This study was conducted in 2020-2021 in the field conditions of Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University. The study, effects of different compost (tomato-apple-grape) applications on yield, quality, soil properties of tomato plants, and second crop spinach cultivation were examined under field conditions. The experiment was carried out according to randomised blocks design with 3 replications. In this study, 18 different treatments including control (with/without fertilizer) [(T0) Control (no fertilizer); (T1) Control + NPK; (T2) 10 t/ha Tomato compost; (T3) 20 t/ha Tomato compost; (T4) 10 t/ha Apple compost; (T5) 20 t/ha Apple compost; (T6) 10 t/ha Grape compost; (T7) 20 t/ha Grape compost; (T8) 10 t/ha Farmyard manure; (T9) 20 t/ha Farmyard manure; (T10) 10 t/ha Tomato compost + NPK; (T11) 20 t/ha Tomato compost + NPK; (T12) 10 t/ha Apple compost + NPK; (T13) 20 t/ha Apple compost + NPK; (T14) 10 t/ha Grape compost + NPK; (T15) 20 t/ha Grape compost + NPK; (T16) 10 t/ha Farmyard manure + NPK and (T17) 20 t/ha Farmyard manure + NPK] were applied. At the end of the study, compost treatments provided a significant yield increase compared to the control treatment. Especially tomato, and grape compost applied at the same dose provided more increase in yield compared to farmyard manure. NPK fertilizer application, together with compost or farmyard manure, also increased yield. In spinach cultivation in the same plots after tomato harvest, the highest biomass was obtained from the plots with farmyard manure, and grape compost application. When spinach was grown without any fertilisation after farmyard manure, and compost application, 555.76% increase in biomass was obtained in farmyard manure application compared to control, and 376.25% increase compared to NPK fertilisation, 541.53% increase was obtained in compost application compared to control, and 366.62% increase was obtained compared to NPK fertilisation. The use of compost in tomato, and second crop spinach cultivation under field conditions provided a significant yield increase in both tomato, and spinach. At the same time, it was found that using compost and farmyard manure increased the soil's organic matter content and levels of some macronutrients, but only had a limited effect on the soil's pH value. Examining the quality characteristics of tomato fruit revealed that the applications had a positive effect on important parameters such as soluble dry matter content. These results demonstrate that composting not only increases yield, but also has a lasting positive effect on the cultivation of subsequent crops by improving soil fertility and product quality.
This study was conducted in 2020-2021 in the field conditions of Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University. The study, effects of different compost (tomato-apple-grape) applications on yield, quality, soil properties of tomato plants, and second crop spinach cultivation were examined under field conditions. The experiment was carried out according to randomised blocks design with 3 replications. In this study, 18 different treatments including control (with/without fertilizer) [(T0) Control (no fertilizer); (T1) Control + NPK; (T2) 10 t/ha Tomato compost; (T3) 20 t/ha Tomato compost; (T4) 10 t/ha Apple compost; (T5) 20 t/ha Apple compost; (T6) 10 t/ha Grape compost; (T7) 20 t/ha Grape compost; (T8) 10 t/ha Farmyard manure; (T9) 20 t/ha Farmyard manure; (T10) 10 t/ha Tomato compost + NPK; (T11) 20 t/ha Tomato compost + NPK; (T12) 10 t/ha Apple compost + NPK; (T13) 20 t/ha Apple compost + NPK; (T14) 10 t/ha Grape compost + NPK; (T15) 20 t/ha Grape compost + NPK; (T16) 10 t/ha Farmyard manure + NPK and (T17) 20 t/ha Farmyard manure + NPK] were applied. At the end of the study, compost treatments provided a significant yield increase compared to the control treatment. Especially tomato, and grape compost applied at the same dose provided more increase in yield compared to farmyard manure. NPK fertilizer application, together with compost or farmyard manure, also increased yield. In spinach cultivation in the same plots after tomato harvest, the highest biomass was obtained from the plots with farmyard manure, and grape compost application. When spinach was grown without any fertilisation after farmyard manure, and compost application, 555.76% increase in biomass was obtained in farmyard manure application compared to control, and 376.25% increase compared to NPK fertilisation, 541.53% increase was obtained in compost application compared to control, and 366.62% increase was obtained compared to NPK fertilisation. The use of compost in tomato, and second crop spinach cultivation under field conditions provided a significant yield increase in both tomato, and spinach. At the same time, it was found that using compost and farmyard manure increased the soil's organic matter content and levels of some macronutrients, but only had a limited effect on the soil's pH value. Examining the quality characteristics of tomato fruit revealed that the applications had a positive effect on important parameters such as soluble dry matter content. These results demonstrate that composting not only increases yield, but also has a lasting positive effect on the cultivation of subsequent crops by improving soil fertility and product quality.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
Total tomato yield
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · Tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · All12 compost variants; every pair disjoint fromT0j.
