East African Journal of Agriculture and Biotechnology · 2026
Assessing the Impact of Soil Erosion and Nutrient Loss under Different Land Uses in Fragile Agro-Ecosystems of Rukiga District in Uganda
Nuwagira, U., Kagoro-Rugunda, G., Wangalwa, R.
Export
Assessing the Impact of Soil Erosion and Nutrient Loss under…
Abstract
Soil erosion poses a major threat to soil fertility and agricultural productivity in fragile agro-ecosystems of Sub-Saharan Africa, particularly on steep cultivated hillsides. In Rwamucucu Subcounty, Rukiga District, Uganda, unsustainable land use and rudimentary farming practices accelerate soil and nutrient losses, undermining crop production. This study aimed to quantify soil and associated nutrient losses under different land uses and soil management practices in erosion-prone areas. An experimental design using 4 × 2 m runoff plots was employed during the rainy season for four consecutive weeks across selected land use categories: terracing, contour cropping, no soil conservation practice, eucalyptus plantation, and natural grass cover. Eroded sediments were collected and analysed for key physico-chemical properties using standard laboratory procedures. Results showed significant variation (p < 0.05) in soil loss among land uses and management practices. Eucalyptus plantations recorded the highest soil loss (484.5 ± 43.8 kg/ha), followed by crop fields without conservation practices (beans (366.1 ± 25.7 kg/ha), bananas (371.3 ± 24.6 kg/ha), and potatoes (342.0 ± 17.83 kg/ha). Contour cropping moderately reduced soil loss, while terracing further lowered erosion, with banana fields under terracing recording 218.3 ± 24.8 kg/ha. Natural grass cover exhibited the least soil loss (116.05 ± 15.32 kg/ha). Substantial losses of soil organic matter and essential nutrients, nitrogen, available phosphorus, potassium, and magnesium were observed across all treatments, with the highest percentage losses generally occurring under no conservation practice and eucalyptus plantations. For example, available phosphorus loss reached up to 99.15 ± 0.26 kg/ha under eucalyptus, while exchangeable potassium losses exceeded 99% in some non-conserved crop fields. Potato-grown fields consistently exhibited higher nutrient losses compared to beans and bananas. These findings demonstrate that soil erosion significantly depletes soil fertility, particularly under poor land management and certain plantation systems. The study shows the critical importance of adopting effective soil conservation measures, such as terracing and contour cropping, to reduce erosion, enhance nutrient retention, and promote sustainable agricultural productivity in erosion-prone highland landscapes.
Show all
Soil erosion poses a major threat to soil fertility and agricultural productivity in fragile agro-ecosystems of Sub-Saharan Africa, particularly on steep cultivated hillsides. In Rwamucucu Subcounty, Rukiga District, Uganda, unsustainable land use and rudimentary farming practices accelerate soil and nutrient losses, undermining crop production. This study aimed to quantify soil and associated nutrient losses under different land uses and soil management practices in erosion-prone areas. An experimental design using 4 × 2 m runoff plots was employed during the rainy season for four consecutive weeks across selected land use categories: terracing, contour cropping, no soil conservation practice, eucalyptus plantation, and natural grass cover. Eroded sediments were collected and analysed for key physico-chemical properties using standard laboratory procedures. Results showed significant variation (p < 0.05) in soil loss among land uses and management practices. Eucalyptus plantations recorded the highest soil loss (484.5 ± 43.8 kg/ha), followed by crop fields without conservation practices (beans (366.1 ± 25.7 kg/ha), bananas (371.3 ± 24.6 kg/ha), and potatoes (342.0 ± 17.83 kg/ha). Contour cropping moderately reduced soil loss, while terracing further lowered erosion, with banana fields under terracing recording 218.3 ± 24.8 kg/ha. Natural grass cover exhibited the least soil loss (116.05 ± 15.32 kg/ha). Substantial losses of soil organic matter and essential nutrients, nitrogen, available phosphorus, potassium, and magnesium were observed across all treatments, with the highest percentage losses generally occurring under no conservation practice and eucalyptus plantations. For example, available phosphorus loss reached up to 99.15 ± 0.26 kg/ha under eucalyptus, while exchangeable potassium losses exceeded 99% in some non-conserved crop fields. Potato-grown fields consistently exhibited higher nutrient losses compared to beans and bananas. These findings demonstrate that soil erosion significantly depletes soil fertility, particularly under poor land management and certain plantation systems. The study shows the critical importance of adopting effective soil conservation measures, such as terracing and contour cropping, to reduce erosion, enhance nutrient retention, and promote sustainable agricultural productivity in erosion-prone highland landscapes.
