Evaluating the effect of phosphogypsum on selected soil properties, and morpho-physiology, yield and phosphorus use efficiency of wheat varieties under saline-sodic soil · Knowledge Library
Evaluating the effect of phosphogypsum on selected soil properties, and morpho-physiology, yield and phosphorus use efficiency of wheat varieties under saline-sodic soil
Salt-affected soils constrain agricultural productivity, particularly in Ethiopia’s irrigated lowlands, where salinity and sodicity severely reduce crop yields. Effective reclamation strategies are therefore essential. This study evaluated the effects of phosphogypsum on soil properties, wheat morphophysiology, yield, and phosphorus-use efficiency under saline-sodic conditions at Kessem Sugar Estate. A factorial pot experiment was conducted during the 2022/23 and 2023/24 cropping seasons using different phosphogypsum rates and wheat varieties. Soil analysis before amendment and after harvest showed that phosphogypsum application markedly improved soil properties. The highest phosphogypsum rate (200% GR) reduced soil pH from 8.45 to 7.93 and exchangeable sodium percentage from 26.5% to 6.9%, while increasing exchangeable Ca, available P, and sulfate by 60.2%, 74.1%, and 159.8%, respectively. Combining 150% or 200% GR phosphogypsum with the salt-tolerant wheat variety ETBW-5879 produced the highest panicle length, seeds per spike, relative-water-content, grain yield, transpiration rate, P uptake, and P-use efficiency. Similarly, phosphogypsum at 150% and 200% GR and the ETBW-5879 variety significantly improved plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll content, biomass yield, photosynthetic rate, and water-use efficiency. Grain yield of ETBW-5879 was substantially higher than that of Gambo and Dande’a under untreated soil conditions, by 294% and 536% at 200% GR, 273% and 502% at 150% GR, and 184% and 358% at 100% GR, respectively. Even at 100% GR, phosphogypsum with ETBW-5879 produced 28% and 87% higher grain yields than phosphogypsum with Gambo and Dande’a, respectively. Overall, ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the other varieties across phosphogypsum rates. The combination of phosphogypsum at 150% GR with ETBW-5879 was the most effective treatment for improving wheat yield under saline-sodic conditions. However, field validation across diverse saline-sodic environments, including assessment of potential phosphogypsum-impurities, is recommended before large-scale adoption.
Show all
Salt-affected soils constrain agricultural productivity, particularly in Ethiopia’s irrigated lowlands, where salinity and sodicity severely reduce crop yields. Effective reclamation strategies are therefore essential. This study evaluated the effects of phosphogypsum on soil properties, wheat morphophysiology, yield, and phosphorus-use efficiency under saline-sodic conditions at Kessem Sugar Estate. A factorial pot experiment was conducted during the 2022/23 and 2023/24 cropping seasons using different phosphogypsum rates and wheat varieties. Soil analysis before amendment and after harvest showed that phosphogypsum application markedly improved soil properties. The highest phosphogypsum rate (200% GR) reduced soil pH from 8.45 to 7.93 and exchangeable sodium percentage from 26.5% to 6.9%, while increasing exchangeable Ca, available P, and sulfate by 60.2%, 74.1%, and 159.8%, respectively. Combining 150% or 200% GR phosphogypsum with the salt-tolerant wheat variety ETBW-5879 produced the highest panicle length, seeds per spike, relative-water-content, grain yield, transpiration rate, P uptake, and P-use efficiency. Similarly, phosphogypsum at 150% and 200% GR and the ETBW-5879 variety significantly improved plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll content, biomass yield, photosynthetic rate, and water-use efficiency. Grain yield of ETBW-5879 was substantially higher than that of Gambo and Dande’a under untreated soil conditions, by 294% and 536% at 200% GR, 273% and 502% at 150% GR, and 184% and 358% at 100% GR, respectively. Even at 100% GR, phosphogypsum with ETBW-5879 produced 28% and 87% higher grain yields than phosphogypsum with Gambo and Dande’a, respectively. Overall, ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the other varieties across phosphogypsum rates. The combination of phosphogypsum at 150% GR with ETBW-5879 was the most effective treatment for improving wheat yield under saline-sodic conditions. However, field validation across diverse saline-sodic environments, including assessment of potential phosphogypsum-impurities, is recommended before large-scale adoption.
