Polyethylene film (PE) mulching produces substantial “white pollution,” prompting the use of biodegradable film (BF) alternatives, yet their performance in rice systems on Northeast black soils is still uncertain. We compared three BFs with different induction periods (45 d, BF45; 60 d, BF60; 80 d, BF80), PE and a no-film control (CK) to quantify their effects on soil hydrothermal conditions, rice growth, yield, grain quality, irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE) and soil C, N. Results showed that mulching increased soil temperature and soil moisture. Across the growing season, the mean soil temperature at the 0–5 cm depth under PE was 5.5% and 2.2–5.5% higher than that under CK and BFs, respectively. Specifically, compared with CK, PE increased grain yield by 31–77% and IWUE by 75–123%, while BFs improved yield by 25–73% and IWUE by 48–101%. PE only slightly outperformed BF80 in yield (by 2.3% in 2023 and 2.1% in 2024) but achieved higher IWUE (11.0–11.7%). Grain chalkiness and sensory scores under BFs were comparable to PE and better than CK. At 0–20 cm, PE increased SOC (2.3–6.8%) and the C/N ratio (0–0.8%) but reduced total nitrogen (TN) (2.7–3.9%) and total carbon (TC) (2.5–3.1%), whereas BFs increased Org-N by 0.4–4.2%, SOC by 2.9–7.1%, and TN by 0.2–0.7%, with BF80 showing the greatest stimulatory effect. Overall, BFs—particularly BF80—are promising substitutes for PE in black soil rice systems, supporting sustainable rice production with strong application potential.
Show all
Polyethylene film (PE) mulching produces substantial “white pollution,” prompting the use of biodegradable film (BF) alternatives, yet their performance in rice systems on Northeast black soils is still uncertain. We compared three BFs with different induction periods (45 d, BF45; 60 d, BF60; 80 d, BF80), PE and a no-film control (CK) to quantify their effects on soil hydrothermal conditions, rice growth, yield, grain quality, irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE) and soil C, N. Results showed that mulching increased soil temperature and soil moisture. Across the growing season, the mean soil temperature at the 0–5 cm depth under PE was 5.5% and 2.2–5.5% higher than that under CK and BFs, respectively. Specifically, compared with CK, PE increased grain yield by 31–77% and IWUE by 75–123%, while BFs improved yield by 25–73% and IWUE by 48–101%. PE only slightly outperformed BF80 in yield (by 2.3% in 2023 and 2.1% in 2024) but achieved higher IWUE (11.0–11.7%). Grain chalkiness and sensory scores under BFs were comparable to PE and better than CK. At 0–20 cm, PE increased SOC (2.3–6.8%) and the C/N ratio (0–0.8%) but reduced total nitrogen (TN) (2.7–3.9%) and total carbon (TC) (2.5–3.1%), whereas BFs increased Org-N by 0.4–4.2%, SOC by 2.9–7.1%, and TN by 0.2–0.7%, with BF80 showing the greatest stimulatory effect. Overall, BFs—particularly BF80—are promising substitutes for PE in black soil rice systems, supporting sustainable rice production with strong application potential.
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
rice grain yield
↑ 1= 12
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · harvest2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE/BN,BF45,BF60,BF80 individually versus CK; Table3 and4 actual pair letters agree in significance despite different repeated2024 yield letters. +/- type not stated.
Numbers
treatment 9,691 vs. control 5,485 kg/hm2 (+76.68 %) · 2023 · PE
treatment 8,450 vs. control 5,485 kg/hm2 (+54.05 %) · 2023 · BF45
treatment 8,827 vs. control 5,485 kg/hm2 (+60.93 %) · 2023 · BF60
treatment 9,475 vs. control 5,485 kg/hm2 (+72.74 %) · 2023 · BF80
treatment 9,031 vs. control 6,893 kg/hm2 (+31.01 %) · 2024 · PE
treatment 8,760 vs. control 6,893 kg/hm2 (+27.08 %) · 2024 · BF45
treatment 8,604 vs. control 6,893 kg/hm2 (+24.82 %) · 2024 · BF60
treatment 8,848 vs. control 6,893 kg/hm2 (+28.35 %) · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 10
“In 2023, yields under BF45, BF60 and BF80 were 54%, 61% and 73% higher than CK”
Source · p. 16
“Both PE and BFs improved soil hydrothermal conditions, enhanced rice growth, and significantly increased yield and IWUE relative to the no-mulch control”
=no effect
BF80 vs. PE (BN), conventional black polyethylene filmnot significant · 2023 and2024 harvest · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · BF80 versus PE/BN; Table3 PE a/BF80 ab both years. Numerical2.3/2.1% deficit not significant. Table4 repeated yield letters differ2024 but also shared.