Soil erosion poses a major threat to soil fertility and agricultural productivity in fragile agro-ecosystems of Sub-Saharan Africa, particularly on steep cultivated hillsides. In Rwamucucu Subcounty, Rukiga District, Uganda, unsustainable land use and rudimentary farming practices accelerate soil and nutrient losses, undermining crop production. This study aimed to quantify soil and associated nutrient losses under different land uses and soil management practices in erosion-prone areas. An experimental design using 4 × 2 m runoff plots was employed during the rainy season for four consecutive weeks across selected land use categories: terracing, contour cropping, no soil conservation practice, eucalyptus plantation, and natural grass cover. Eroded sediments were collected and analysed for key physico-chemical properties using standard laboratory procedures. Results showed significant variation (p < 0.05) in soil loss among land uses and management practices. Eucalyptus plantations recorded the highest soil loss (484.5 ± 43.8 kg/ha), followed by crop fields without conservation practices (beans (366.1 ± 25.7 kg/ha), bananas (371.3 ± 24.6 kg/ha), and potatoes (342.0 ± 17.83 kg/ha). Contour cropping moderately reduced soil loss, while terracing further lowered erosion, with banana fields under terracing recording 218.3 ± 24.8 kg/ha. Natural grass cover exhibited the least soil loss (116.05 ± 15.32 kg/ha). Substantial losses of soil organic matter and essential nutrients, nitrogen, available phosphorus, potassium, and magnesium were observed across all treatments, with the highest percentage losses generally occurring under no conservation practice and eucalyptus plantations. For example, available phosphorus loss reached up to 99.15 ± 0.26 kg/ha under eucalyptus, while exchangeable potassium losses exceeded 99% in some non-conserved crop fields. Potato-grown fields consistently exhibited higher nutrient losses compared to beans and bananas. These findings demonstrate that soil erosion significantly depletes soil fertility, particularly under poor land management and certain plantation systems. The study shows the critical importance of adopting effective soil conservation measures, such as terracing and contour cropping, to reduce erosion, enhance nutrient retention, and promote sustainable agricultural productivity in erosion-prone highland landscapes.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
eroded soil
↑ 2↓ 24
- decrease
Terracing vs. No management practicesignificant · 6 September–6 October2022, four weeks · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Banana and bean fields only; respective LSD lettersf/bc,de/ab. Potato sharesc, separate null. Existing management, no random treatment assignment stated.
Numbers
- treatment 218.3 vs. control 371.3 kg/ha (-41.21 %) · banana
- treatment 276.6 vs. control 366.1 kg/ha (-24.46 %) · beans
Source · p. 6 “The terracing method had the least recorded amount of eroded soil as compared to other methods for crops”
Source · p. 6 “| Terracing | Banana | 218.3±24.8 f |”
Source · p. 6 “| No management practice | Banana | 371.3±24.6 bc |”
- decrease
Contour cropping vs. No management practicesignificant · 6 September–6 October2022, four weeks · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Banana fields; contour ef/no-managementbc distinct. Beans printed32.033versusprose320.33 omitted as ambiguous.
Numbers
- treatment 261.3 vs. control 371.3 kg/ha (-29.63 %)
Source · p. 6 “| Contour | Banana | 261.3±43.7 ef |”
Source · p. 6 “| No management practice | Banana | 371.3±24.6 bc |”
- increase
Eucalyptus plantation vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022, four weeks · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Eucalyptus plantation versus natural grass; lettersa/g. Spatial land-use comparison, no temporal conversion experiment.
Numbers
- treatment 484.5 vs. control 116.1 kg/ha (+317.5 %)
Source · p. 10 “growing eucalyptus plantations on steep slopes led to more erosion than when the hills were left with their natural grasses.”
- increase
Banana, beans and potato cropland vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022, four weeks · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Cropland without soil conservation versus natural grass; banana/beans/potato individual lettersbc/ab/bc versusg. Agreeing individual pairs, not omnibus or pooled contrast.
