Journal of Soil Science and Environmental Management · 2017
Effect of compost and earthworm production on soil properties, growth and dry matter yield of maize in crude oil degraded soil
Nweke, I. A.
Export
Effect of compost and earthworm production on soil propertie…
Abstract
No abstract in the library.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
available P
↑ 1↓ 12
- increase
PC vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots
Numbers
- treatment 30.6 vs. control 18 mg/kg (+70 %)
Source · p. 6 “The available P content of the treated soils was not enhanced except for PC pots, which showed rapid increase in the available P content.”
- decrease
GC and PGC, agreeing P decreases vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · GC12.40/PGC9.80c vsDS18.00b mg/kg, both differences exceed2.68LSD.
Numbers
- treatment 12.4 vs. control 18 mg/kg (-31.11 %) · GC
- treatment 9.8 vs. control 18 mg/kg (-45.56 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “GC | 7.02 b | 0.24 a | 2.72 a | 98 b | 12.40 c”
Source · p. 5 “PGC | 7.62 b | 0.12 a | 2.58 b | 97 b | 9.80 c”
Source · p. 6 “The P content obtained from DS and CP were statistically similar but better than the values obtain from PGC treated pots.”
maize height
↑ 11
- increase
PC and PGC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 4 and 6 weeks after planting · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · Individual pairs exceed LSD6.64cm(4WAP)/10.28cm(6WAP); all pots inoculated earthworms. PC24.83/48.19,PGC26.53/47.43 versus DS9.81/13.03cm.
Numbers
- treatment 24.83 vs. control 9.81 cm (+153.1 %) · 4WAP · PC
- treatment 48.19 vs. control 13.03 cm (+269.8 %) · 6WAP · PC
- treatment 26.53 vs. control 9.81 cm (+170.4 %) · 4WAP · PGC
- treatment 47.43 vs. control 13.03 cm (+264 %) · 6WAP · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The value of maize height recorded in PGC and PC at 4 and 6 WAP were statistical similar, but significantly better than the other treatments.”
number of leaves
↑ 11
- increase
PC, GC and PGC, agreeing manure-compost pairs vs. DSsignificant · 4 and 6WAP · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC7.38/10.13,GC7.13/9.25,PGC7.75/10.13 versus DS4.50/6.38leaves; LSD1.82/1.57, each pair passes; CP does not.
Numbers
- treatment 7.38 vs. control 4.5 leaves/plant (+64 %) · 4WAP · PC
- treatment 10.13 vs. control 6.38 leaves/plant (+58.78 %) · 6WAP · PC
- treatment 7.13 vs. control 4.5 leaves/plant (+58.44 %) · 4WAP · GC
- treatment 9.25 vs. control 6.38 leaves/plant (+44.98 %) · 6WAP · GC
- treatment 7.75 vs. control 4.5 leaves/plant (+72.22 %) · 4WAP · PGC
- treatment 10.13 vs. control 6.38 leaves/plant (+58.78 %) · 6WAP · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The number of leaves and leaf area in 4 and 6 WAP follow the trend of maize height results”
Source · p. 4 “DS | 6.68 a | 9.81 b | 13.03 c | 3.25 b | 4.50 b | 6.38 b”
leaf area
↑ 11
- increase
PC and PGC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 4 and 6WAP · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC150.0/292.94,PGC144.3/266.92 versus DS34.68/43.78cm2, LSD66.13/56.90. Each pair passes.
Numbers
- treatment 150 vs. control 34.68 cm2 (+332.5 %) · 4WAP · PC
- treatment 292.9 vs. control 43.78 cm2 (+569.1 %) · 6WAP · PC
- treatment 144.3 vs. control 34.68 cm2 (+316.1 %) · 4WAP · PGC
- treatment 266.9 vs. control 43.78 cm2 (+509.7 %) · 6WAP · PGC
Source · p. 5 “PC and PGC were at par in all the growth parameters assessed in this study, but competitively and significantly (P < 0.05) performed better than the other treatments.”
shoot dry matter yield
↑ 11
- increase
PC, GC and PGC, agreeing manure-compost pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC77.87,GC24.65,PGC74.30 versus DS.43g/kg; LSD18.24 all pass; no uncertainty stated.
Numbers
- treatment 77.87 vs. control 0.43 g/kg (+18,010 %) · PC
- treatment 24.65 vs. control 0.43 g/kg (+5,633 %) · GC
- treatment 74.3 vs. control 0.43 g/kg (+17,180 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The result of the shoot and root dried matter yield showed that PC and PGC performed much better than the other amendments.”
Source · p. 4 “GC | 10.73 a | 15.51 b | 26.78 b | 4.13 b | 7.13 a | 9.25 a | 37.43 c | 66.95 b | 107.5 b | 24.65 b | 10.82 a”
root dry matter yield
↑ 11
- increase
PC and PGC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC19.09,PGC15.13 versusDS.03g/kg, LSD11.37 both pass.