Numbers
treatment 60.21 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+29.68 %) · T2
treatment 103.1 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+122.1 %) · T3
treatment 59.81 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+28.82 %) · T4
treatment 77.21 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+66.29 %) · T5
treatment 77.66 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+67.26 %) · T6
treatment 81.88 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+76.35 %) · T7
treatment 66.56 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+43.36 %) · T10
treatment 98.01 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+111.1 %) · T11
treatment 70.78 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+52.44 %) · T12
treatment 83.15 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+79.09 %) · T13
treatment 66.16 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+42.49 %) · T14
treatment 91.55 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+97.18 %) · T15
Source · p. 5
“The effects observed in marketable yield according to the treatments were also observed in total yield.”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · Tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; all disjoint letters fromT0j.
Numbers
treatment 71.77 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+54.58 %) · T8
treatment 81.39 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+75.3 %) · T9
treatment 71.85 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+54.75 %) · T16
treatment 79.19 vs. control 46.43 t/ha (+70.56 %) · T17
Source · p. 5
“The effects observed in marketable yield according to the treatments were also observed in total yield.”
Residual spinach biomass
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · Spinach after tomato harvest2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · All12 compost treatments; residual effect, no new fertilizer to spinach; all distinct letters fromT0n.
Numbers
treatment 111.2 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+73.88 %) · T2
treatment 121.6 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+90.14 %) · T3
treatment 106.3 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+66.22 %) · T4
treatment 112.7 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+76.19 %) · T5
treatment 128.5 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+100.9 %) · T6
treatment 136.5 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+113.3 %) · T7
Soil organic matter
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato harvest2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · All12 compost variants; all letters disjoint fromT0g; postharvest depth unspecified.
Numbers
treatment 3.19 vs. control 2.27 % (+40.53 %) · T2
treatment 3.24 vs. control 2.27 % (+42.73 %) · T3
treatment 3.13 vs. control 2.27 % (+37.89 %) · T4
treatment 3.26 vs. control 2.27 % (+43.61 %) · T5
treatment 3.06 vs. control 2.27 % (+34.8 %) · T6
treatment 3.2 vs. control 2.27 % (+40.97 %) · T7
treatment 3.07 vs. control 2.27 % (+35.24 %)
Soil total N
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · All12 compost variants; distinct fromT0e; postharvest depth unspecified.
Numbers
treatment 0.128 vs. control 0.12 % (+6.667 %) · T2
treatment 0.128 vs. control 0.12 % (+6.667 %) · T3
treatment 0.131 vs. control 0.12 % (+9.167 %) · T4
treatment 0.13 vs. control 0.12 % (+8.333 %) · T5
treatment 0.133 vs. control 0.12 % (+10.83 %) · T6
treatment 0.133 vs. control 0.12 % (+10.83 %) · T7
treatment 0.133 vs. control 0.12 % (+10.83 %)
Soil available P
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T3–7,T10–15 only; all distinct fromT0g. T2 sharesg, excluded table-only null. Stock computation/depth unspecified; Table10 kg P/ha as printed.
Numbers
treatment 6.85 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+8.903 %) · T3
treatment 9.21 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+46.42 %) · T4
treatment 9.28 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+47.54 %) · T5
treatment 8.71 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+38.47 %) · T6
treatment 8.63 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+37.2 %) · T7
treatment 7.52 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+19.55 %)
Soil available K
↑ 22
↑increase
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T12–15 only: apple/grape compost10/20t/ha+NPK. Table10 a versusT0c. Other compost variants sharec, no significant gain. Depth/computation unspecified, kg K/ha as printed.
Numbers
treatment 66.2 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+49.77 %) · T12
treatment 66.47 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+50.38 %) · T13
treatment 65.8 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+48.87 %) · T14
treatment 66.07 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+49.48 %) · T15
Source · p. 11
“The addition of farmyard manure, and compost to the soil in the experiment contributed significantly to the increase of NPK level in the soil.”
Soil pH
↓ 22
↓decrease
Fruit-waste compost treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T3–7,T10–15 only; Table9 b versusT0a; T2ab sharesa, excluded. Lower postharvest pH than concurrent control, despite increase over pretrial soil; depth not restated.
Numbers
treatment 7.17 vs. control 7.29 (-1.646 %) · T3
treatment 7.17 vs. control 7.29 (-1.646 %) · T4
treatment 7.16 vs. control 7.29 (-1.783 %) · T5
treatment 7.11 vs. control 7.29 (-2.469 %) · T6
treatment 7.11 vs. control 7.29 (-2.469 %) · T7
treatment 7.13 vs. control 7.29 (-2.195 %)
Marketable tomato yield
↑ 11
↑increase
T3,20t/ha tomato compost vs. T9,20t/ha farmyard manuresignificant · Tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · 20t/ha tomato compost versus20t/ha cow manure, both withoutNPK; Table4 a versusb-e. Grape superiority claim not supported.
