European Journal of Soil Science · 2020
Tillage and cropping effects on soil organic carbon: Biodegradation and storage in density and size fractions
Zhang, Y., Li, X., Gregorich, E., McLaughlin, N., Zhang, X., Guo, Y., Gao, Y., Liang, A.
Export
Tillage and cropping effects on soil organic carbon: Biodegr…
Abstract
Improvements in management practices can prevent the decline of soil organic carbon (SOC) storage caused by conventional tillage practice in Northeast China. Density and size fractionation can track the transformation of plant residue into SOC and its location in the soil matrix. We used a long‐term field study in China to evaluate these changes as a result of improved management involving tillage and cropping systems. Experimental treatments included no‐till (NT) and mouldboard ploughing (MP) under monoculture maize ( Zea mays L.) (MM) and maize‐soybean ( Glycine max Merr.) rotation (MS); these were compared to the traditional management involving conventional tillage (CT) under MM. An incubation study was conducted to evaluate mineralization and the biodegradability of SOC. The soils were also physically fractionated by density (light fraction, LF) and size (sand, silt and clay). With improved management, the SOC storage in the clay size fraction showed the largest increase across all fractions. This increase was greater for MS than MM. The NTMS treatment resulted in a decline in silt‐OC storage compared to CTMM. The SOC mineralization (mg CO 2 ‐C g −1 soil) was affected by tillage and driven by LF‐OC and was observed in the order: NTMM (2.06) > MPMM (1.72) ≈ NTMS (1.71) > CTMM (1.52) ≈ MPMS (1.41). Both cropping and depth affected the biodegradability of SOC. Considering the plough layer (0–20 cm), treatments under MM had a larger proportion of biodegradable SOC than those under MS. We conclude that the significant differences in SOC storage in physical fractions and SOC biodegradation were caused by differences in soil management. Highlights Clay size fraction showed the largest increase in SOC storage when residue was returned. Silt size fraction lost SOC in no‐till maize‐soybean compared with traditional farming practice. Potential SOC mineralization depended on quantity of SOC in the LF. Biodegradability of the SOC was driven by cropping system not tillage.
Show all
Improvements in management practices can prevent the decline of soil organic carbon (SOC) storage caused by conventional tillage practice in Northeast China. Density and size fractionation can track the transformation of plant residue into SOC and its location in the soil matrix. We used a long‐term field study in China to evaluate these changes as a result of improved management involving tillage and cropping systems. Experimental treatments included no‐till (NT) and mouldboard ploughing (MP) under monoculture maize ( Zea mays L.) (MM) and maize‐soybean ( Glycine max Merr.) rotation (MS); these were compared to the traditional management involving conventional tillage (CT) under MM. An incubation study was conducted to evaluate mineralization and the biodegradability of SOC. The soils were also physically fractionated by density (light fraction, LF) and size (sand, silt and clay). With improved management, the SOC storage in the clay size fraction showed the largest increase across all fractions. This increase was greater for MS than MM. The NTMS treatment resulted in a decline in silt‐OC storage compared to CTMM. The SOC mineralization (mg CO 2 ‐C g −1 soil) was affected by tillage and driven by LF‐OC and was observed in the order: NTMM (2.06) > MPMM (1.72) ≈ NTMS (1.71) > CTMM (1.52) ≈ MPMS (1.41). Both cropping and depth affected the biodegradability of SOC. Considering the plough layer (0–20 cm), treatments under MM had a larger proportion of biodegradable SOC than those under MS. We conclude that the significant differences in SOC storage in physical fractions and SOC biodegradation were caused by differences in soil management. Highlights Clay size fraction showed the largest increase in SOC storage when residue was returned. Silt size fraction lost SOC in no‐till maize‐soybean compared with traditional farming practice. Potential SOC mineralization depended on quantity of SOC in the LF. Biodegradability of the SOC was driven by cropping system not tillage.
Improvements in management practices can prevent the decline of soil organic carbon (SOC) storage caused by conventional tillage practice in Northeast China. Density and size fractionation can track the transformation of plant residue into SOC and its location in the soil matrix. We used a long‐term field study in China to evaluate these changes as a result of improved management involving tillage and cropping systems. Experimental treatments included no‐till (NT) and mouldboard ploughing (MP) under monoculture maize ( Zea mays L.) (MM) and maize‐soybean ( Glycine max Merr.) rotation (MS); these were compared to the traditional management involving conventional tillage (CT) under MM. An incubation study was conducted to evaluate mineralization and the biodegradability of SOC. The soils were also physically fractionated by density (light fraction, LF) and size (sand, silt and clay). With improved management, the SOC storage in the clay size fraction showed the largest increase across all fractions. This increase was greater for MS than MM. The NTMS treatment resulted in a decline in silt‐OC storage compared to CTMM. The SOC mineralization (mg CO 2 ‐C g −1 soil) was affected by tillage and driven by LF‐OC and was observed in the order: NTMM (2.06) > MPMM (1.72) ≈ NTMS (1.71) > CTMM (1.52) ≈ MPMS (1.41). Both cropping and depth affected the biodegradability of SOC. Considering the plough layer (0–20 cm), treatments under MM had a larger proportion of biodegradable SOC than those under MS. We conclude that the significant differences in SOC storage in physical fractions and SOC biodegradation were caused by differences in soil management. Highlights Clay size fraction showed the largest increase in SOC storage when residue was returned. Silt size fraction lost SOC in no‐till maize‐soybean compared with traditional farming practice. Potential SOC mineralization depended on quantity of SOC in the LF. Biodegradability of the SOC was driven by cropping system not tillage.
Similar papers
Tillage and crop rotation effects on soil carbon and selected soil physical properties in a Haplic Cambisol in Eastern Cape, South Africa
Mtyobile, Muzangwa & Mnkeni · 2019 · Soil and Water Research
10 shared concepts
8 findings1 site
In-season temporal variability of soil carbon and nitrogen pools after half a century of a tillage and crop rotation gradient
Gonzalez-Maldonado et al. · 2025 · Soil and Tillage Research
10 shared concepts
43 findings2 sites
Distribution of soil aggregates and organic carbon in deep soil under long-term conservation tillage with residual retention in dryland
Wang et al. · 2019 · Journal of Arid Land
8 shared concepts