whole-season maize water consumption:2015short-term SS,long-term SM/S;2016short-term S. Table5 LSD0.05 disjoint within-duration letters; other dates/variants excluded.
Numbers
treatment 367.4 vs. control 340 mm (+8.059 %) · 2015ST SS/control
treatment 350.8 vs. control 341.5 mm (+2.723 %) · 2015LT SM/control
treatment 368.7 vs. control 341.5 mm (+7.965 %) · 2015LT S/control
treatment 358.8 vs. control 305.7 mm (+17.37 %) · 2016ST S/control
annual total water consumption of wheat and maize
↑ 1↓ 12
↓decrease
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 annual totals · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015short-term SM/SS and2016long-term SM/S/SS,versus duration/year-matchedcontrol. Table6 lowercase LSD0.05 letters; annual totals copied as printed, not summed.
Numbers
treatment 762.6 vs. control 773.4 mm (-1.396 %) · 2015ST SM/control
treatment 757.2 vs. control 773.4 mm (-2.095 %) · 2015ST SS/control
treatment 566.1 vs. control 575.8 mm (-1.685 %) · 2016LT SM/control
treatment 561.4 vs. control 575.8 mm (-2.501 %)
wheat Pn
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015/2016 stages Table2: SS all12;SM all exceptLT2016jointing;S all exceptST2016booting/filling. LSD.05 versus matchedcontrol. Variants merged, no across-year test.
Numbers
treatment 8.11 vs. control 6.37 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+27.32 %) · ST2015SMjoint
treatment 19.76 vs. control 12.21 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+61.83 %) · ST2015SMheading
treatment 16.06 vs. control 12.85 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+24.98 %) · ST2015SMfill
treatment 7.05 vs. control 6.37 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+10.68 %) · ST2015Sjoint
treatment 14.43 vs. control 12.21 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+18.18 %) · ST2015Sheading
maize Pn
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015bigbellmouth/filling,2016filling,both terms;allS/SS;SM exceptLT2015filling/ST2016filling. Table3 LSD.05.
Numbers
treatment 39.02 vs. control 35.42 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+10.16 %) · ST2015SMBB
treatment 22.83 vs. control 20.41 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+11.86 %) · ST2015SMfill
treatment 40.6 vs. control 35.42 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+14.62 %) · ST2015SBB
treatment 23.41 vs. control 20.41 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+14.7 %) · ST2015Sfill
treatment 42.01 vs. control 35.42 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+18.61 %) · ST2015SSBB
treatment 21.42 vs. control 20.41 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+4.949 %)
wheat LWUE
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Table2 LSD.05:2015ST jointSM/SS,headingall;2015LT jointS/SS,heading/fillingall;2016ST joint/fillSM,bootS;2016LT bootSS,fillall. Same-letter exceptions excluded.
Numbers
treatment 8.3 vs. control 7.65 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+8.497 %) · ST2015SMjoint
treatment 10 vs. control 7.65 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+30.72 %) · ST2015SSjoint
treatment 6.66 vs. control 5.81 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+14.63 %) · ST2015SMheading
treatment 6.13 vs. control 5.81 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+5.508 %) · ST2015Sheading
treatment 6.2 vs. control 5.81 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+6.713 %) · ST2015SSheading
maize LWUE
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Table3 LSD.05:2015ST bigbellmouthSM/S,fillSM/SS;2015LT bigbellmouthS,fillall;2016fillingallbothterms. Short2015SSbigbellmouth and Sfill nulls excluded;LT2015SSbigbellmouth decrease separate.
Numbers
treatment 6.5 vs. control 5.93 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+9.612 %) · ST2015SMBB
treatment 6.3 vs. control 5.93 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+6.239 %) · ST2015SBB
treatment 7.04 vs. control 6.44 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+9.317 %) · ST2015SMfill
treatment 7 vs. control 6.44 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+8.696 %) · ST2015SSfill
treatment 9 vs. control 7.69 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+17.04 %) · LT2015SBB
wheat aboveground biomass
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Harvest2015allvariantsbothterms;2016SM/SSbothterms,Sshortonly;Fig7A LSDletters versus matchedcontrol;LT2016S e/control e excluded.
