Sustainability · 2022
Rice Growth Performance, Nutrient Use Efficiency and Changes in Soil Properties Influenced by Biochar under Alternate Wetting and Drying Irrigation
Haque, A. N. A., Uddin, M. K., Sulaiman, M. F., Amin, A. M., Hossain, M., Solaiman, Z. M., Mosharrof, M.
Export
Rice Growth Performance, Nutrient Use Efficiency and Changes…
Abstract
Water-saving irrigation occasionally causes an inconsequential yield loss in rice; thereby, biochar incorporation in this context has great scope due to its properties, including the release of nutrients and improving soil physicochemical properties. An experiment was conducted to investigate the effect of biochar combined with fertilizer on physiological response, water and nutrient efficiency of rice and changes in biochemical properties of soil under AWD (alternate wetting and drying) irrigation system. Two types of irrigation practice, such as AWD and CF (continuous flooding), and four types of fertilizer combination, namely T1: 25% Rice husk biochar (RHB) + 75% of recommended fertilizer dose (RFD); T2: 25% oil palm empty fruit bunch biochar (EFBB) + 75% of RFD; T3: 100% RFD; and T0: 0% biochar and fertilizer, were assigned to assess their impacts. The AWD irrigation produced a sharply reduced grain yield (210.58 g pot−1) compared to CF irrigation (218.04 g pot−1), whereas the biochar combination treatments T1 and T2 produced greater yields (260.27 and 252.12 g pot−1, respectively), which were up to 12.5% higher than RFD. Within AWD, irrigation water usage by T1 and T2 (98.50 and 102.37 g L−1, respectively) was profoundly reduced by up to 28.8%, with improved water use efficiency (WUE). The main effect of biochar treatment T1 and T2 also increased photosynthesis rate during vegetative and maturing stage (up to 17.6 and 24.4%, respectively), in addition to boosting agronomic efficiency of nitrogen (N), phosphorous (P) and potassium (K) compared to RFD (T3). Nevertheless, T1 and T2 significantly enhanced the total carbon and nitrogen; dehydrogenase and urease enzyme activities also increased in both irrigation regimes. The results reveal that the integrated application of RHB and EFBB with fertilizer in the AWD regime significantly reduces irrigation water usage and improves nutrient use efficiency, WUE and soil biochemical properties with a minimum yield penalty for rice.
Show all
Water-saving irrigation occasionally causes an inconsequential yield loss in rice; thereby, biochar incorporation in this context has great scope due to its properties, including the release of nutrients and improving soil physicochemical properties. An experiment was conducted to investigate the effect of biochar combined with fertilizer on physiological response, water and nutrient efficiency of rice and changes in biochemical properties of soil under AWD (alternate wetting and drying) irrigation system. Two types of irrigation practice, such as AWD and CF (continuous flooding), and four types of fertilizer combination, namely T1: 25% Rice husk biochar (RHB) + 75% of recommended fertilizer dose (RFD); T2: 25% oil palm empty fruit bunch biochar (EFBB) + 75% of RFD; T3: 100% RFD; and T0: 0% biochar and fertilizer, were assigned to assess their impacts. The AWD irrigation produced a sharply reduced grain yield (210.58 g pot−1) compared to CF irrigation (218.04 g pot−1), whereas the biochar combination treatments T1 and T2 produced greater yields (260.27 and 252.12 g pot−1, respectively), which were up to 12.5% higher than RFD. Within AWD, irrigation water usage by T1 and T2 (98.50 and 102.37 g L−1, respectively) was profoundly reduced by up to 28.8%, with improved water use efficiency (WUE). The main effect of biochar treatment T1 and T2 also increased photosynthesis rate during vegetative and maturing stage (up to 17.6 and 24.4%, respectively), in addition to boosting agronomic efficiency of nitrogen (N), phosphorous (P) and potassium (K) compared to RFD (T3). Nevertheless, T1 and T2 significantly enhanced the total carbon and nitrogen; dehydrogenase and urease enzyme activities also increased in both irrigation regimes. The results reveal that the integrated application of RHB and EFBB with fertilizer in the AWD regime significantly reduces irrigation water usage and improves nutrient use efficiency, WUE and soil biochemical properties with a minimum yield penalty for rice.