Numbers
treatment 9,475 vs. control 9,691 kg/hm2 (-2.229 %) · 2023
treatment 8,848 vs. control 9,031 kg/hm2 (-2.026 %) · 2024
Source · p. 10
“Compared with BF80, PE increased grain yield by only 2.3% and 2.1% in 2023 and 2024, respectively”
Source · p. 11
“BN | 461.6 ± 18.8 a | 100.2 ± 5.1 a | 92.8 ± 1.2 ab | 24.9 ± 1.1 a | 9691.4 ± 915.2 a”
Source · p. 11
“BF80 | 438.0 ± 26.8 a | 100.5 ± 8.4 a | 92.8 ± 1.5 ab | 25.2 ± 0.7 a | 9475.4 ± 910.5 ab”
irrigation water use efficiency (IWUE)
↑ 1= 12
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 individually versus CK; Table4 Duncan.05, no pooled means.
Numbers
treatment 18.1 vs. control 8.1 kg/hm2/mm (+123.5 %) · 2023 · PE
treatment 14.2 vs. control 8.1 kg/hm2/mm (+75.31 %) · 2023 · BF45
treatment 15 vs. control 8.1 kg/hm2/mm (+85.19 %) · 2023 · BF60
treatment 16.3 vs. control 8.1 kg/hm2/mm (+101.2 %) · 2023 · BF80
treatment 18.2 vs. control 10.4 kg/hm2/mm (+75 %) · 2024 · PE
total nitrogen (TN)
↓ 1= 12
=no effect
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlnot significant · 0–20 cm · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · 0-5cm:all PE/BFs both years.0-20cm:all PE/BFs2023, PE/BF60/BF80 only2024. Those pairs share letters; BF45 at0-20cm2024 significant decline stored separately. Abstract TNincrease conflicts with results/table. Reported intervals overlap; methods5-20/table0-20 mismatch documented.
Numbers
treatment 1.5 vs. control 1.6 g/kg (-6.25 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 1.5 vs. control 1.6 g/kg (-6.25 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 1.6 vs. control 1.6 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 1.6 vs. control 1.6 g/kg (0 %)
leaf area index (LAI)
↑ 11
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 2023 and2024, tillering through ripening · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 individually versus CK, Duncan.05; all four stages. +/- kind unstated, dispersion omitted.
Numbers
treatment 3.26 vs. control 1.31 m2/m2 (+148.9 %) · 2023 tillering · PE
treatment 2.8 vs. control 1.31 m2/m2 (+113.7 %) · 2023 tillering · BF45
treatment 2.76 vs. control 1.31 m2/m2 (+110.7 %) · 2023 tillering · BF60
treatment 3.11 vs. control 1.31 m2/m2 (+137.4 %) · 2023 tillering · BF80
treatment 5.92 vs. control 1.99 m2/m2 (+197.5 %) · 2023 jointing-booting · PE
tiller number and effective tillers/productive panicles per area
↑ 11
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 2023 and2024, late tillering and maturity · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK; Fig4 stages3/4 all disjoint; early stages excluded. Maturity productive panicles Table3 are same response, not additional finding. +/- type unspecified.
Numbers
percent_change 66 · 2023 late tillering · BF45
percent_change 99 · 2023 late tillering · BF60
percent_change 110 · 2023 late tillering · BF80
percent_change 50 · 2024 late tillering · BF45
percent_change 44 · 2024 late tillering · BF60
percent_change 52
aboveground dry matter
↑ 11
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 2023 and2024, jointing-booting through maturity · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 individually versus CK; Fig5 disjoint letters at stages2-4 both years. No chart means. Percentages are printed examples, not reconstructed means.