Source · p. 10
“the biomass under control was lower than that under other treatments in the short-term experiment.”
Source · p. 11
“At the filling and harvest stages, the biomass under the S treatment in two experiments was higher than other treatments, while that under the control was the lowest.”
Source · p. 17
“promoted dry matter accumulation”
maize aboveground biomass
↑ 11
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Harvest2015SSshort,S/SSlong;2016allvariantsbothterms;Fig7B distinctletters versus matchedcontrol;2015SMshortcd/Sshortd sharecontrolshortcd;SMlongcd sharescontrollongc,excluded
Source · p. 11
“In 2015, the biomass of the SS treatment was the highest, followed by the S and SM treatments, and the control treatment had the lowest biomass in the different periods of short- and long-term experiments.”
Source · p. 11
“The biomass in two experiments of SS treatment was the highest compared with other treatments, followed by the SM treatment except the big bellmouth stage.”
significant · 0–100 cm · 2015 maize season · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Long-term2006-2016 versus short-term2014-2016 SS; big-bellmouth, filling and harvest stages. Original Fig4A longSS a versus shortSS b/c/c, LSD0.05. No chart-derived means.
Source · p. 6
“During the whole stage, long-term SM, S, and SS treatments led to higher SWS compared with the respective short-term treatments”
· ST2016SM
treatment 5,104 vs. control 4,826 kg/ha (+5.756 %) · ST2016S
treatment 5,618 vs. control 4,826 kg/ha (+16.4 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 7,351 vs. control 6,910 kg/ha (+6.392 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 7,604 vs. control 6,910 kg/ha (+10.05 %) · LT2016S
treatment 7,743 vs. control 6,910 kg/ha (+12.06 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 17
“increased yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
Source · p. 14
“In both experiments, the yield under the S treatment was the highest, which was 14.6 and 17.7% higher than that under the control, respectively.”
↑increase
long-term soil conservation measures vs. short-term soil conservation measuressignificance not stated · 2015 and2016 wheat harvest · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Matching SM, S and SS in long-term2006-2016 versus short-term2014-2016 parallel experiments. Table4 letters do not unambiguously provide a duration-pair test; no annual-total Table6 alpha transferred.
Numbers
treatment 8,583 vs. control 8,028 kg/ha (+6.92 %) · 2015SM,long/short
treatment 9,625 vs. control 8,704 kg/ha (+10.59 %) · 2015S,long/short
treatment 8,458 vs. control 8,167 kg/ha (+3.571 %) · 2015SS,long/short
treatment 7,351 vs. control 5,243 kg/ha (+40.21 %) · 2016SM,long/short
treatment 7,604 vs. control 5,104 kg/ha (+48.98 %) · 2016S,long/short
treatment 7,743 vs. control 5,618 kg/ha (+37.82 %) · 2016SS,long/short
Source · p. 14
“The yield under each treatment in the long-term experiment was higher than that in the short-term experiment”
Source · p. 14
“The yield and WUE of each treatment in the long-term experiment were higher than those in the short-term experiment.”
· ST2016SM
treatment 5,404 vs. control 4,443 kg/ha (+21.64 %) · ST2016S
treatment 6,066 vs. control 4,443 kg/ha (+36.53 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 6,812 vs. control 5,928 kg/ha (+14.91 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 6,963 vs. control 5,928 kg/ha (+17.45 %) · LT2016S
treatment 7,154 vs. control 5,928 kg/ha (+20.68 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 17
“increased yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
Source · p. 14
“the effect of the SS treatment on increasing yield and saving water was better than other treatments.”
↑increase
long-term soil conservation measures vs. short-term soil conservation measuressignificance not stated · 2015 and2016 maize harvest · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Matching SM, S and SS, long-term2006-2016 versus short-term2014-2016 parallel experiments. Crop-specific duration test not unambiguously shown; no Table6 annual-total alpha transferred.
