Agronomy · 2025
Effects of Water Application Frequency and Water Use Efficiency Under Deficit Irrigation on Maize Yield in Xinjiang
Duan, T., Zhang, L., Wang, G., Liang, F.
Export
Effects of Water Application Frequency and Water Use Efficie…
Abstract
Water conservation is critical for global maize production, particularly in arid regions where water scarcity, exacerbated by climate change, threatens conventional irrigation sustainability. Optimizing irrigation strategies to reconcile water productivity and yield remains a key scientific challenge in water-limited agriculture. This four-year study (2018–2021) evaluated integrated irrigation management that combined frequency and volume adjustments. A field experiment compared three strategies: high-frequency limited irrigation (HL: 2400 m3·hm−2), low-frequency conventional irrigation (LC: 2400 m3·hm−2), and high-frequency conventional irrigation (HC: 4800 m3·hm−2). The four-year mean yield showed that HL (10,793.78 kg·hm−2) had a non-significant 18.2% numerical advantage over LC (9129.11 kg·hm−2, p > 0.05). The WUE for HL reached 3.63 kg·m−3, representing an 18.6% numerical increase compared to LC (3.06 kg·m−3; p > 0.05). Physiological parameters (plant height + 2.6%, leaf area + 9.9%, SPAD + 1.5%) showed marginal improvements in HL, yet lacked both statistical significance (p > 0.05) and strong yield correlation. Multi-year analyses confirmed no statistically distinguishable differences between strategies (p > 0.05), demonstrating that irrigation frequency adjustments alone cannot reliably enhance drought resilience. These findings caution against advocating for HL as a superior practice, given the statistical equivalence between HL and LC despite water savings, and the non-significant yield gap between HL and HC. Future research must establish causality through models integrating real-time soil–crop–climate feedback prior to recommending altered irrigation regimes.
Show all
Water conservation is critical for global maize production, particularly in arid regions where water scarcity, exacerbated by climate change, threatens conventional irrigation sustainability. Optimizing irrigation strategies to reconcile water productivity and yield remains a key scientific challenge in water-limited agriculture. This four-year study (2018–2021) evaluated integrated irrigation management that combined frequency and volume adjustments. A field experiment compared three strategies: high-frequency limited irrigation (HL: 2400 m3·hm−2), low-frequency conventional irrigation (LC: 2400 m3·hm−2), and high-frequency conventional irrigation (HC: 4800 m3·hm−2). The four-year mean yield showed that HL (10,793.78 kg·hm−2) had a non-significant 18.2% numerical advantage over LC (9129.11 kg·hm−2, p > 0.05). The WUE for HL reached 3.63 kg·m−3, representing an 18.6% numerical increase compared to LC (3.06 kg·m−3; p > 0.05). Physiological parameters (plant height + 2.6%, leaf area + 9.9%, SPAD + 1.5%) showed marginal improvements in HL, yet lacked both statistical significance (p > 0.05) and strong yield correlation. Multi-year analyses confirmed no statistically distinguishable differences between strategies (p > 0.05), demonstrating that irrigation frequency adjustments alone cannot reliably enhance drought resilience. These findings caution against advocating for HL as a superior practice, given the statistical equivalence between HL and LC despite water savings, and the non-significant yield gap between HL and HC. Future research must establish causality through models integrating real-time soil–crop–climate feedback prior to recommending altered irrigation regimes.
Water conservation is critical for global maize production, particularly in arid regions where water scarcity, exacerbated by climate change, threatens conventional irrigation sustainability. Optimizing irrigation strategies to reconcile water productivity and yield remains a key scientific challenge in water-limited agriculture. This four-year study (2018–2021) evaluated integrated irrigation management that combined frequency and volume adjustments. A field experiment compared three strategies: high-frequency limited irrigation (HL: 2400 m3·hm−2), low-frequency conventional irrigation (LC: 2400 m3·hm−2), and high-frequency conventional irrigation (HC: 4800 m3·hm−2). The four-year mean yield showed that HL (10,793.78 kg·hm−2) had a non-significant 18.2% numerical advantage over LC (9129.11 kg·hm−2, p > 0.05). The WUE for HL reached 3.63 kg·m−3, representing an 18.6% numerical increase compared to LC (3.06 kg·m−3; p > 0.05). Physiological parameters (plant height + 2.6%, leaf area + 9.9%, SPAD + 1.5%) showed marginal improvements in HL, yet lacked both statistical significance (p > 0.05) and strong yield correlation. Multi-year analyses confirmed no statistically distinguishable differences between strategies (p > 0.05), demonstrating that irrigation frequency adjustments alone cannot reliably enhance drought resilience. These findings caution against advocating for HL as a superior practice, given the statistical equivalence between HL and LC despite water savings, and the non-significant yield gap between HL and HC. Future research must establish causality through models integrating real-time soil–crop–climate feedback prior to recommending altered irrigation regimes.
Similar papers
Effects of Supplemental Irrigation Based on Testing Soil Moisture on Dry Matter Accumulation and Distribution and Water Use Efficiency in Winter Wheat
Han et al. · 2010 · Acta Agronomica Sinica
9 shared concepts
12 findings1 site
Acidified Biochar as a Soil Amendment to Drought Stressed (Vicia faba L.) Plants: Influences on Growth and Productivity, Nutrient Status, and Water Use Efficiency
Abd El-Mageed et al. · 2021 · Agronomy
9 shared concepts
40 findings1 site
Effects of Soil Water Deficit at Different Growth Stages on Maize Growth, Yield, and Water Use Efficiency under Alternate Partial Root-Zone Irrigation
Cheng et al. · 2021 · Water
9 shared concepts