Water-saving irrigation occasionally causes an inconsequential yield loss in rice; thereby, biochar incorporation in this context has great scope due to its properties, including the release of nutrients and improving soil physicochemical properties. An experiment was conducted to investigate the effect of biochar combined with fertilizer on physiological response, water and nutrient efficiency of rice and changes in biochemical properties of soil under AWD (alternate wetting and drying) irrigation system. Two types of irrigation practice, such as AWD and CF (continuous flooding), and four types of fertilizer combination, namely T1: 25% Rice husk biochar (RHB) + 75% of recommended fertilizer dose (RFD); T2: 25% oil palm empty fruit bunch biochar (EFBB) + 75% of RFD; T3: 100% RFD; and T0: 0% biochar and fertilizer, were assigned to assess their impacts. The AWD irrigation produced a sharply reduced grain yield (210.58 g pot−1) compared to CF irrigation (218.04 g pot−1), whereas the biochar combination treatments T1 and T2 produced greater yields (260.27 and 252.12 g pot−1, respectively), which were up to 12.5% higher than RFD. Within AWD, irrigation water usage by T1 and T2 (98.50 and 102.37 g L−1, respectively) was profoundly reduced by up to 28.8%, with improved water use efficiency (WUE). The main effect of biochar treatment T1 and T2 also increased photosynthesis rate during vegetative and maturing stage (up to 17.6 and 24.4%, respectively), in addition to boosting agronomic efficiency of nitrogen (N), phosphorous (P) and potassium (K) compared to RFD (T3). Nevertheless, T1 and T2 significantly enhanced the total carbon and nitrogen; dehydrogenase and urease enzyme activities also increased in both irrigation regimes. The results reveal that the integrated application of RHB and EFBB with fertilizer in the AWD regime significantly reduces irrigation water usage and improves nutrient use efficiency, WUE and soil biochemical properties with a minimum yield penalty for rice.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
grain yield
↑ 1↓ 12
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 260.3 vs. control 231.3 g pot-1 (+12.54 %) · RHB
- treatment 252.1 vs. control 231.3 g pot-1 (+9.015 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 7 “greater grain yield was produced by T1”
Source · p. 7 “T1 27.88 a 208.39 a 260.27 a 327.34 a”
Source · p. 7 “T2 28.15 a 208.31 a 252.12 a 319.36 a”
Source · p. 7 “T3 24.97 b 201.00 b 231.27 b 304.83 b”
- decrease
AWD vs. CFsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Irrigation main effect, marginal acrossT0-T3
Numbers
- treatment 210.6 vs. control 218 g pot-1 (-3.421 %)
Source · p. 7 “AWD 22.81 b 196.08 b 210.58 b 270.25 b CF 23.63 a 200.52 a 218.04 a 278.97 a”
water use efficiency
↑ 22
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately under AWD, whole crop WUE
Numbers
- treatment 5.91 vs. control 4.77 g L-1 (+23.9 %) · RHB
- treatment 5.49 vs. control 4.77 g L-1 (+15.09 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 8 “A significantly improved WUE was exhibited by T1 and T2”
- increase
AWD vs. CFsignificant · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Whole crop WUE, irrigation comparison separately withinT0-T3; distinct same-treatment pair letters in Fig1B
Numbers
- treatment 5.91 vs. control 4.56 g L-1 (+29.61 %) · T1 RHB
- treatment 5.49 vs. control 4.3 g L-1 (+27.67 %) · T2 EFBB
- treatment 4.77 vs. control 3.93 g L-1 (+21.37 %) · T3 RFD
- treatment 3.64 vs. control 3.01 g L-1 (+20.93 %) · T0
Source · p. 8 “Significantly increased WUE was observed in AWD irrigation with the same biochar treatment over the CF regime.”