Numbers
treatment 7,593 vs. control 7,182 kg/ha (+5.717 %) · 2015SM,long/short
treatment 7,838 vs. control 7,466 kg/ha (+4.977 %) · 2015S,long/short
treatment 7,727 vs. control 7,534 kg/ha (+2.56 %) · 2015SS,long/short
treatment 6,812 vs. control 5,218 kg/ha (+30.55 %) · 2016SM,long/short
treatment 6,963 vs. control 5,404 kg/ha (+28.83 %) · 2016S,long/short
treatment 7,154 vs. control 6,066 kg/ha (+17.94 %) · 2016SS,long/short
Source · p. 14
“Compared with the short-term experiment, the 100-grain weight, yield, and WUE in the long-term experiment were higher.”
Source · p. 17
“Long-term applications of the same measure were more beneficial for improving the yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
treatment 22.1 vs. control 19.7 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.18 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 29.1 vs. control 27 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+7.778 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 30.3 vs. control 27 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.22 %) · LT2016S
treatment 31.3 vs. control 27 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+15.93 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 14
“In the short-term experiment, the water use efficiency (WUE) under the SM, S, and SS treatments was 9.7, 16.6, and 19.4% higher than that under the control, respectively.”
Source · p. 14
“the yield and WUE under the SS treatment were the highest, which were 12.1 and 15.9% higher than those under the control, respectively.”
↑increase
long-term soil conservation measures vs. short-term soil conservation measuressignificance not stated · 2016 wheat harvest · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Matching SM,S,SS long-term2006-2016 versus short-term2014-2016. Duration pair significance not unambiguously shown in Table4; annual WUE test not substituted.
Numbers
treatment 29.1 vs. control 20.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+44.78 %) · SM,long/short
treatment 30.3 vs. control 20.9 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+44.98 %) · S,long/short
treatment 31.3 vs. control 22.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+41.63 %) · SS,long/short
Source · p. 14
“The yield and WUE of each treatment in the long-term experiment were higher than those in the short-term experiment.”
treatment 17.7 vs. control 14.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+22.07 %) · ST2016SM
treatment 19.7 vs. control 14.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+35.86 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 21.7 vs. control 18.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+17.3 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 22.4 vs. control 18.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+21.08 %) · LT2016S
treatment 24.5 vs. control 18.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+32.43 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 17
“The yield and WUE of maize of the short-term and long-term SS treatments were all higher than those of other treatments in two experiments”
Source · p. 17
“the yield and WUE of the SS treatment were still the highest, at 23.3 and 32.4% higher than that of the control, respectively.”
↑increase
long-term soil conservation measures vs. short-term soil conservation measuressignificance not stated · 2015 and2016 maize harvest · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Matching SM/SS in2015 andSM/S/SS in2016 long-term versus short-term.2015S has opposite numerical direction and is excluded as an isolated exception. Crop-specific duration-pair significance not unambiguously shown.
Numbers
treatment 21.6 vs. control 20.8 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+3.846 %) · 2015SM,long/short
treatment 22.7 vs. control 20.5 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+10.73 %) · 2015SS,long/short
treatment 21.7 vs. control 17.7 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+22.6 %) · 2016SM,long/short
treatment 22.4 vs. control 15.1 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+48.34 %) · 2016S,long/short
treatment 24.5 vs. control 19.7 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+24.37 %) · 2016SS,long/short
Source · p. 14
“Compared with the short-term experiment, the 100-grain weight, yield, and WUE in the long-term experiment were higher.”