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
plant height
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, a versusc/d.
Numbers
treatment 68.4 vs. control 42.8 cm (+59.81 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 67.9 vs. control 50.8 cm (+33.66 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 68.3 vs. control 42.8 cm (+59.58 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 70 vs. control 50.8 cm (+37.8 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 9
“Applying higher phosphogypsum rates and using different wheat varieties significantly increased plant height and leaf area”
Source · p. 10
“| PG/G 0% GR | 42.8 c | 50.8 d | 9.7 d | 11.0 d | 34.5 d | 35.7 d |
| PG 150% GR | 68.4 a | 67.9 a | 22.4 a | 21.9 a | 46.3 a | 44.5 a |”
Source · p. 10
“| PG 200% GR | 68.3 a | 70.0 a | 22.3 a | 21.8 a | 45.7 a | 44.6 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 61.6 vs. control 57.9 cm (+6.39 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 66 vs. control 61.5 cm (+7.317 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 61.6 vs. control 54 cm (+14.07 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 66 vs. control 54.9 cm (+20.22 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 10
“| ETBW-5879 | 61.6 a | 66.0 a | 19.2 a | 20.1 a | 42.4 a | 44.5 a |
| Gamboo | 57.9 b | 61.5 b | 16.7 b | 17.6 b | 40.7 b | 40.5 b |
| Dande’a | 54.0 c | 54.9 c | 14.2 c | 15.1 c | 37.8 c | 37.1 c |”
leaf area
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, a versusd.
Numbers
treatment 22.4 vs. control 9.7 cm2 (+130.9 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 21.9 vs. control 11 cm2 (+99.09 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 22.3 vs. control 9.7 cm2 (+129.9 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 21.8 vs. control 11 cm2 (+98.18 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 9
chlorophyll content (SPAD)
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, a versusd.
Numbers
treatment 46.3 vs. control 34.5 SPAD (+34.2 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 44.5 vs. control 35.7 SPAD (+24.65 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 45.7 vs. control 34.5 SPAD (+32.46 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 44.6 vs. control 35.7 SPAD (+24.93 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 10
aboveground dry biomass
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, a versuse/d. Table200%secondyear24.4, notprose24.9.
Numbers
treatment 17.8 vs. control 5.9 g pot-1 (+201.7 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 23.1 vs. control 7.7 g pot-1 (+200 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 17.9 vs. control 5.9 g pot-1 (+203.4 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 24.4 vs. control 7.7 g pot-1 (+216.9 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
photosynthetic rate
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, b/a versusf/d.
Numbers
treatment 13.7 vs. control 7.1 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+92.96 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 19.3 vs. control 8 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+141.3 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 14.6 vs. control 7.1 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+105.6 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 21 vs. control 8 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+162.5 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
instantaneous water-use efficiency
↑ 22
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars, ba/a versuse firstyear, a versusb secondyear.
Numbers
treatment 2.9 vs. control 2 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+45 %) · 2022/23 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 2.8 vs. control 2.2 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+27.27 %) · 2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 3 vs. control 2 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+50 %) · 2022/23 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 2.9 vs. control 2.2 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+31.82 %) · 2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
clay content
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged wheat varieties; Table1 a versusb. Source depth0–20cm, outcome depthnotstated.
Numbers
treatment 34.9 vs. control 33.8 % (+3.254 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 35 vs. control 33.8 % (+3.55 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 7
“increased the clay content from 33.8% in the control treatment to 34.5%, 34.7%, 34.9%, and 35.0%, respectively”
Source · p. 8
dispersive charge (DC)
↓ 11
↓decrease
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; all different Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 444.6 vs. control 516.7 (-13.95 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 314.5 vs. control 516.7 (-39.13 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 253.4 vs. control 516.7 (-50.96 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 192.7 vs. control 516.7 (-62.71 %)
flocculating charge (FC)
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; all different Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 80.5 vs. control 58.7 (+37.14 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 111.6 vs. control 58.7 (+90.12 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 133.6 vs. control 58.7 (+127.6 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 147.4 vs. control 58.7 (+151.1 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
net dispersive charge (NDC)
↓ 11
↓decrease
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; all different Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 364.1 vs. control 458 (-20.5 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 202.9 vs. control 458 (-55.7 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 119.8 vs. control 458 (-73.84 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 45.3 vs. control 458 (-90.11 %)
CROSS
↓ 11
↓decrease
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; all different Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 14.1 vs. control 17.2 (-18.02 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 9.6 vs. control 17.2 (-44.19 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 7.2 vs. control 17.2 (-58.14 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 5.1 vs. control 17.2 (-70.35 %)
soil pH
↓ 11
↓decrease
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; Table2 b/d/e/f versusa. Not initial-baseline comparison.