Numbers
- treatment 371.3 vs. control 116.1 kg/ha (+219.9 %) · banana
- treatment 366.1 vs. control 116.1 kg/ha (+215.5 %) · beans
- treatment 342.2 vs. control 116.1 kg/ha (+194.9 %) · potato
Source · p. 6 “natural grass recorded the least amount of eroded soil”
Source · p. 6 “crops grown in fields with no soil conservation practice lose a lot of soil as a result of soil erosion.”
percentage loss of organic matter
↑ 2↓ 13
- decrease
Terracing vs. No management practicesignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Banana fields only, SOM relativepercentage loss; terracec/nomanagementab. Initial soil0-20cm, eroded sediment depth unspecified; not a0-20cm stock. Prose kg/ha conflicts title percentage loss.
Numbers
- treatment 78.43 vs. control 93.1 % relative concentration loss (title; prose kg/ha) (-15.76 %)
Source · p. 8 “banana (78.43±17.17 kg/ha)”
Source · p. 8 “banana-grown fields (93.10±11.19 kg/ha)”
Source · p. 9 “Banana 78.43”
Source · p. 10 “Banana 93.10”
- increase
Eucalyptus plantation vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Eucalyptus versus naturalgrass relativeSOMconcentrationloss; lettersa/bc. Table98.53 overrides prose98.65.
Numbers
- treatment 98.53 vs. control 87.46 % relative concentration loss (+12.66 %)
Source · p. 10 “Eucalypt 98.53±0.20a”
Source · p. 10 “Natural 87.46±10.1”
Source · p. 8 “natural grass lost organic matter (87.46±10.17 kg/ha).”
- increase
Beans and potato cropland vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Bean and potato cropland without conservation versus naturalgrass; individual SOMlettersa/bc. Bananaab sharesb withgrassbc, excluded. Relative concentrationloss, not area massloss.
Numbers
- treatment 97.79 vs. control 87.46 % relative concentration loss (+11.81 %) · beans
- treatment 98.65 vs. control 87.46 % relative concentration loss (+12.79 %) · potato
Source · p. 11 “The highest percentage loss of organic matter was evidenced in no soil management practice for potato-grown fields, followed by bean and banana-grown fields.”
Source · p. 10 “Natural 87.46±10.1”
Source · p. 10 “Beans 97.79±3.37a”
Source · p. 10 “Potatoes 98.65±0.21a”
percentage loss of available phosphorus
↑ 22
- increase
Eucalyptus plantation vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Eucalyptus versus naturalgrass relativeavailablePloss; lettersa/d. Tabletitlepercentage, headermg/kg andprosekg/ha conflict; not a massload.
Numbers
- treatment 99.15 vs. control 61.88 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (+60.23 %)
Source · p. 9 “highest percentage loss of available phosphorus”
Source · p. 10 “99.15 93.84”
Source · p. 10 “± 0.26a 2.99b ± 61.88 97.47 ± 2.08”
- increase
Banana, beans and potato cropland vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Unconserved banana/beans/potato cropland versus naturalgrass; individual Plettersbc/ab/ab versusd. Relativepercentageloss (tabletitle) with conflictingmg/kgheader/kg/haprose.
Numbers
- treatment 89.47 vs. control 61.88 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (+44.59 %) · banana
- treatment 93.74 vs. control 61.88 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (+51.49 %) · beans
- treatment 97.71 vs. control 61.88 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (+57.9 %) · potato
Source · p. 11 “The study showed that the percentage loss of available phosphorus was high in potato-grown fields, followed by bean and banana-grown fields”
Source · p. 10 “13.86d”
Source · p. 10 “± 0.26a 2.99b ± 61.88 97.47 ± 2.08”
percentage loss of exchangeable potassium
↓ 11
- decrease
Eucalyptus plantation vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Eucalyptus versus naturalgrass relativeexchangeableKloss; actual lettersb/a, decrease despite broad highnutrientlossclaim. Percentage title, cmol/kgheader,kg/haprose conflict.
Numbers
- treatment 93.84 vs. control 97.47 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (-3.724 %)
Source · p. 9 “(93.84±2.99 kg/ha) and (97.47±2.08 kg/ha).”