Source · p. 17
“Long-term applications of the same measure were more beneficial for improving the yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
treatment 10,460 vs. control 9,269 kg/ha (+12.86 %) · ST2016SM
treatment 10,510 vs. control 9,269 kg/ha (+13.37 %) · ST2016S
treatment 11,680 vs. control 9,269 kg/ha (+26.05 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 14,160 vs. control 12,840 kg/ha (+10.33 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 14,570 vs. control 12,840 kg/ha (+13.47 %) · LT2016S
treatment 14,900 vs. control 12,840 kg/ha (+16.04 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 14
“in 2015, the annual total yield of wheat and maize under the S treatment was the highest, while, in 2016, the SS treatment in the short-term experiment showed the highest total yield compared with the other treatments”
Source · p. 17
“promoted dry matter accumulation, which increased yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
treatment 16,180 vs. control 15,210 kg/ha (+6.352 %) · 2015SMlong/short
treatment 16,180 vs. control 15,700 kg/ha (+3.086 %) · 2015SSlong/short
treatment 14,160 vs. control 10,460 kg/ha (+35.39 %) · 2016SMlong/short
treatment 14,570 vs. control 10,510 kg/ha (+38.62 %) · 2016Slong/short
treatment 14,900 vs. control 11,680 kg/ha (+27.5 %) · 2016SSlong/short
Source · p. 17
“Long-term applications of the same measure were more beneficial for improving the yield and WUE of wheat and maize.”
Source · p. 8
“Control 14077.0dB 15082.7cA 9269.2cB 12837.7bA”
Source · p. 8
“SM 15209.9cB 16176.0bA 10461.0bB 14163.3aA”
Source · p. 8
“SS 15700.4bB 16184.9bA 11684.2aB 14897.2aA”
treatment 18.9 vs. control 16.8 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.5 %) · ST2016SM
treatment 19.9 vs. control 16.8 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+18.45 %) · ST2016S
treatment 20.8 vs. control 16.8 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+23.81 %) · ST2016SS
treatment 25 vs. control 22.3 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+12.11 %) · LT2016SM
treatment 25.9 vs. control 22.3 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+16.14 %) · LT2016S
treatment 27.6 vs. control 22.3 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+23.77 %) · LT2016SS
Source · p. 17
“The annual total WUE of these two scenarios was much higher than that of other scenarios, at 24.4 and 23.8% higher than that of the control, respectively.”
↑increase
long-term soil conservation measures vs. short-term soil conservation measuressignificant · 2016 · Yuzhou Experimental Station · matchedSM/S/SS;Table6 uppercaseA/B;bothdurations measuredsameyear
Numbers
treatment 25 vs. control 18.9 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+32.28 %) · 2016SMlong/short
treatment 25.9 vs. control 19.9 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+30.15 %) · 2016Slong/short
treatment 27.6 vs. control 20.8 kg mm-1 ha-1 (+32.69 %) · 2016SSlong/short
Source · p. 14
“The annual total WUE in the long-term treatments in 2016 was higher than the short-term treatments”
· 2016LT SS/control
Source · p. 7
“the water consumption of the short-term experiment was lower than that of the control.”
Source · p. 14
“the total water consumption of wheat under the SS treatment was decreased by 10.1, 6.8, and 8.5% compared with the control, SM, and S treatments, respectively.”
↑increase
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 wheat seasons · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Whole-season water consumption:2015long-term SM/S/SS;2016short-term SM. Table4 within-duration disjoint LSD0.05 letters.2016ST SS ab/control b excluded.
Numbers
treatment 461.1 vs. control 448.1 mm (+2.901 %) · 2015LT SM/control
treatment 461.8 vs. control 448.1 mm (+3.057 %) · 2015LT S/control
treatment 473.3 vs. control 448.1 mm (+5.624 %) · 2015LT SS/control
treatment 260.7 vs. control 244.7 mm (+6.539 %) · 2016ST SM/control
Source · p. 7
“the water consumption of different measures in the long-term experiment was higher than that of the control”
Source · p. 14
“In the short-term experiment, the total water consumption under the SM and SS treatments was higher than that under control.”
Source · p. 7
“The total water consumption of maize with the SS treatment in the short-term experiment and the S and SM treatments in the long-term experiment during the whole growth period were higher than that of other treatments.”