Numbers
percent_change 51 · 2023 jointing-booting · BF45
percent_change 72 · 2023 jointing-booting · BF60
percent_change 96 · 2023 jointing-booting · BF80
percent_change 60 · 2023 heading-flowering · BF45
percent_change 86 · 2023 heading-flowering · BF60
percent_change 88
belowground dry matter
↑ 11
↑increase
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK throughout2023 and at tillering/jointing2024; PE alone also heading/maturity2024. BF heading/maturity2024 overlap CK and excluded from significant scope. Fig5 individual letters, no chart means.
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · harvest2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE/BF45/BF60/BF80 in2023; PE only in2024. BF2024 ab shares b with CK and not included. Duncan.05 actual pairs.
Numbers
treatment 100.2 vs. control 85.7 grains/panicle (+16.92 %) · 2023 · PE
treatment 98.8 vs. control 85.7 grains/panicle (+15.29 %) · 2023 · BF45
treatment 98.1 vs. control 85.7 grains/panicle (+14.47 %) · 2023 · BF60
treatment 100.5 vs. control 85.7 grains/panicle (+17.27 %) · 2023 · BF80
treatment 103.4 vs. control 89.3 grains/panicle (+15.79 %) · 2024 · PE
soil organic carbon (SOC)
= 11
=no effect
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlnot significant · 0–20 cm · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK, each reported interval0-5 and0-20cm; all SOC pair letters a/a. Methods say0-5/5-20, tables0-5/0-20, use table labels. Abstract/conclusion numerical SOC gains not significant; concentration, not stock.
Numbers
treatment 15.7 vs. control 15.4 g/kg (+1.948 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 16.1 vs. control 15.4 g/kg (+4.545 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 16.1 vs. control 15.4 g/kg (+4.545 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 16.2 vs. control 15.4 g/kg (+5.195 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 16.1 vs. control 16.3 g/kg (-1.227 %)
organic nitrogen (Org-N)
= 11
=no effect
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlnot significant · 0–20 cm · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK in both reported0-5 and0-20cm intervals; every Org-N pair a/a. Marginal numerical BF increase not significant. Methods depth mismatch documented.
Numbers
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 1.5 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (+7.143 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · PE
total carbon (TC)
= 11
=no effect
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlnot significant · 0–20 cm · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK; reported0-5 and0-20cm, all TC pairs share a. Table7 2024TC repeats Table6 and is below SOC: source anomaly, literal values retained with no repair. Methods depth mismatch documented.
Numbers
treatment 18.3 vs. control 18.6 g/kg (-1.613 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 18.8 vs. control 18.6 g/kg (+1.075 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 18.7 vs. control 18.6 g/kg (+0.5376 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 18.4 vs. control 18.6 g/kg (-1.075 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 16.7 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-3.468 %)
C/N ratio
= 11
=no effect
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments vs. CK, untreated no-film controlnot significant · 0–20 cm · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · PE,BF45,BF60,BF80 versus CK in reported0-5 and0-20cm; all C/N pairs a/a, headline numerical increases not significant; methods depth mismatch documented.
Numbers
treatment 12 vs. control 11.9 (+0.8403 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 12.2 vs. control 11.9 (+2.521 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 12 vs. control 11.9 (+0.8403 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 11.7 vs. control 11.9 (-1.681 %) · 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 11.3 vs. control 11.2 (+0.8929 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 16 vs. control 10.4 kg/hm2/mm (+53.85 %) · 2024 · BF45
treatment 15.4 vs. control 10.4 kg/hm2/mm (+48.08 %) · 2024 · BF60
treatment 16.3 vs. control 10.4 kg/hm2/mm (+56.73 %) · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 10
“Overall, IWUE increased by 48–101% under BFs and by 75–123% under PE relative to CK.”
=no effect
BF80 vs. PE (BN), conventional black polyethylene filmnot significant · 2023 and2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · BF80 versus PE; Table4 PE a/BF80 ab both years, numerical11.0-11.7% PE advantage not significant.