straw yield
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 327.3 vs. control 304.8 g pot-1 (+7.384 %) · RHB
- treatment 319.4 vs. control 304.8 g pot-1 (+4.767 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 7 “a similar trend of treatment variation by different biochar treatments was also observed in the straw yield production”
Source · p. 7 “T1 27.88 a 208.39 a 260.27 a 327.34 a”
Source · p. 7 “T2 28.15 a 208.31 a 252.12 a 319.36 a”
Source · p. 7 “T3 24.97 b 201.00 b 231.27 b 304.83 b”
nitrogen uptake
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations; grain+straw N uptake
Numbers
- treatment 6.57 vs. control 5.19 g pot-1 (+26.59 %) · RHB
- treatment 6.19 vs. control 5.19 g pot-1 (+19.27 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 8 “the higher N uptake was observed in T1”
Source · p. 9 “T1 | 6.57 a | 2.10 a | 5.87 a”
Source · p. 9 “T2 | 6.19 a | 1.85 b | 6.01 a”
Source · p. 9 “T3 | 5.19 b | 1.59 c | 4.98 b”
phosphorus uptake
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations; grain+straw P uptake
Numbers
- treatment 2.1 vs. control 1.59 g pot-1 (+32.08 %) · RHB
- treatment 1.85 vs. control 1.59 g pot-1 (+16.35 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 9 “T1 \> T2 \> T3 \> T0 with values 2.10, 1.85, 1.59 and 0.58”
potassium uptake
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · Harvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations; grain+straw K uptake
Numbers
- treatment 5.87 vs. control 4.98 g pot-1 (+17.87 %) · RHB
- treatment 6.01 vs. control 4.98 g pot-1 (+20.68 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 9 “significantly enhanced K uptake was found in T1 and T2”
Source · p. 9 “T3 | 5.19 b | 1.59 c | 4.98 b”
total carbon
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm, both biochars separately within each irrigation; totalC concentration
Numbers
- treatment 61.98 vs. control 45.33 g kg-1 (+36.73 %) · RHB,AWD
- treatment 68.65 vs. control 45.33 g kg-1 (+51.44 %) · EFBB,AWD
- treatment 62.55 vs. control 54.9 g kg-1 (+13.93 %) · RHB,CF
- treatment 69.18 vs. control 54.9 g kg-1 (+26.01 %) · EFBB,CF
Source · p. 11 “T1 | 61.98 b | 3.03 bc”
Source · p. 11 “T2 | 68.65 a | 3.55 a”
Source · p. 11 “AWD | T3 | 45.33 d | 2.03 d”
Source · p. 11 “T1 | 62.55 ab | 3.23 ab”
Source · p. 11 “T2 | 69.18 a | 3.65 a”
Source · p. 11 “CF | T3 | 54.90 c | 2.68 c”
total nitrogen
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm, both biochars separately within each irrigation; totalN concentration
Numbers
- treatment 3.03 vs. control 2.03 g kg-1 (+49.26 %) · RHB,AWD
- treatment 3.55 vs. control 2.03 g kg-1 (+74.88 %) · EFBB,AWD
- treatment 3.23 vs. control 2.68 g kg-1 (+20.52 %) · RHB,CF
- treatment 3.65 vs. control 2.68 g kg-1 (+36.19 %) · EFBB,CF
Source · p. 11 “T1 | 61.98 b | 3.03 bc”
Source · p. 11 “T2 | 68.65 a | 3.55 a”
Source · p. 11 “AWD | T3 | 45.33 d | 2.03 d”
Source · p. 11 “T1 | 62.55 ab | 3.23 ab”
Source · p. 11 “T2 | 69.18 a | 3.65 a”
Source · p. 11 “CF | T3 | 54.90 c | 2.68 c”
pH
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm; both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 6.25 vs. control 5.33 (+17.26 %) · RHB
- treatment 6.51 vs. control 5.33 (+22.14 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 12 “T2 exhibited maximum pH (6.51), followed by T1 (6.25), which was significantly greater than T3 (5.33)”
CEC
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm; both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 18.4 vs. control 16.5 cmolc(+) kg-1 (+11.52 %) · RHB
- treatment 18.38 vs. control 16.5 cmolc(+) kg-1 (+11.39 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 12 “T1 | 6.25 b | 18.40 a | 14.61 a | 2.49 b”
Source · p. 12 “T2 | 6.51 a | 18.38 a | 13.68 b | 3.60 a”
Source · p. 12 “T3 | 5.33 c | 16.50 b | 10.80 c | 1.90 c”
available P
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm; both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 14.61 vs. control 10.8 mg kg-1 (+35.28 %) · RHB
- treatment 13.68 vs. control 10.8 mg kg-1 (+26.67 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 12 “maximum available P was found in T1 (14.61 mg kg−1), followed by T2 (13.68 mg kg−1) and T3 (10.80 mg kg−1)”
exchangeable K
↑ 11
- increase
T1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variants vs. T3:100% RFDsignificant · 0–15 cm · Postharvest98DAT · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · 0-15cm; both biochars separately, marginal across irrigations
Numbers
- treatment 2.49 vs. control 1.9 cmolc(+) kg-1 (+31.05 %) · RHB
- treatment 3.6 vs. control 1.9 cmolc(+) kg-1 (+89.47 %) · EFBB
Source · p. 12 “T1 | 6.25 b | 18.40 a | 14.61 a | 2.49 b”
Source · p. 12 “T2 | 6.51 a | 18.38 a | 13.68 b | 3.60 a”
Source · p. 12 “T3 | 5.33 c | 16.50 b | 10.80 c | 1.90 c”
irrigation water volume
↓ 11
- decrease
AWD vs. CFsignificant · TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse · Whole crop period, irrigation comparison separately atT0,T1,T2,T3; every same-treatment pair distinct letters in Fig1A
Numbers
- treatment 98.5 vs. control 130.4 L (-24.46 %) · T1 RHB
- treatment 102.4 vs. control 135.1 L (-24.23 %) · T2 EFBB
- treatment 68.92 vs. control 90.22 L (-23.61 %) · T0
Source · p. 8 “in the same biochar treatment case, CF-treated Pots showed significantly greater irrigation water consumption than AWD irrigation.”