Source · p. 10
“The total water consumption of the short-term S treatment was the highest compared with that of other treatments in both experiments”
↓decrease
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2016 maize season · Yuzhou Experimental Station · Whole-season maize water consumption:short-term SM andlong-term S/SS,Table5 disjoint LSD0.05 letters. Short-term SM literal printed water mean is294. with c; recorded294, no digit supplied. Long-term SM ab/control a excluded.
Numbers
treatment 294 vs. control 305.7 mm (-3.827 %) · 2016ST SM/control; printed294.c
treatment 310.4 vs. control 319.7 mm (-2.909 %) · 2016LT S/control
treatment 291.6 vs. control 319.7 mm (-8.789 %) · 2016LT SS/control
Source · p. 10
“the long-term SS treatment had the lowest water consumption.”
Source · p. 14
“its water consumption was the lowest, but the yield was higher.”
Source · p. 8
“24.0b | 294.c | 5217.9c”
· 2016LT S/control
treatment 539 vs. control 575.8 mm (-6.391 %) · 2016LT SS/control
SM, S and SS, agreeing soil-conservation variants vs. Control, conventional tillagesignificant · 2015 and2016 annual totals · Yuzhou Experimental Station · 2015long-term SM/S/SS and2016short-term S,versus duration/year-matchedcontrol. Table6 lowercase LSD0.05 letters; no annual totals computed.
Numbers
treatment 811.9 vs. control 789.6 mm (+2.824 %) · 2015LT SM/control
treatment 830.6 vs. control 789.6 mm (+5.193 %) · 2015LT S/control
treatment 814 vs. control 789.6 mm (+3.09 %) · 2015LT SS/control
treatment 603.2 vs. control 550.4 mm (+9.593 %) · 2016ST S/control
Source · p. 14
“the annual total water consumption under the S treatment in the two experiments in 2015 and in the short-term experiment in 2016 was higher than that under other treatments.”
treatment 14.21 vs. control 12.85 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+10.58 %) · ST2015Sfill
treatment 8.57 vs. control 6.37 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+34.54 %) · ST2015SSjoint
treatment 14.53 vs. control 12.21 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+19 %) · ST2015SSheading
treatment 13.85 vs. control 12.85 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+7.782 %) · ST2015SSfill
treatment 9.62 vs. control 8.22 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+17.03 %) · LT2015SMjoint
treatment 15.57 vs. control 10.52 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+48 %) · LT2015SMheading
treatment 12.92 vs. control 11.6 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+11.38 %) · LT2015SMfill
treatment 10.4 vs. control 8.22 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+26.52 %) · LT2015Sjoint
treatment 14.16 vs. control 10.52 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+34.6 %) · LT2015Sheading
treatment 13.32 vs. control 11.6 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+14.83 %) · LT2015Sfill
treatment 10.34 vs. control 8.22 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+25.79 %) · LT2015SSjoint
treatment 15.61 vs. control 10.52 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+48.38 %) · LT2015SSheading
treatment 18.21 vs. control 11.6 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+56.98 %) · LT2015SSfill
treatment 8.68 vs. control 7.73 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+12.29 %) · ST2016SMjoint
treatment 9.02 vs. control 8.22 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+9.732 %) · ST2016SMboot
treatment 11.36 vs. control 8.31 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+36.7 %) · ST2016SMfill
treatment 9.95 vs. control 7.73 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+28.72 %) · ST2016Sjoint
treatment 9.8 vs. control 7.73 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+26.78 %) · ST2016SSjoint
treatment 9.2 vs. control 8.22 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+11.92 %) · ST2016SSboot
treatment 12.54 vs. control 8.31 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+50.9 %) · ST2016SSfill
treatment 12.45 vs. control 9.97 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+24.87 %) · LT2016SMboot
treatment 10.27 vs. control 9.03 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+13.73 %) · LT2016SMfill
treatment 10 vs. control 8.44 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+18.48 %) · LT2016Sjoint
treatment 12.47 vs. control 9.97 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+25.08 %) · LT2016Sboot
treatment 12.86 vs. control 9.03 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+42.41 %) · LT2016Sfill
treatment 9.5 vs. control 8.44 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+12.56 %) · LT2016SSjoint
treatment 11.44 vs. control 9.97 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+14.74 %) · LT2016SSboot
treatment 13.59 vs. control 9.03 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+50.5 %) · LT2016SSfill
Source · p. 13
“was more beneficial in increasing the Pn of wheat, while the SS treatment showed the highest Pn in the long-term experiment in the whole stage of wheat.”