Numbers
treatment 16.3 vs. control 18.1 kg/hm2/mm (-9.945 %) · 2023
treatment 16.3 vs. control 18.2 kg/hm2/mm (-10.44 %) · 2024
Source · p. 11
“PE | 9691.4 ± 915.2 a | | 535 | 18.1 ± 1.7 a | 9030.7 ± 750.8 a | 497 | 18.2 ± 1.5 a”
Source · p. 11
“BF80 | 9475.4 ± 910.5 ab | | 580 | 16.3 ± 1.6 ab | 8847.7 ± 377.6 a | 544 | 16.3 ± 0.7 ab”
· 0–5 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 1.5 vs. control 1.5 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 1.5 vs. control 1.5 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.5 g/kg (-6.667 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.5 g/kg (-6.667 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF80
treatment 2.9 vs. control 3.1 g/kg (-6.452 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 3 vs. control 3.1 g/kg (-3.226 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 3 vs. control 3.1 g/kg (-3.226 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 3.1 vs. control 3.1 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 2.9 vs. control 3 g/kg (-3.333 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 2.9 vs. control 3 g/kg (-3.333 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 2.9 vs. control 3 g/kg (-3.333 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 11
“total N (TN) under BF treatments tended to be slightly lower than CK (about 3–7% reduction)”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.6 ± 0.10 a | 29.5 ± 1.36 a | 3.0 ± 0.02 abc | 17.3 ± 0.17 a | 11.2 ± 0.12 a”
Source · p. 12
“BF60 | | 2.7 ± 0.09 a | 31.3 ± 0.94 a | 2.9 ± 0.12 cd | 17.0 ± 0.47 a | 11.8 ± 0.16 a”
↓decrease
BF45 vs. CK, untreated no-film controlsignificant · 0–20 cm · 2024 · Heilongjiang Water Conservancy Science and Technology Experiment Research Center · BF45 versus CK, Table7 reported0-20cm (methods5-20cm), BF45 d versus CK abc disjoint at Duncan.05. Contradicts abstract broad TNincrease, agrees Results decline.
Numbers
treatment 2.8 vs. control 3 g/kg (-6.667 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024
Source · p. 11
“total N (TN) under BF treatments tended to be slightly lower than CK (about 3–7% reduction)”
Source · p. 12
“BF45 | | 2.6 ± 0.10 a | 30.8 ± 1.02 a | 2.8 ± 0.11 d | 16.8 ± 0.35 a | 11.6 ± 0.54 a”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.6 ± 0.10 a | 29.5 ± 1.36 a | 3.0 ± 0.02 abc | 17.3 ± 0.17 a | 11.2 ± 0.12 a”
treatment 4.63 vs. control 1.99 m2/m2 (+132.7 %) · 2023 jointing-booting · BF45
treatment 4.87 vs. control 1.99 m2/m2 (+144.7 %) · 2023 jointing-booting · BF60
treatment 5.13 vs. control 1.99 m2/m2 (+157.8 %) · 2023 jointing-booting · BF80
treatment 6.71 vs. control 2.89 m2/m2 (+132.2 %) · 2023 heading-flowering · PE
treatment 5.06 vs. control 2.89 m2/m2 (+75.09 %) · 2023 heading-flowering · BF45
treatment 5.55 vs. control 2.89 m2/m2 (+92.04 %) · 2023 heading-flowering · BF60
treatment 5.94 vs. control 2.89 m2/m2 (+105.5 %) · 2023 heading-flowering · BF80
treatment 4.04 vs. control 1.59 m2/m2 (+154.1 %) · 2023 ripening · PE