Numbers
- treatment 19.09 vs. control 0.03 g/kg (+63,530 %) · PC
- treatment 15.13 vs. control 0.03 g/kg (+50,330 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The result of the shoot and root dried matter yield showed that PC and PGC performed much better than the other amendments.”
number of earthworm survived
↑ 11
- increase
CP and GC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP14.75,GC36.50 vsDS0earthworms/pot, LSD11.33 both pass; PC7.25/PGC8 fail. Counts include offspring, not percent survival of original10.
Numbers
- treatment 14.75 vs. control 0 number/pot · CP
- treatment 36.5 vs. control 0 number/pot · GC
Source · p. 5 “The zero (0) value recorded in DS pots showed that no earthworm survived to harvest in DS”
Source · p. 5 “GC and CP maybe considered as the best medium for earthworm production under the crude oil degraded soil.”
earthworm biomass
↑ 11
- increase
CP and GC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP6.00,GC3.50 vsDS0g/pot, LSD2.35 both pass. PC1.18/PGC1.48 fail.
Numbers
- treatment 6 vs. control 0 g/pot · CP
- treatment 3.5 vs. control 0 g/pot · GC
Source · p. 5 “GC and CP maybe considered as the best medium for earthworm production under the crude oil degraded soil.”
Source · p. 4 “Earthworm biomass at harvest (g/pot)”
pH
↑ 11
- increase
all compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP6.76 PC8.34 GC7.02 PGC7.62 vsDS5.79, LSD.74 all individual pairs pass.
Numbers
- treatment 6.76 vs. control 5.79 pH (+16.75 %) · CP
- treatment 8.34 vs. control 5.79 pH (+44.04 %) · PC
- treatment 7.02 vs. control 5.79 pH (+21.24 %) · GC
- treatment 7.62 vs. control 5.79 pH (+31.61 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The pH changed from acidic medium of DS through neutral to alkaline medium observed in PC treated pots.”
organic matter
↑ 11
- increase
all compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP2.02 PC1.32 GC2.72 PGC2.58 vsDS.91%, LSD.10 all individual pairs pass.
Numbers
- treatment 2.02 vs. control 0.91 % (+122 %) · CP
- treatment 1.32 vs. control 0.91 % (+45.05 %) · PC
- treatment 2.72 vs. control 0.91 % (+198.9 %) · GC
- treatment 2.58 vs. control 0.91 % (+183.5 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “The organic matter (OM) content of the treated soils were very significantly (P<0.05) improved.”
nitrogen
= 11
- no effect
all compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairs vs. DSnot significant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP.28 PC.56 GC.24 PGC.12 vsDS.32% all share a in Table4, no omnibus null propagated.
Numbers
- treatment 0.28 vs. control 0.32 % (-12.5 %) · CP
- treatment 0.56 vs. control 0.32 % (+75 %) · PC
- treatment 0.24 vs. control 0.32 % (-25 %) · GC
- treatment 0.12 vs. control 0.32 % (-62.5 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “there was significant (P < 0.05) difference among the treatments except for the result obtained for nitrogen (N) and base saturation (BS).”
base saturation
= 11
- no effect
all compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairs vs. DSnot significant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP95 PC99 GC98 PGC97 vsDS85%, all share b in Table4.
Numbers
- treatment 95 vs. control 85 % (+11.76 %) · CP
- treatment 99 vs. control 85 % (+16.47 %) · PC
- treatment 98 vs. control 85 % (+15.29 %) · GC
- treatment 97 vs. control 85 % (+14.12 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “there was significant (P < 0.05) difference among the treatments except for the result obtained for nitrogen (N) and base saturation (BS).”
exchangeable Mg
↓ 11
- decrease
PC and PGC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC1.35c/PGC1.20d vsDS1.63b cmol/kg; differences>.08LSD, not chemical enhancement.
Numbers
- treatment 1.35 vs. control 1.63 cmol/kg (-17.18 %) · PC
- treatment 1.2 vs. control 1.63 cmol/kg (-26.38 %) · PGC
Source · p. 5 “PC | 8.34 a | 0.56 a | 1.32 d | 99 b | 30.60 a | 3.60 bcd | 1.35 c”
Source · p. 5 “PGC | 7.62 b | 0.12 a | 2.58 b | 97 b | 9.80 c | 3.20 d | 1.20 d”
exchangeable K
↑ 11
- increase
GC vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · GC.12a vsDS.07b cmol/kg, difference>.02LSD. Printed41.67% uses alternative denominator; not computed here.
Numbers
- treatment 0.12 vs. control 0.07 cmol/kg (+71.43 %)
Source · p. 6 “Similar to Mg, the exchangeable K of GC was improved by 41.67% by the application of compost and earthworm production.”
exchangeable acidity
↓ 11
- decrease
all compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · CP.32 PC.08 GC.16 PGC.16 vsDS1.12cmol/kg; all exceed.07LSD. Impossible1300%decrease not entered.