Source · p. 17
“The short- and long-term applications of the SM, S, and SS treatments improved the photosynthetic characteristics of wheat and maize”
· ST2015SSfill
treatment 35.99 vs. control 34.31 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+4.897 %) · LT2015SMBB
treatment 35.49 vs. control 34.31 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+3.439 %) · LT2015SBB
treatment 22.54 vs. control 19.84 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+13.61 %) · LT2015Sfill
treatment 35.75 vs. control 34.31 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+4.197 %) · LT2015SSBB
treatment 23.28 vs. control 19.84 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+17.34 %) · LT2015SSfill
treatment 17.52 vs. control 16.63 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+5.352 %) · ST2016Sfill
treatment 19.22 vs. control 16.63 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+15.57 %) · ST2016SSfill
treatment 18.11 vs. control 16.98 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+6.655 %) · LT2016SMfill
treatment 17.89 vs. control 16.98 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+5.359 %) · LT2016Sfill
treatment 21.49 vs. control 16.98 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+26.56 %) · LT2016SSfill
Source · p. 13
“In the short- and long-term experiments, different measures increased the Pn of maize.”
treatment 7.08 vs. control 5.72 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+23.78 %) · LT2015Sjoint
treatment 6.53 vs. control 5.72 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+14.16 %) · LT2015SSjoint
treatment 7.34 vs. control 3.77 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+94.69 %) · LT2015SMheading
treatment 6.22 vs. control 3.77 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+64.99 %) · LT2015Sheading
treatment 6.91 vs. control 3.77 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+83.29 %) · LT2015SSheading
treatment 3.84 vs. control 2.97 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+29.29 %) · LT2015SMfill
treatment 3.88 vs. control 2.97 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+30.64 %) · LT2015Sfill
treatment 4.49 vs. control 2.97 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+51.18 %) · LT2015SSfill
treatment 4.64 vs. control 4.12 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+12.62 %) · ST2016SMjoint
treatment 4.7 vs. control 4.39 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+7.062 %) · ST2016Sboot
treatment 4.96 vs. control 4.41 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+12.47 %) · ST2016SMfill
treatment 4.9 vs. control 4.01 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+22.19 %) · LT2016SSboot
treatment 7.99 vs. control 5.38 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+48.51 %) · LT2016SMfill
treatment 10.2 vs. control 5.38 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+89.59 %) · LT2016Sfill
treatment 11.02 vs. control 5.38 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+104.8 %) · LT2016SSfill
Source · p. 13
“LWUE under the S treatment at the jointing stage and under the SS treatment at the filing stage in the long-term experiment was significantly higher than that in the other treatments at these two stages.”
Source · p. 13
“In the short-term experiment, the LWUE under the SM treatment was higher than that under other treatments.”
treatment 7.01 vs. control 6.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+2.485 %) · LT2015SMfill
treatment 7.06 vs. control 6.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+3.216 %) · LT2015Sfill
treatment 7.06 vs. control 6.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+3.216 %) · LT2015SSfill
treatment 6.14 vs. control 5.58 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+10.04 %) · ST2016SMfill
treatment 6.23 vs. control 5.58 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+11.65 %) · ST2016Sfill
treatment 6.86 vs. control 5.58 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+22.94 %) · ST2016SSfill
treatment 6.04 vs. control 5.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+3.425 %) · LT2016SMfill
treatment 7.07 vs. control 5.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+21.06 %) · LT2016Sfill
treatment 8.77 vs. control 5.84 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+50.17 %) · LT2016SSfill
Source · p. 13
“The SM, S, and SS treatments all increased LWUE clearly at the big bellmouth stage in the short-term experiment and at the filling stage in the long-term experiment”