treatment 2.85 vs. control 1.59 m2/m2 (+79.25 %) · 2023 ripening · BF45
treatment 3.38 vs. control 1.59 m2/m2 (+112.6 %) · 2023 ripening · BF60
treatment 3.42 vs. control 1.59 m2/m2 (+115.1 %) · 2023 ripening · BF80
treatment 2.89 vs. control 1.6 m2/m2 (+80.62 %) · 2024 tillering · PE
treatment 2.38 vs. control 1.6 m2/m2 (+48.75 %) · 2024 tillering · BF45
treatment 2.27 vs. control 1.6 m2/m2 (+41.87 %) · 2024 tillering · BF60
treatment 2.45 vs. control 1.6 m2/m2 (+53.13 %) · 2024 tillering · BF80
treatment 5.03 vs. control 3.15 m2/m2 (+59.68 %) · 2024 jointing-booting · PE
treatment 4.73 vs. control 3.15 m2/m2 (+50.16 %) · 2024 jointing-booting · BF45
treatment 4.65 vs. control 3.15 m2/m2 (+47.62 %) · 2024 jointing-booting · BF60
treatment 4.89 vs. control 3.15 m2/m2 (+55.24 %) · 2024 jointing-booting · BF80
treatment 5.9 vs. control 3.92 m2/m2 (+50.51 %) · 2024 heading-flowering · PE
treatment 5.11 vs. control 3.92 m2/m2 (+30.36 %) · 2024 heading-flowering · BF45
treatment 4.96 vs. control 3.92 m2/m2 (+26.53 %) · 2024 heading-flowering · BF60
treatment 5.18 vs. control 3.92 m2/m2 (+32.14 %) · 2024 heading-flowering · BF80
treatment 3.53 vs. control 2.24 m2/m2 (+57.59 %) · 2024 ripening · PE
treatment 3.01 vs. control 2.24 m2/m2 (+34.37 %) · 2024 ripening · BF45
treatment 2.89 vs. control 2.24 m2/m2 (+29.02 %) · 2024 ripening · BF60
treatment 3.07 vs. control 2.24 m2/m2 (+37.05 %) · 2024 ripening · BF80
Source · p. 8
“Across both years, mulching significantly increased LAI at tillering, jointing–booting, and heading–flowering compared with CK.”
· 2024 late tillering · BF80
percent_change 152 · 2023 late tillering · PE
percent_change 84 · 2024 late tillering · PE
treatment 461.6 vs. control 264.8 10^4/hm2 (+74.32 %) · 2023 maturity · PE/BN
treatment 357.9 vs. control 264.8 10^4/hm2 (+35.16 %) · 2023 maturity · BF45
treatment 406.5 vs. control 264.8 10^4/hm2 (+53.51 %) · 2023 maturity · BF60
treatment 438 vs. control 264.8 10^4/hm2 (+65.41 %) · 2023 maturity · BF80
treatment 400.3 vs. control 231 10^4/hm2 (+73.29 %) · 2024 maturity · PE/BN
treatment 335.6 vs. control 231 10^4/hm2 (+45.28 %) · 2024 maturity · BF45
treatment 328.7 vs. control 231 10^4/hm2 (+42.29 %) · 2024 maturity · BF60
treatment 338.9 vs. control 231 10^4/hm2 (+46.71 %) · 2024 maturity · BF80
Source · p. 9
“Mulching treatments significantly increased both the total tiller number during the tillering stage and the number of effective tillers at maturity compared with CK”
· 2023 heading-flowering · BF80
percent_change 43 · 2023 maturity · BF45
percent_change 56 · 2023 maturity · BF60
percent_change 58 · 2023 maturity · BF80
percent_change 34 · 2024 maturity · BF80
percent_change 83 · 2023 maturity · PE
percent_change 46 · 2024 maturity · PE
Source · p. 9
“Across both years, mulching significantly increased dry matter compared with CK, with PE consistently producing the highest values.”
· 2023 maturity · BF80
Source · p. 9
“Across both years, mulching significantly increased dry matter compared with CK, with PE consistently producing the highest values.”
