Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems · 2024
No yield advantage of biodynamic compost preparations in a long-term field trial
Dietrich, L., Dahn, C., Fritz, J., Berg, M., Köpke, U., Döring, T. F.
Export
No yield advantage of biodynamic compost preparations in a l…
Abstract
Biodynamic farming is a growing branch of organic farming which uses various so-called biodynamic preparations with the aim to enhance plant growth and soil quality. These preparations comprise plant parts fermented in animal sheaths (e.g., cow intestines or deer bladders) which are then applied to manures and composts before applying to the field (compost preparations). Two special preparations based on manure and silica are applied to the crops as field sprays (spray preparations). The effect of these biodynamic preparations, however, is a matter of debate. In a long-term experiment over 27 yrs, within an organic crop rotation, the use of biodynamic compost preparations has recently been shown to impact the soil biological community. Using the same experiment, we investigated whether these soil-level effects also displayed in agronomic parameters of arable crops. We found that the use of biodynamic compost preparations, when compared with farmyard manure (FYM) compost application without preparations, had no effect on yield in any of the investigated crops (spring wheat, winter wheat, oats, winter rye, faba bean, potatoes, maize, and grass/clover), or when data from all crops were pooled. Temporal yield stability of spring wheat and grass/clover was also unaffected by the biodynamic compost preparations. The application of FYM compost, however, led to significant increases in both yield and yield stability as compared to the non-fertilized control. We conclude that while biodynamic compost preparations did influence biological processes in the soil, they did not increase the crop yields in our long-term trial.
Show all
Biodynamic farming is a growing branch of organic farming which uses various so-called biodynamic preparations with the aim to enhance plant growth and soil quality. These preparations comprise plant parts fermented in animal sheaths (e.g., cow intestines or deer bladders) which are then applied to manures and composts before applying to the field (compost preparations). Two special preparations based on manure and silica are applied to the crops as field sprays (spray preparations). The effect of these biodynamic preparations, however, is a matter of debate. In a long-term experiment over 27 yrs, within an organic crop rotation, the use of biodynamic compost preparations has recently been shown to impact the soil biological community. Using the same experiment, we investigated whether these soil-level effects also displayed in agronomic parameters of arable crops. We found that the use of biodynamic compost preparations, when compared with farmyard manure (FYM) compost application without preparations, had no effect on yield in any of the investigated crops (spring wheat, winter wheat, oats, winter rye, faba bean, potatoes, maize, and grass/clover), or when data from all crops were pooled. Temporal yield stability of spring wheat and grass/clover was also unaffected by the biodynamic compost preparations. The application of FYM compost, however, led to significant increases in both yield and yield stability as compared to the non-fertilized control. We conclude that while biodynamic compost preparations did influence biological processes in the soil, they did not increase the crop yields in our long-term trial.
Biodynamic farming is a growing branch of organic farming which uses various so-called biodynamic preparations with the aim to enhance plant growth and soil quality. These preparations comprise plant parts fermented in animal sheaths (e.g., cow intestines or deer bladders) which are then applied to manures and composts before applying to the field (compost preparations). Two special preparations based on manure and silica are applied to the crops as field sprays (spray preparations). The effect of these biodynamic preparations, however, is a matter of debate. In a long-term experiment over 27 yrs, within an organic crop rotation, the use of biodynamic compost preparations has recently been shown to impact the soil biological community. Using the same experiment, we investigated whether these soil-level effects also displayed in agronomic parameters of arable crops. We found that the use of biodynamic compost preparations, when compared with farmyard manure (FYM) compost application without preparations, had no effect on yield in any of the investigated crops (spring wheat, winter wheat, oats, winter rye, faba bean, potatoes, maize, and grass/clover), or when data from all crops were pooled. Temporal yield stability of spring wheat and grass/clover was also unaffected by the biodynamic compost preparations. The application of FYM compost, however, led to significant increases in both yield and yield stability as compared to the non-fertilized control. We conclude that while biodynamic compost preparations did influence biological processes in the soil, they did not increase the crop yields in our long-term trial.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
normalized crop yield
↑ 1= 12
- no effect
FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variants vs. FYM without preparationsnot significant · 1993–2021 · Wiesengut · All crops and years pooled; also consistent within crops. All502–507 and Achillea502 preparations independently agree versus plain compost; no field sprays
Source · p. 5 “no statistically significant differences between biodynamically amended FYM and non-treated FYM application could be determined neither on a crop level (Fig. 3a) nor across all crops (Fig. 3b).”