Numbers
treatment 8.34 vs. control 8.45 (-1.302 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 8.14 vs. control 8.45 (-3.669 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 8.02 vs. control 8.45 (-5.089 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 7.93 vs. control 8.45 (-6.154 %)
exchangeable sodium percentage
↓ 11
↓decrease
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; Table2 b/d/e/f versusa. Actual200%ESP8.9, abstract6.9 is wrong.
Numbers
treatment 18 vs. control 26.5 % (-32.08 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 14 vs. control 26.5 % (-47.17 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 11.7 vs. control 26.5 % (-55.85 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
soil ECe
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; ECe b/a versusc;50/100%PG sharec and are excluded.
Numbers
treatment 6.8 vs. control 6.5 dS m-1 (+4.615 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 7 vs. control 6.5 dS m-1 (+7.692 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 8
“phosphogypsum application progressively increased soil ECe by 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, and 0.5 dS m”
Source · p. 9
exchangeable calcium
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; distinct Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 26.6 vs. control 23.3 cmolc kg-1 (+14.16 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 29.1 vs. control 23.3 cmolc kg-1 (+24.89 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 31.6 vs. control 23.3 cmolc kg-1 (+35.62 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 37.4 vs. control 23.3 cmolc kg-1 (+60.52 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
available phosphorus
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; distinct Tukey letters.
Numbers
treatment 22.9 vs. control 19.2 mg kg-1 (+19.27 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 28.1 vs. control 19.2 mg kg-1 (+46.35 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 31.6 vs. control 19.2 mg kg-1 (+64.58 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 33.4 vs. control 19.2 mg kg-1 (+73.96 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
soil sulfate
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum50–200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · after second harvest2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 50–200%PG individually versus0%GR, averaged cultivars; sulfate e/c/b/a versusf.
Numbers
treatment 28.9 vs. control 22.2 meq l-1 (+30.18 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG50%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 44.1 vs. control 22.2 meq l-1 (+98.65 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG100%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 53.4 vs. control 22.2 meq l-1 (+140.5 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG150%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
treatment 57.8 vs. control 22.2 meq l-1 (+160.4 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
leaf relative water content
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, distinctTukeyletters. Not cultivar pairtests.
Numbers
treatment 71.4 vs. control 58 % (+23.1 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 74.8 vs. control 60.4 % (+23.84 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 72.5 vs. control 58 % (+25 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 74.1 vs. control 60.4 % (+22.68 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 68.1 vs. control 53.9 % (+26.35 %)
transpiration rate
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, distinctTukeyletters. Not cultivar pairtests.
Numbers
treatment 4.9 vs. control 4.2 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+16.67 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.2 vs. control 4.2 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+71.43 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 5 vs. control 4.2 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+19.05 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.6 vs. control 4.2 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+80.95 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
panicle length
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, distinctTukeyletters.
Numbers
treatment 10.4 vs. control 6.2 cm (+67.74 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 10.6 vs. control 6.8 cm (+55.88 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 10.7 vs. control 6.2 cm (+72.58 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 11.2 vs. control 6.8 cm (+64.71 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.6 vs. control 5.6 cm (+71.43 %)
seeds per spike
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, distinctTukeyletters.
Numbers
treatment 33.7 vs. control 13.6 (+147.8 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 38.2 vs. control 16.8 (+127.4 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 34.6 vs. control 13.6 (+154.4 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 39.1 vs. control 16.8 (+132.7 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 30.8 vs. control 9.7 (+217.5 %)
grain yield
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, distinctTukeyletters. Table6, not mistaken proseTable7reference.
Numbers
treatment 6.9 vs. control 2.8 g pot-1 (+146.4 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9 vs. control 3.1 g pot-1 (+190.3 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.6 vs. control 2.8 g pot-1 (+171.4 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.2 vs. control 3.1 g pot-1 (+196.8 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 5.4 vs. control 2 g pot-1 (+170 %)
total phosphorus uptake in grain and straw
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, Table7 distinctletters; grainplusstraw uptake, notroot.