Source · p. 15 “T3 with AWD reduced only 19.5% of irrigation water.”
Set-up
Treatments
- integrated use of biochar with fertilizerBiochar
- T1:25% RHB+75% RFDBiocharT2:25% EFBB+75% RFDBiocharT3:100% RFDInorganic fertilizerT0:no biochar and chemical fertilizerNo soil amendmentT1 andT2, agreeing biochar-fertilizer variantsBiochar
- irrigation regimesIrrigation
- AWDAlternate wetting and drying (AWD)CFFlood irrigation
Measured
- photosynthesis ratePhotosynthesis
- Unit
- µmol m-2 s-1
- Method
- LI6400XT,25/86DAT
- stomatal conductance
- Unit
- mmol m-2 s-1
- transpiration rate
- Unit
- mmol m-2 s-1
- grain yieldYield
- Unit
- g pot-1
- straw yieldYield
- Unit
- g pot-1
- number of tillers hill-1Tiller number per plant
- Unit
- tillers hill-1
- grain numbers panicle-1Grain number
- Unit
- grains panicle-1
- irrigation water volumeIrrigation water requirement
- Unit
- L
- Method
- Total applied water after transplanting until harvest
- water use efficiencyIrrigation water use efficiency
- Unit
- g L-1
- Method
- Biological grain+straw yield/total irrigation water
- nitrogen uptakeAboveground plant Nitrogen uptake
- Unit
- g pot-1
- Method
- Grain+straw yield times nutrient concentration
- phosphorus uptakeAboveground plant Phosphorus uptake
- Unit
- g pot-1
- potassium uptakePlant K uptake
- Unit
- g pot-1
- agronomic N use efficiencyAgronomic nitrogen use efficiency
- Unit
- g g-1
- agronomic P use efficiencyAgronomic phosphorus use efficiency
- Unit
- g g-1
- agronomic K use efficiencyAgronomic potassium use efficiency
- Unit
- g g-1
- dehydrogenase activityDehydrogenase
- Unit
- µg TPF g-1 dry soil24h-1
- urease activityUrease
- Unit
- µg NH4-N g-1 dry soil3h-1
- acid phosphatase activityAcid phosphatase
- Unit
- µg p-NPP g-1 dry soil h-1
- total carbon
- Unit
- g kg-1
- total nitrogen
- Unit
- g kg-1
- pH
- CECCation exchange capacity
- Unit
- cmolc(+) kg-1
- Method
- Ammonium acetate leaching
- available PAvailable phosphorus
- Unit
- mg kg-1
- exchangeable KExchangeable/available potassium
- Unit
- cmolc(+) kg-1
Sites
TanjungKarang paddy soil; Universiti Putra Malaysia glasshouse
- Location
- TanjungKarang, Kuala Selangor, Malaysia (soil origin)Universiti Putra Malaysia, Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia (glasshouse; longitude101°71′ invalid as printed)
- Land use
- paddy fieldRice fields
- Management on the whole site
- rice MR297Rice
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–15 cm | – | – | 5.14 | – | – |
Similar papers
Impact of Organic Amendment with Alternate Wetting and Drying Irrigation on Rice Yield, Water Use Efficiency and Physicochemical Properties of Soil
Haque et al. · 2021 · Agronomy
16 shared concepts
15 findings1 site
Integrated Nutrient Management for Rice Yield, Soil Fertility, and Carbon Sequestration
Urmi et al. · 2022 · Plants
14 shared concepts
26 findings1 site
Long-term effects of integrated organic and inorganic fertilization on soil properties, nutrient use efficiency, and crop yield in a rice–wheat system
Sharma et al. · 2026 · Frontiers in Soil Science
12 shared concepts
30 findings1 site
Strategic management of nano-fertilizers for sustainable rice yield, grain quality, and soil health
Sahoo et al. · 2024 · Frontiers in Environmental Science
12 shared concepts
21 findings1 site
Microbial consortia enhance wheat productivity, plant nutrition and soil fertility in Vertisols of Central India
Pradhan, Mitra & Sahu · 2026 · Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
11 shared concepts
24 findings1 site