- increase
all composted FYM treatments, agreeing variants vs. no FYM controlsignificant · 1993–2021 · Wiesengut · All crops/years pooled; three independently tested compost variants agree. No synthetic control mean or chart estimate
Source · p. 5 “Normalized yield across all years and crops was significantly higher in the three treatments which received composted FYM than in the control treatment (Fig. 3b).”
adjusted coefficient of variation of yield
↑ 1= 12
- no effect
FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variants vs. FYM without preparationsnot significant · long-term trial · Wiesengut · Grass/clover and spring wheat; both preparation variants versus plain compost, independently tested
Numbers
- treatment 45.5 vs. control 45.7 % (-0.4376 %) · grass/clover,allpreps vsFYM
- treatment 45.2 vs. control 45.7 % (-1.094 %) · grass/clover,Achillea vsFYM
- treatment 44 vs. control 41.3 % (+6.538 %) · springwheat,allpreps vsFYM
- treatment 44.4 vs. control 41.3 % (+7.506 %) · springwheat,Achillea vsFYM
Source · p. 5 “We found that biodynamic compost preparations did not have a significant impact on yields and yield stability in any of the tested crop species”
- increase
FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variants vs. no FYM controlsignificant · long-term trial · Wiesengut · Spring wheat; both preparation-containing composts a versus control b. Adjusted CV increases; prose calls this increased stability, contrary to the measured CV direction. Plain FYM ab overlaps control and is excluded
Numbers
- treatment 44 vs. control 36.3 % (+21.21 %) · springwheat,allpreps vscontrol
- treatment 44.4 vs. control 36.3 % (+22.31 %) · springwheat,Achillea vscontrol
Source · p. 5 “Yield stability over the years of the experiment was similar among treatments in the grass/clover plots and showed significantly higher values in the FYM treatments as compared to the control in spring wheat (Fig. 5, Table 3).”
maize plant height
↑ 1= 12
- no effect
FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variants vs. FYM without preparationsnot significant · 20 September2012 · Wiesengut · Maize; allpreps a,Achillea ab,plainFYM a; both preparation variants versus plain compost
Source · p. 5 “Neither of the studied agronomic parameters (yield, plant height, thousand grain mass) was affected by the compost preparations in our trial.”
- increase
FYM without preparations vs. no FYM controlsignificant · 20 September2012 · Wiesengut · Plain compost a versus noFYM b, Fig4b; Achillea ab not included in positive contrast
Source · p. 5 “FYM treatments turned out to induce increased height growth in maize plants compared to the control treatment in one year of maize cultivation at the research site (Fig. 4b).”
1000 grain mass
= 11
- no effect
FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variants vs. FYM without preparationsnot significant · across years · Wiesengut · Faba bean,springwheat,winterrye,winterwheat; both biodynamic compost preparation variants versus plain compost
Source · p. 5 “Neither of the studied agronomic parameters (yield, plant height, thousand grain mass) was affected by the compost preparations in our trial.”
Set-up
Treatments
- compost application practicesAnimal manure compost
- FYM + all preps and FYM + Achillea, agreeing variantsBiodynamic farmingFYM without preparationsAnimal manure compostno FYM controlNo compostall composted FYM treatments, agreeing variantsAnimal manure compost
Measured
- normalized crop yieldYield
- Unit
- % of control average
- Method
- Withinyear normalization; acrossyears model with year random factor
- adjusted coefficient of variation of yieldYield variability
- Unit
- %
- Method
- Döring and Reckling2018 adjusted CV; higher value means greater variation, although paper calls it higher yield stability
- 1000 grain massThousand kernel weight
- Unit
- g
- maize plant heightPlant height
- Unit
- cm
Sites
Wiesengut
- Location
- Hennef near Bonn, Germany
- Soil
- Fluvisol · WRB
- Land use
- rainfed organic crop rotationNon-irrigated arable land
- Management on the whole site
- organic farming
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| loamy Fluvisol (depth unstated) | loamy | – | – | – | – |
Similar papers
Enhanced soil quality with reduced tillage and solid manures in organic farming – a synthesis of 15 years
Krauss et al. · 2020 · Scientific Reports
4 shared concepts
24 findings1 site
THE EFFECT OF TRICHODERMA SP. SEED COATING AND THE APPLICATION OF BOKASHI TOWARD SOYBEAN YIELD
Winara, Sumadi & Nuraini · 2019 · Jurnal Penelitian Saintek
4 shared concepts
3 findings1 site
Effects of Rotating Rice with Upland Crops and Adding Organic Amendments, and of Related Soil Quality on Rice Yield in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta
Qui et al. · 2024 · Agronomy
4 shared concepts
3 findings1 site
Composted Cattle Manure Increases Microbial Activity and Soil Fertility More Than Composted Swine Manure in a Submerged Rice Paddy
Das et al. · 2017 · Frontiers in Microbiology
4 shared concepts
14 findings1 site
Increase in pigments and stomatal conductance of murta ( Ugni molinae) through applications of organic-based fertilizer
Betancur et al. · 2026 · REVISTA CIENTÍFICA CUADERNOS DE INVESTIGACIÓN
3 shared concepts
12 findings1 site