Numbers
treatment 40.8 vs. control 6.4 mg pot-1 (+537.5 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 44.9 vs. control 10.1 mg pot-1 (+344.6 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 48.5 vs. control 6.4 mg pot-1 (+657.8 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 54.1 vs. control 10.1 mg pot-1 (+435.6 %)
grain P concentration
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, Table7 distinctletters.
Numbers
treatment 4,439 vs. control 1,900 mg kg-1 (+133.6 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 3,809 vs. control 2,445 mg kg-1 (+55.81 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 5,046 vs. control 1,900 mg kg-1 (+165.5 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,475 vs. control 2,445 mg kg-1 (+83.07 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,332 vs. control 1,838 mg kg-1 (+135.7 %)
straw P concentration
↑ 11
↑increase
phosphogypsum150% and200%GR vs. PG/G0%GR untreated soilsignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · 150/200%PG versusmatched0%GR within each wheatvariety; all3cultivars, Table7 distinctletters.
Numbers
treatment 515.3 vs. control 135.5 mg kg-1 (+280.3 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 404.9 vs. control 231.6 mg kg-1 (+74.83 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 554.1 vs. control 135.5 mg kg-1 (+308.9 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 462.7 vs. control 231.6 mg kg-1 (+99.78 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 496.9 vs. control 107.7 mg kg-1 (+361.4 %)
phosphorus-use efficiency (PUE)
1
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificance not stated · 2022/23, first planting season · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · Author-reported cultivar relative effects across PG50-200%GR: ETBW versusGambo andDande'a individually. PUE is apparent recovery of applied phosphorus; percent relative increase is not percentage-point difference. Figure1 confirms direction; cultivar-pair significance unreported.
“Among the tested varieties, the salt-tolerant ETBW-5879 exhibited superior performance, with PAE and PUE increases of 5.9% and
21.7%, respectively, compared with Gambo, and 13.0% and 46.7%, respectively, compared with Dande'a (figure 1).”
“Applying higher phosphogypsum rates and using different wheat varieties significantly increased plant height and leaf area”
Source · p. 10
“| PG/G 0% GR | 42.8 c | 50.8 d | 9.7 d | 11.0 d | 34.5 d | 35.7 d |
| PG 150% GR | 68.4 a | 67.9 a | 22.4 a | 21.9 a | 46.3 a | 44.5 a |”
Source · p. 10
“| PG 200% GR | 68.3 a | 70.0 a | 22.3 a | 21.8 a | 45.7 a | 44.6 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 19.2 vs. control 16.7 cm2 (+14.97 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 20.1 vs. control 17.6 cm2 (+14.2 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 19.2 vs. control 14.2 cm2 (+35.21 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 20.1 vs. control 15.1 cm2 (+33.11 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 10
“| ETBW-5879 | 61.6 a | 66.0 a | 19.2 a | 20.1 a | 42.4 a | 44.5 a |
| Gamboo | 57.9 b | 61.5 b | 16.7 b | 17.6 b | 40.7 b | 40.5 b |
| Dande’a | 54.0 c | 54.9 c | 14.2 c | 15.1 c | 37.8 c | 37.1 c |”
“Increasing the phosphogypsum rate from 50% to 200% GR raised the SPAD value”
Source · p. 10
“| PG/G 0% GR | 42.8 c | 50.8 d | 9.7 d | 11.0 d | 34.5 d | 35.7 d |
| PG 150% GR | 68.4 a | 67.9 a | 22.4 a | 21.9 a | 46.3 a | 44.5 a |”
Source · p. 10
“| PG 200% GR | 68.3 a | 70.0 a | 22.3 a | 21.8 a | 45.7 a | 44.6 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 42.4 vs. control 40.7 SPAD (+4.177 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 44.5 vs. control 40.5 SPAD (+9.877 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 42.4 vs. control 37.8 SPAD (+12.17 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 44.5 vs. control 37.1 SPAD (+19.95 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 10
