Agronomy · 2025
Long-Term Straw Return Combined with Chemical Fertilizer Enhances Crop Yields in Wheat-Maize Rotation Systems by Improving Soil Nutrients Stoichiometry and Aggregate Stability in the Shajiang Black Soil (Vertisol) Region of North China Plain
Tang, X., Qu, Y., Wu, Y., Li, S., Wang, F., Li, D., Li, X., Wang, J., Zhao, J.
Export
Long-Term Straw Return Combined with Chemical Fertilizer Enh…
Abstract
The sustainability of wheat-maize rotation systems in the North China Plain is challenged by the over-reliance on chemical fertilizers, which leads to the decline of soil organic matter and structural degradation, particularly in the unique Shajiang black soil (Vertisol). While straw return is widely recommended to mitigate these issues, the synergistic mechanisms of its long-term combination with chemical fertilizers on soil nutrient stoichiometry and aggregate stability remain inadequately quantified. A long-term field experiment was conducted with the five fertilization treatments including: (1) no fertilizer or straw (CK), (2) chemical fertilizer alone (NPK), (3) straw return chemical fertilizer (NPKS), (4) straw return with 10% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (10%NPKS), and (5) straw return with 20% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (20%NPKS) in the Shajiang black soil (Vertisol) region to investigate the effects of straw return combined with chemical fertilizers on soil organic carbon (SOC), total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) stoichiometry, aggregate stability, and crop yield in winter wheat-summer maize rotation systems of North China Plain. Our study demonstrated that the co-application of straw with a straw-decomposing microbial inoculant is a highly effective strategy for enhancing soil health and crop productivity, with its efficacy being critically dose-dependent. Our results identified the 10%NPKS treatment as the optimal practice. It most effectively improved soil physical structure by significantly increasing the content of large macroaggregates (>0.5 mm) and key stability indices (MWD, GMD, WA), while concurrently enhancing nutrient cycling, as evidenced by elevated SOC, TN, and shifted C/P and N/P stoichiometry. Multivariate analyses confirmed strong positive correlations among these soil properties, indicating a synergistic improvement in soil quality. Crucially, these enhancements translated into significant yield gains, with a notable crop-specific response: maize yield was maximized under the 10%NPKS treatment, whereas wheat yield benefited sufficiently from NPKS treatment. A key mechanistic insight was that 20%NPKS treatment, despite leading to the highest SOC and TN, induced a relative phosphorus limitation and likely caused transient nutrient immobilization, thereby attenuating its benefits for soil structure and yield. We conclude that co-applying straw with a 10% microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer represents the superior strategy, offering a sustainable pathway to synergistically improve soil structure, nutrient availability, and crop productivity, particularly in maize-dominated systems.
Show all
The sustainability of wheat-maize rotation systems in the North China Plain is challenged by the over-reliance on chemical fertilizers, which leads to the decline of soil organic matter and structural degradation, particularly in the unique Shajiang black soil (Vertisol). While straw return is widely recommended to mitigate these issues, the synergistic mechanisms of its long-term combination with chemical fertilizers on soil nutrient stoichiometry and aggregate stability remain inadequately quantified. A long-term field experiment was conducted with the five fertilization treatments including: (1) no fertilizer or straw (CK), (2) chemical fertilizer alone (NPK), (3) straw return chemical fertilizer (NPKS), (4) straw return with 10% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (10%NPKS), and (5) straw return with 20% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (20%NPKS) in the Shajiang black soil (Vertisol) region to investigate the effects of straw return combined with chemical fertilizers on soil organic carbon (SOC), total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) stoichiometry, aggregate stability, and crop yield in winter wheat-summer maize rotation systems of North China Plain. Our study demonstrated that the co-application of straw with a straw-decomposing microbial inoculant is a highly effective strategy for enhancing soil health and crop productivity, with its efficacy being critically dose-dependent. Our results identified the 10%NPKS treatment as the optimal practice. It most effectively improved soil physical structure by significantly increasing the content of large macroaggregates (>0.5 mm) and key stability indices (MWD, GMD, WA), while concurrently enhancing nutrient cycling, as evidenced by elevated SOC, TN, and shifted C/P and N/P stoichiometry. Multivariate analyses confirmed strong positive correlations among these soil properties, indicating a synergistic improvement in soil quality. Crucially, these enhancements translated into significant yield gains, with a notable crop-specific response: maize yield was maximized under the 10%NPKS treatment, whereas wheat yield benefited sufficiently from NPKS treatment. A key mechanistic insight was that 20%NPKS treatment, despite leading to the highest SOC and TN, induced a relative phosphorus limitation and likely caused transient nutrient immobilization, thereby attenuating its benefits for soil structure and yield. We conclude that co-applying straw with a 10% microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer represents the superior strategy, offering a sustainable pathway to synergistically improve soil structure, nutrient availability, and crop productivity, particularly in maize-dominated systems.