Source · p. 9
“belowground dry matter increased by 56.7%, 61.1%, and 72.5% at heading–flowering and by 29.1%, 39.2%, and 43.4% at maturity”
Source · p. 10
“Mulching increased yield mainly by increasing the number of productive panicles and grains per panicle”
· 0–5 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 16.2 vs. control 16.3 g/kg (-0.6135 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 16.1 vs. control 16.3 g/kg (-1.227 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 16.1 vs. control 16.3 g/kg (-1.227 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF80
treatment 30.4 vs. control 29.7 g/kg (+2.357 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 30.6 vs. control 29.7 g/kg (+3.03 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 30.7 vs. control 29.7 g/kg (+3.367 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 31.3 vs. control 29.7 g/kg (+5.387 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 31.5 vs. control 29.5 g/kg (+6.78 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 30.8 vs. control 29.5 g/kg (+4.407 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 31.3 vs. control 29.5 g/kg (+6.102 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 31.7 vs. control 29.5 g/kg (+7.458 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 11
“In the surface 0–5 cm layer, mulching treatments had little effect on soil organic carbon (SOC), total carbon (TC), or nitrogen fractions”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.7 ± 0.08 a | 29.7 ± 0.26 a | 3.1 ± 0.05 ab | 36.8 ± 0.31 a | 12.0 ± 0.28 a”
Source · p. 12
“BF80 | | 2.8 ± 0.02 a | 31.3 ± 0.74 a | 3.1 ± 0.04 a | 36.7 ± 0.56 a | 11.8 ± 0.16 a”
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 1.4 vs. control 1.4 g/kg (0 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF80
treatment 2.7 vs. control 2.7 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 2.7 vs. control 2.7 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 2.7 vs. control 2.7 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 2.8 vs. control 2.7 g/kg (+3.704 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 2.6 vs. control 2.6 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 2.6 vs. control 2.6 g/kg (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 2.7 vs. control 2.6 g/kg (+3.846 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 2.7 vs. control 2.6 g/kg (+3.846 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 11
“Organic N (Org-N) was also marginally higher under BFs than under CK and PE in 2024”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.6 ± 0.10 a | 29.5 ± 1.36 a | 3.0 ± 0.02 abc | 17.3 ± 0.17 a | 11.2 ± 0.12 a”
Source · p. 12
“BF80 | | 2.7 ± 1.31 a | 31.7 ± 2.22 a | 2.9 ± 0.22 cd | 17.0 ± 0.28 a | 11.8 ± 0.49 a”
· 0–5 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 16.8 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-2.89 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 17 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-1.734 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 17 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-1.734 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF80
treatment 35.6 vs. control 36.8 g/kg (-3.261 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 36.1 vs. control 36.8 g/kg (-1.902 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 36.5 vs. control 36.8 g/kg (-0.8152 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 36.7 vs. control 36.8 g/kg (-0.2717 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 16.7 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-3.468 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · PE; anomalous printedTC retained
treatment 16.8 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-2.89 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF45; anomalous printedTC retained
treatment 17 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-1.734 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF60; anomalous printedTC retained
treatment 17 vs. control 17.3 g/kg (-1.734 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF80; anomalous printedTC retained
Source · p. 11
“For TC, values under BFs were similar to CK”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.7 ± 0.08 a | 29.7 ± 0.26 a | 3.1 ± 0.05 ab | 36.8 ± 0.31 a | 12.0 ± 0.28 a”
Source · p. 12
“PE | | 2.7 ± 0.15 a | 30.4 ± 0.32 a | 2.9 ± 0.11 ab | 35.6 ± 1.76 abc | 12.1 ± 0.16 a”
treatment 11.6 vs. control 11.2 (+3.571 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 11.8 vs. control 11.2 (+5.357 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 11.8 vs. control 11.2 (+5.357 %) · 0–5 cm · 2024 · BF80
treatment 12.1 vs. control 12 (+0.8333 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · PE
treatment 12.1 vs. control 12 (+0.8333 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF45
treatment 12 vs. control 12 (0 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF60
treatment 11.8 vs. control 12 (-1.667 %) · 0–20 cm · 2023 · BF80
treatment 11.3 vs. control 11.2 (+0.8929 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · PE
treatment 11.6 vs. control 11.2 (+3.571 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF45
treatment 11.8 vs. control 11.2 (+5.357 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF60
treatment 11.8 vs. control 11.2 (+5.357 %) · 0–20 cm · 2024 · BF80
Source · p. 12
“The C:N ratio was close to 12.0 for all treatments in 2023, but in 2024 it increased under BFs by roughly 3–5% compared with CK and PE.”
Source · p. 12
“CK | | 2.6 ± 0.10 a | 29.5 ± 1.36 a | 3.0 ± 0.02 abc | 17.3 ± 0.17 a | 11.2 ± 0.12 a”
Source · p. 12
“BF80 | | 2.7 ± 1.31 a | 31.7 ± 2.22 a | 2.9 ± 0.22 cd | 17.0 ± 0.28 a | 11.8 ± 0.49 a”
→Plastic mulch
PE and BFs, agreeing individual mulched treatments→Plastic mulch