Numbers
- treatment 0.32 vs. control 1.12 cmol/kg (-71.43 %) · CP
- treatment 0.08 vs. control 1.12 cmol/kg (-92.86 %) · PC
- treatment 0.16 vs. control 1.12 cmol/kg (-85.71 %) · GC
- treatment 0.16 vs. control 1.12 cmol/kg (-85.71 %) · PGC
Source · p. 6 “The EA and ECEC values of the degraded soil were higher than the values obtained from the other treatments.”
ECEC
↓ 11
- decrease
PC and PGC, agreeing individual pairs vs. DSsignificant · 8week harvest · Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots · PC5.42b/PGC4.70b vsDS7.28a cmol/kg; differences>.99LSD.
Numbers
- treatment 5.42 vs. control 7.28 cmol/kg (-25.55 %) · PC
- treatment 4.7 vs. control 7.28 cmol/kg (-35.44 %) · PGC
Source · p. 6 “The EA and ECEC values of the degraded soil were higher than the values obtained from the other treatments.”
Source · p. 5 “PC | 8.34 a | 0.56 a | 1.32 d | 99 b | 30.60 a | 3.60 bcd | 1.35 c | 0.04 d | 0.08 abcd | 0.08 d | 5.42 b”
Set-up
Treatments
- compost materialsCompost
- DSNo compostCPCompostPCPoultry manure and litterGCPig manurePGCCompostall compost materials, agreeing individual DS pairsCompostPC and PGC, agreeing individual pairsCompostPC, GC and PGC, agreeing manure-compost pairsCompostCP and GC, agreeing individual pairsCompostGC and PGC, agreeing P decreasesCompost
Measured
- maize heightPlant height
- Unit
- cm
- number of leavesLeaf number
- Unit
- leaves/plant
- leaf area
- Unit
- cm2
- shoot dry matter yieldAboveground biomass
- Unit
- g/kg
- Method
- oven dried24h
- root dry matter yieldRoot biomass
- Unit
- g/kg
- number of earthworm survivedClitellata/Oligochaeta/Earthworms
- Unit
- number/pot
- earthworm biomassClitellata/Oligochaeta/Earthworms
- Unit
- g/pot
- pH
- Method
- 1:2.5soil:water
- organic matterSoil organic matter
- Unit
- %
- nitrogenTotal Nitrogen
- Unit
- %
- Method
- semi-micro Kjeldahl
- base saturation
- Unit
- %
- available PAvailable phosphorus
- Unit
- mg/kg
- Method
- Bray II
- exchangeable CaExchangeable Ca2+
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- exchangeable MgExchangeable Mg2+
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- exchangeable KExchangeable/available potassium
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- exchangeable NaExchangeable Na+
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- exchangeable acidityExchange acidity
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- Method
- McLean titrimetric
- ECECCation exchange capacity
- Unit
- cmol/kg
- Method
- sum exchangeable bases plus exchangeable acidity
- siltSilt content
- Unit
- %
- clayClay content
- Unit
- %
Sites
Asa soil / Igbariam Campus pots
- Location
- Asa, Ukwaeast local government area, Abia State, Nigeria (source soil)Faculty of Agriculture, Chukwuemeka Odimegwu Ojukwu University, Igbariam Campus, Anambra State (greenhouse)6.23° N, 6.75° E
- Climate
- 26.5–27 °C mean annual temperature1,800–2,500 mm annual precipitation
- Land use
- abandoned cropland affected by oil spillageArable land
- Management on the whole site
- maize orba super IIMaize/Corn/Zea mays, Eudrilus eugenae inoculationEarthworm addition
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–30 cm | Sandy clay loam | 26 % | 5.05 | 0.65 g/kg (Table1; prose says %) | – |
Similar papers
Effects of four organic amendments on soil physiochemical properties and yield of maize (Zea mays) and cowpea (Vigna unguiculata) intercrop in Awka, southeastern Nigeria
Onunwa et al. · 2021 · Agro-Science
14 shared concepts
14 findings1 site
Influence of Wood Ash Concentration on Coastal Plain Soil, Growth and Yield of Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) in a Humid Tropical Zone of South Eastern Nigeria
Okon, Sunday & Umoh · 2024 · AKSU Journal of Agriculture and Food Sciences
14 shared concepts
20 findings1 site
Seasonal Impacts of Organic Fertilizers, Cover Crop Residues, and Composts on Soil Health Indicators in Sandy Soils: A Case Study with Organic Celery
Ray & Zhao · 2025 · Agronomy
12 shared concepts
41 findings1 site
Long term effects of manure, charcoal and mineral fertilization on crop production and fertility on a highly weathered Central Amazonian upland soil
Steiner et al. · 2007 · Plant and Soil
12 shared concepts
26 findings1 site
Organic Manuring on Fruits and Vegetable Production and Soil Properties in Landmark University, Omu - Aran, South - West Nigeria
O et al. · 2017 · Nigerian Journal of Soil Science
13 shared concepts
17 findings2 sites