The sustainability of wheat-maize rotation systems in the North China Plain is challenged by the over-reliance on chemical fertilizers, which leads to the decline of soil organic matter and structural degradation, particularly in the unique Shajiang black soil (Vertisol). While straw return is widely recommended to mitigate these issues, the synergistic mechanisms of its long-term combination with chemical fertilizers on soil nutrient stoichiometry and aggregate stability remain inadequately quantified. A long-term field experiment was conducted with the five fertilization treatments including: (1) no fertilizer or straw (CK), (2) chemical fertilizer alone (NPK), (3) straw return chemical fertilizer (NPKS), (4) straw return with 10% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (10%NPKS), and (5) straw return with 20% straw-decomposing microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer (20%NPKS) in the Shajiang black soil (Vertisol) region to investigate the effects of straw return combined with chemical fertilizers on soil organic carbon (SOC), total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) stoichiometry, aggregate stability, and crop yield in winter wheat-summer maize rotation systems of North China Plain. Our study demonstrated that the co-application of straw with a straw-decomposing microbial inoculant is a highly effective strategy for enhancing soil health and crop productivity, with its efficacy being critically dose-dependent. Our results identified the 10%NPKS treatment as the optimal practice. It most effectively improved soil physical structure by significantly increasing the content of large macroaggregates (>0.5 mm) and key stability indices (MWD, GMD, WA), while concurrently enhancing nutrient cycling, as evidenced by elevated SOC, TN, and shifted C/P and N/P stoichiometry. Multivariate analyses confirmed strong positive correlations among these soil properties, indicating a synergistic improvement in soil quality. Crucially, these enhancements translated into significant yield gains, with a notable crop-specific response: maize yield was maximized under the 10%NPKS treatment, whereas wheat yield benefited sufficiently from NPKS treatment. A key mechanistic insight was that 20%NPKS treatment, despite leading to the highest SOC and TN, induced a relative phosphorus limitation and likely caused transient nutrient immobilization, thereby attenuating its benefits for soil structure and yield. We conclude that co-applying straw with a 10% microbial inoculant combined with chemical fertilizer represents the superior strategy, offering a sustainable pathway to synergistically improve soil structure, nutrient availability, and crop productivity, particularly in maize-dominated systems.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
wheat yield
↑ 2= 13
- increase
NPK,NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing fertilized comparisons vs. CKsignificant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Wheat harvest;all fertilized variants B/A/AB/AB versusCK C;peakNPKS
Numbers
- treatment 49.17 vs. control 11.17 kg 50−1 m−2 (printed) (+340.2 %) · NPKS maximum versusCK minimum, identified from Fig6a letters/bar ranking;printed endpoints
Source · p. 10 “Compared to CK treatment, the NPK, NPKS, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatments significantly increased wheat yield”
- increase
NPKS vs. NPKsignificant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Wheat harvest;NPKS A versusNPK B
Numbers
- percent_change 10.9
Source · p. 10 “compared to NPK treatment, the NPKS treatment significantly increased wheat yield by 10.90%”
- no effect
10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing inoculated straw comparisons vs. NPKnot significant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Wheat harvest;both inoculated variants AB shareNPK B
Source · p. 10 “however, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS had no significant difference”
maize yield
↑ 2= 13
- increase
NPK,NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing fertilized comparisons vs. CKsignificant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Maize harvest;all fertilized variants B/AB/A/A versusCK C;10/20% similar
Source · p. 10 “while those treatments significantly increased maize yield with the values of 39.34–64.54%”
- no effect
NPKS vs. NPKnot significant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Maize harvest;NPKS AB sharesNPK B
Source · p. 10 “Conversely, compared to NPK treatment, the NPKS treatment no significant difference”
- increase
10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing inoculated straw comparisons vs. NPKsignificant · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Maize harvest,Fig6b axis corrects prose wheat typo;10/20%A versusNPK B
Numbers
- percent_change 17.89 · 10%NPKS
- percent_change 18.09 · 20%NPKS
Source · p. 10 “10%NPKS and 20%NPKS significantly increased wheat yield by 17.89% and 18.09%, respectively”
Source · p. 18 “Conversely, NPKS treatment showed no significant benefit over NPK, the 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatments significantly boosted yields”
soil pH
↓ 1= 12
- decrease
10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing inoculated straw comparisons vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · 10%NPKS and20%NPKS; Fig2A versus CK B/A
Source · p. 6 “Compared to CK treatment, the 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatments decreased significantly soil pH with the value of 13.20% and 12.05%”