Numbers
treatment 90.3 vs. control 74.52 t/ha (+21.18 %)
Source · p. 5
“some compost applications increased the yield more than farmyard manure”
treatment 184.2 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+187.9 %) · T10
treatment 190 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+197 %) · T11
treatment 256 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+300.2 %) · T12
treatment 274 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+328.3 %) · T13
treatment 327.3 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+411.6 %) · T14
treatment 346.4 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+441.5 %) · T15
Source · p. 12
“The use of farmyard manure, and compost provided a significant increase in second crop spinach biomass”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · Residual spinach after tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; no new fertilizer to spinach; all distinct fromT0n. Erroneous abstract555.76% increase omitted.
Numbers
treatment 132.1 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+106.5 %) · T8
treatment 140.4 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+119.5 %) · T9
treatment 352.5 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+451.1 %) · T16
treatment 355.5 vs. control 63.97 g/plant (+455.8 %) · T17
Source · p. 12
“The use of farmyard manure, and compost provided a significant increase in second crop spinach biomass”
· T10
treatment 3.2 vs. control 2.27 % (+40.97 %) · T11
treatment 2.98 vs. control 2.27 % (+31.28 %) · T12
treatment 3.19 vs. control 2.27 % (+40.53 %) · T13
treatment 2.96 vs. control 2.27 % (+30.4 %) · T14
treatment 3.21 vs. control 2.27 % (+41.41 %) · T15
Source · p. 10
“the amount of soil organic matter increased significantly depending on compost, and farmyard manure applications.”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; all distinct letters versusT0g; depth not restated.
Numbers
treatment 2.96 vs. control 2.27 % (+30.4 %) · T8
treatment 3.13 vs. control 2.27 % (+37.89 %) · T9
treatment 2.96 vs. control 2.27 % (+30.4 %) · T16
treatment 3.11 vs. control 2.27 % (+37 %) · T17
Source · p. 10
“the amount of soil organic matter increased significantly depending on compost, and farmyard manure applications.”
· T10
treatment 0.134 vs. control 0.12 % (+11.67 %) · T11
treatment 0.133 vs. control 0.12 % (+10.83 %) · T12
treatment 0.139 vs. control 0.12 % (+15.83 %) · T13
treatment 0.139 vs. control 0.12 % (+15.83 %) · T14
treatment 0.142 vs. control 0.12 % (+18.33 %) · T15
Source · p. 11
“compost, and especially farmyard manure provided an increase”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; disjoint letters versusT0e; Table10 means supersede misassigned T8/T9 means in Results.
Numbers
treatment 0.133 vs. control 0.12 % (+10.83 %) · T8
treatment 0.134 vs. control 0.12 % (+11.67 %) · T9
treatment 0.143 vs. control 0.12 % (+19.17 %) · T16
treatment 0.15 vs. control 0.12 % (+25 %) · T17
Source · p. 11
“compost, and especially farmyard manure provided an increase”
· T10
treatment 8.31 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+32.11 %) · T11
treatment 9.44 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+50.08 %) · T12
treatment 9.3 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+47.85 %) · T13
treatment 9.01 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+43.24 %) · T14
treatment 8.68 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+38 %) · T15
Source · p. 11
“The addition of farmyard manure, and compost to the soil in the experiment contributed significantly to the increase of NPK level in the soil.”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; disjoint versusT0g; Table10 kg P/ha, calculation/depth unspecified.
Numbers
treatment 9.19 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+46.1 %) · T8
treatment 9.43 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+49.92 %) · T9
treatment 9.65 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+53.42 %) · T16
treatment 9.64 vs. control 6.29 kg/ha (+53.26 %) · T17
Source · p. 11
“The application of farmyard manure to the soil increased the phosphorus accumulation more than the compost applications”
↑increase
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T9,T16,T17 only:20t/ha manure alone or10/20t+NPK; b/a versusT0c. T8bc sharesc, excluded. Depth/computation unspecified.
Numbers
treatment 50.37 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+13.96 %) · T9
treatment 66.33 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+50.07 %) · T16
treatment 66.77 vs. control 44.2 kg/ha (+51.06 %) · T17
Source · p. 11
“The application of farmyard manure to the soil increased K accumulation more than compost applications”
· T10
treatment 7.14 vs. control 7.29 (-2.058 %) · T11
treatment 7.18 vs. control 7.29 (-1.509 %) · T12
treatment 7.1 vs. control 7.29 (-2.606 %) · T13
treatment 7.13 vs. control 7.29 (-2.195 %) · T14
treatment 7.12 vs. control 7.29 (-2.332 %) · T15
Source · p. 11
“Compost applications have been found to cause a much smaller increase in soil pH than control treatments.”
↓decrease
Farmyard manure treatments, agreeing variants specified in context vs. T0, no fertilizersignificant · After tomato2021 · Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa University Research and Application Centre · T8,T9,T16,T17; Table9 b versusT0a. Postharvest depth unspecified, concurrent control comparison.
Numbers
treatment 7.1 vs. control 7.29 (-2.606 %) · T8
treatment 7.11 vs. control 7.29 (-2.469 %) · T9
treatment 7.13 vs. control 7.29 (-2.195 %) · T16
treatment 7.15 vs. control 7.29 (-1.92 %) · T17
Source · p. 10
“pH increased at a lower rate in plots where compost, and farmyard manure were used.”