Source · p. 10 “99.15 93.84”
Source · p. 10 “± 0.26a 2.99b ± 61.88 97.47 ± 2.08”
percentage loss of nitrogen
↑ 11
- increase
Beans and potato cropland vs. Natural grasssignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Unconserved bean/potato cropland versus naturalgrass; individual Nlettersa/ab versusd. Banana d/grassd excluded. Relativeconcentrationloss, not massload.
Numbers
- treatment 96.34 vs. control 86.72 % relative concentration loss (+11.09 %) · beans
- treatment 91.31 vs. control 86.72 % relative concentration loss (+5.293 %) · potato
Source · p. 8 “The percentage of nitrogen lost under no soil conservation practice was highest in bean-grown fields (96.34±3.63 kg/ha), followed by potato-grown fields (91.31±5.39 kg/ha)”
Source · p. 10 “Natural 87.46±10.1 86.72”
Source · p. 10 “4.99d”
percentage loss of exchangeable magnesium
↓ 11
- decrease
Terracing vs. No management practicesignificant · 6 September–6 October2022 · Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District · Potato fields only; terrace Mglettersb/no-managementa; source titlepercentageloss, headercmol/kg, prosekg/ha. Othercrop pairs sharea.
Numbers
- treatment 79.26 vs. control 91.35 % relative concentration loss (title; source units conflict) (-13.23 %)
Source · p. 9 “79.26 ± 19.91b”
Source · p. 10 “91.35 ± 5.04a”
Source · p. 12 “The percentage loss of exchangeable magnesium was highest in fields with no soil conservation measures.”
Set-up
Treatments
- soil conservation practicesSoil conservation measures
- No management practiceNo soil conservation measuresTerracingTerracesContour croppingContour tillage
- land use/coverLand use
- Natural grassNatural grasslandEucalyptus plantationBroad-leaved forestBanana, beans and potato croplandArable landBeans and potato croplandArable land
Measured
- eroded soilErosion
- Unit
- kg/ha
- Method
- Runoff sediment collected weekly for four weeks in4x2m plots.
- percentage loss of organic matterSoil organic matter
- Unit
- % loss relative to original concentration (table title; prose incorrectly kg/ha)
- Method
- Initial soil versus eroded-sediment concentration, relative percentage loss.
- percentage loss of available phosphorusAvailable phosphorus
- Unit
- % loss relative to original concentration (title; header mg/kg; prose kg/ha)
- percentage loss of exchangeable potassiumExchangeable/available potassium
- Unit
- % loss relative to original concentration (title; header cmol/kg; prose kg/ha)
- percentage loss of nitrogenTotal Nitrogen
- Unit
- % loss relative to original concentration (title; prose kg/ha)
- percentage loss of exchangeable magnesiumExchangeable Mg2+
- Unit
- % loss relative to original concentration (title; header cmol/kg; prose kg/ha)
Sites
Rwamucucu sub-county, Rukiga District
- Location
- Rukiga district, western Uganda (district reference coordinate)KanyabutegyeRwabatunguNyaruhanga
- Climate
- 1,000–1,300 mm annual precipitation
- Land use
- crop fieldsArable land, natural grassNatural grassland, eucalyptus woodlotsBroad-leaved forest
Similar papers
Global analysis of cover management and support practice factors that control soil erosion and conservation
Ebabu et al. · 2022 · International Soil and Water Conservation Research
7 shared concepts
19 findings1 site
The Effect of Soil Conservation Measures on Runoff, Soil Erosion, TN, and TP Losses Based on Experimental Runoff Plots in Northern China
Fang · 2021 · Water
5 shared concepts
11 findings1 site
Land use, management and climate effects on runoff and soil loss responses in the highlands of Ethiopia
Ebabu et al. · 2023 · Journal of Environmental Management
5 shared concepts
13 findings4 sites
Assessment of Soil Redistribution Following Land Rehabilitation with an Apple Orchard in Hilly Regions of Central Iran
Ayoubi et al. · 2022 · Agronomy
7 shared concepts
10 findings1 site
Assessing the impacts of different land uses and soil and water conservation interventions on runoff and sediment yield at different scales in the central highlands of Ethiopia
Yaekob et al. · 2020 · Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems
4 shared concepts
11 findings2 sites
