Frontiers in Plant Science · 2026
Organic fertilizer substitution in saline-alkali paddy fields: trade-offs among soil quality, greenhouse gas emissions, yield, and profitability
Liu, S., Liang, S., Zhao, Z., Hao, W., Gong, S., Zhang, M., Wang, H., Chu, Q., Wang, R., Li, H., Sha, Z.
Export
Organic fertilizer substitution in saline-alkali paddy field…
Abstract
Balancing crop productivity with greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation is a major challenge in saline-alkali rice systems. We conducted a three-season field experiment in Shanghai, China, to evaluate four fertilization regimes: no fertilizer (CK), full chemical fertilization (CT), 50% organic substitution (MF), and 100% organic substitution (OF). We quantified methane (CH 4 ) and Nitrous oxide (N 2 O) emissions, rice yield, soil properties, soil enzyme activities, soil quality index (SQI), and net environmental and economic benefits (NEEB). Relative to CT, organic substitution consistently lowered N 2 O emissions but increased CH 4 emissions. Across the study period, MF reduced cumulative N 2 O emissions by 30.50%, maintained rice grain yield, improved soil quality, and increased NEEB by 31.42%. OF further reduced N 2 O emissions by 48.65% but greatly stimulated CH 4 emissions and caused clear yield and profit penalties. The increase in CH 4 under organic substitution was associated with higher soil organic carbon and enzyme activity, whereas N 2 O emissions were closely related to soil inorganic N availability. Overall, MF provided the most balanced outcome among productivity, soil improvement, and environmental performance. These findings indicate that partial replacement of chemical fertilizer with organic fertilizer is a promising management strategy for saline-alkali paddy fields, whereas complete substitution is less suitable because the gains in N 2 O mitigation are offset by increased CH 4 emissions and lower agronomic performance.
Show all
Balancing crop productivity with greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation is a major challenge in saline-alkali rice systems. We conducted a three-season field experiment in Shanghai, China, to evaluate four fertilization regimes: no fertilizer (CK), full chemical fertilization (CT), 50% organic substitution (MF), and 100% organic substitution (OF). We quantified methane (CH 4 ) and Nitrous oxide (N 2 O) emissions, rice yield, soil properties, soil enzyme activities, soil quality index (SQI), and net environmental and economic benefits (NEEB). Relative to CT, organic substitution consistently lowered N 2 O emissions but increased CH 4 emissions. Across the study period, MF reduced cumulative N 2 O emissions by 30.50%, maintained rice grain yield, improved soil quality, and increased NEEB by 31.42%. OF further reduced N 2 O emissions by 48.65% but greatly stimulated CH 4 emissions and caused clear yield and profit penalties. The increase in CH 4 under organic substitution was associated with higher soil organic carbon and enzyme activity, whereas N 2 O emissions were closely related to soil inorganic N availability. Overall, MF provided the most balanced outcome among productivity, soil improvement, and environmental performance. These findings indicate that partial replacement of chemical fertilizer with organic fertilizer is a promising management strategy for saline-alkali paddy fields, whereas complete substitution is less suitable because the gains in N 2 O mitigation are offset by increased CH 4 emissions and lower agronomic performance.
Balancing crop productivity with greenhouse gas (GHG) mitigation is a major challenge in saline-alkali rice systems. We conducted a three-season field experiment in Shanghai, China, to evaluate four fertilization regimes: no fertilizer (CK), full chemical fertilization (CT), 50% organic substitution (MF), and 100% organic substitution (OF). We quantified methane (CH 4 ) and Nitrous oxide (N 2 O) emissions, rice yield, soil properties, soil enzyme activities, soil quality index (SQI), and net environmental and economic benefits (NEEB). Relative to CT, organic substitution consistently lowered N 2 O emissions but increased CH 4 emissions. Across the study period, MF reduced cumulative N 2 O emissions by 30.50%, maintained rice grain yield, improved soil quality, and increased NEEB by 31.42%. OF further reduced N 2 O emissions by 48.65% but greatly stimulated CH 4 emissions and caused clear yield and profit penalties. The increase in CH 4 under organic substitution was associated with higher soil organic carbon and enzyme activity, whereas N 2 O emissions were closely related to soil inorganic N availability. Overall, MF provided the most balanced outcome among productivity, soil improvement, and environmental performance. These findings indicate that partial replacement of chemical fertilizer with organic fertilizer is a promising management strategy for saline-alkali paddy fields, whereas complete substitution is less suitable because the gains in N 2 O mitigation are offset by increased CH 4 emissions and lower agronomic performance.
Similar papers
Evaluation of Olive Mill Waste Compost as a Sustainable Alternative to Conventional Fertilizers in Wheat Cultivation
García-Rández et al. · 2025 · Agriculture
7 shared concepts
15 findings1 site
Impacts of Different Long-Term Fertilizer Management Regimes on Soil Nitrogen Mineralization and Its Enzyme Activities under a Double-Cropping Rice System in Southern China
Tang et al. · 2023 · Agronomy
8 shared concepts
15 findings1 site
Methane and nitrous oxide emissions as affected by long-term fertilizer management from double-cropping paddy fields in Southern China
Tang et al. · 2016 · The Journal of Agricultural Science
7 shared concepts