- no effect
NPK and NPKS, agreeing pH comparisons vs. CKnot significant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County
Source · p. 6 “while the NPK and NPKS were no significantly difference”
SOC
↑ 1↓ 12
- increase
NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing straw-return packages vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · NPKS,10%NPKS,20%NPKS; highest20%;100.705 source typo not numerically corrected
Numbers
- percent_change 58.06 · NPKS
- percent_change 62.88 · 10%NPKS
Source · p. 6 “NPKS, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatment increased significantly by 58.06%, 62.88% and 100.705 as compared with CK treatment”
- decrease
NPK vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County
Source · p. 6 “SOC contents in the NPK treatment decreased significantly by 10.88%”
TN
↑ 11
- increase
NPK,NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing fertilized comparisons vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · All four fertilized treatments; individual letters differ from CK; highest10/20% bothA
Source · p. 6 “compared to CK treatment, the NPK, NPKS, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS increased significantly TN contents with 17–28 times”
TP
↑ 11
- increase
NPK vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Fig2d A/B overrides Discussion blanket null
Source · p. 6 “TP content was higher in the NPK treatment than that in CK and 20%NPKS treatments”
0.5–2mm aggregate content
↑ 11
- increase
NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing straw-return packages vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Straw packages; uppercase A versus CK B;0.5–2mm fraction
Source · p. 8 “Compared with CK and NPK treatments, the NPKS, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatments increased significantly 0.5–2 mm aggregate content”
MWD
↑ 11
- increase
NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing straw-return packages vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Straw variants; highest10%;all A/B versus CK C
Source · p. 9 “Compared with CK and NPK treatments, the MWD values of the NPKS, 10%NPKS and 20%NPKS treatments increased significantly”
GMD
↑ 11
- increase
NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing straw-return packages vs. CKsignificant · 0–20 cm · mid-November2023 · Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County · Straw variants; highest10%;all A/B versus CK C
Source · p. 9 “the GMD values of those treatments increased significantly by 44.71–47.33%, 92.39–95.87% and 65.40–68.40%, respectively”
Set-up
Treatments
- fertilization treatmentsFertilization
- CKNo fertilizerNPKNPK fertilizerNPKSResidue incorporation10%NPKSResidue incorporation20%NPKSResidue incorporation10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing inoculated straw comparisonsResidue incorporationNPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing straw-return packagesResidue incorporationNPK,NPKS,10%NPKS and20%NPKS, agreeing fertilized comparisonsFertilizationNPK and NPKS, agreeing pH comparisonsNPK fertilizer
Measured
- soil pHpH
- Method
- potentiometric, stated2.5:1 soil-water ratio
- SOCSoil organic carbon
- Unit
- g kg−1
- Method
- potassium dichromate wet oxidation
- TNTotal Nitrogen
- Unit
- g kg−1
- TPTotal Phosphorus
- Unit
- g kg−1
- TKTotal Potassium/Total K
- Unit
- g kg−1
- C/NC:N ratio
- C/PC:P ratio
- N/PC:N:P stoichiometry
- 0.5–2mm aggregate contentMacroaggregates
- Unit
- %
- 0.25–0.5mm aggregate contentMacroaggregates
- Unit
- %
- >2mm aggregate contentMacroaggregates
- Unit
- %
- MWDWater-stable aggregate mean weight diameter (MWD)
- Unit
- mm
- GMDAggregate geometric mean diameter
- Unit
- mm
- WAWater-stable aggregates
- Unit
- %
- FDFractal dimension
- MWSSASpecific surface area
- Unit
- cm2 g−1
- wheat yieldYield
- Unit
- kg 50−1 m−2 (printed)
- maize yieldYield
- Unit
- kg 50−1 m−2 (printed)
Sites
Agricultural Science Research Institute in Linquan County
- Location
- Linquan County, Anhui Province, China32.92° N, 115.10° E
- Climate
- 15.3 °C mean annual temperature892 mm annual precipitation
- Soil
- Vertisol · USDA
- Land use
- winter wheat-summer maize cropping systemArable land
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| pre-experiment soil (depth not stated) | – | – | 5.72 | – | – |
Similar papers
Integrative effects of no-tillage and straw returning on soil organic carbón and water stable aggregation under rice-rape rotation
Kubar et al. · 2018 · Chilean journal of agricultural research
10 shared concepts
12 findings1 site
Effects of Biogas Slurry on Crop Yield, Physicochemical Properties and Aggregation Characteristics of Lime Concretion Soil in Wheat–Maize Rotation in the North China Plain
Tang et al. · 2022 · Journal of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition
11 shared concepts
20 findings1 site
Nutrient Characterization in Soil Aggregate Fractions with Different Fertilizer Treatments in Greenhouse Vegetable Cultivation
Wang et al. · 2022 · Agriculture
9 shared concepts
15 findings1 site
Soil quality, elemental stoichiometry and crop yield under partial substitution of chemical fertilizers with organic inputs in Vertisols: a six-site field study
Jiang et al. · 2026 · Frontiers in Plant Science
10 shared concepts
14 findings6 sites
Soil Aggregates and Aggregate-Associated Carbon and Nitrogen in Farmland in Relation to Long-Term Fertilization on the Loess Plateau, China
Wang et al. · 2023 · Agronomy
10 shared concepts
30 findings1 site