“| ETBW-5879 | 61.6 a | 66.0 a | 19.2 a | 20.1 a | 42.4 a | 44.5 a |
| Gamboo | 57.9 b | 61.5 b | 16.7 b | 17.6 b | 40.7 b | 40.5 b |
| Dande’a | 54.0 c | 54.9 c | 14.2 c | 15.1 c | 37.8 c | 37.1 c |”
Source · p. 13
“higher phosphogypsum application rates combined with the salt-tolerant variety ETBW-5879 enhanced both biomass and grain yields”
Source · p. 11
“| PG/G 0% GR | | 5.9 e | 7.7 d | 7.1 f | 8.0 d | 2.0 e | 2.2 b |”
Source · p. 11
“| PG 150% | GR | 17.8 a | 23.1 a | 13.7 b | 19.3 b | 2.9 ba | 2.8 a |
| PG 200% | GR | 17.9 a | 24.4 a | 14.6 a | 21.0 a | 3.0 a | 2.9 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 14 vs. control 11.9 g pot-1 (+17.65 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 20 vs. control 16.6 g pot-1 (+20.48 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 14 vs. control 10 g pot-1 (+40 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 20 vs. control 13.3 g pot-1 (+50.38 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 11
“| ETBW-5879 | | 14.0 a | 20.0 a | 12.7 a | 17.2 a | 2.8 a | 2.9 a |
| Gamboo | | 11.9 b | 16.6 b | 10.9 b | 14.6 b | 2.6 b | 2.7 b |
| Dande’a | | 10.0 c | 13.3 c | 9.0 c | 12.6 c | 2.3 c | 2.5 c |”
Source · p. 11
“Increasing rates of phosphogypsum enhanced both parameters”
Source · p. 11
“| PG/G 0% GR | | 5.9 e | 7.7 d | 7.1 f | 8.0 d | 2.0 e | 2.2 b |”
Source · p. 11
“| PG 150% | GR | 17.8 a | 23.1 a | 13.7 b | 19.3 b | 2.9 ba | 2.8 a |
| PG 200% | GR | 17.9 a | 24.4 a | 14.6 a | 21.0 a | 3.0 a | 2.9 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 12.7 vs. control 10.9 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+16.51 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 17.2 vs. control 14.6 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+17.81 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 12.7 vs. control 9 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+41.11 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 17.2 vs. control 12.6 µmol CO2 m-2 s-1 (+36.51 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 11
“| ETBW-5879 | | 14.0 a | 20.0 a | 12.7 a | 17.2 a | 2.8 a | 2.9 a |
| Gamboo | | 11.9 b | 16.6 b | 10.9 b | 14.6 b | 2.6 b | 2.7 b |
| Dande’a | | 10.0 c | 13.3 c | 9.0 c | 12.6 c | 2.3 c | 2.5 c |”
Source · p. 11
“Increasing rates of phosphogypsum enhanced both parameters”
Source · p. 11
“| PG/G 0% GR | | 5.9 e | 7.7 d | 7.1 f | 8.0 d | 2.0 e | 2.2 b |”
Source · p. 11
“| PG 150% | GR | 17.8 a | 23.1 a | 13.7 b | 19.3 b | 2.9 ba | 2.8 a |
| PG 200% | GR | 17.9 a | 24.4 a | 14.6 a | 21.0 a | 3.0 a | 2.9 a |”
↑increase
ETBW-5879 vs. Gambo and Dande’asignificant · 2022/23 and2023/24 · KA-23 field, Kessem Sugar Estate soil in Hawassa University lath house · ETBW versus Gambo and Dande’a individually, averaged amendments; a versusb/c bothyears.
Numbers
treatment 2.8 vs. control 2.6 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+7.692 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 2.9 vs. control 2.7 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+7.407 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusGamboo; averaged amendments
treatment 2.8 vs. control 2.3 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+21.74 %) · 2022/23 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
treatment 2.9 vs. control 2.5 µmol CO2 mmol-1 H2O (+16 %) · 2023/24 · ETBW-5879 versusDande’a; averaged amendments
Source · p. 18
“ETBW-5879 consistently outperformed the others, showing superior plant height, leaf area, chlorophyll (SPAD) content, biomass accumulation, photosynthetic rate, and WUE.”
Source · p. 11
“| ETBW-5879 | | 14.0 a | 20.0 a | 12.7 a | 17.2 a | 2.8 a | 2.9 a |
| Gamboo | | 11.9 b | 16.6 b | 10.9 b | 14.6 b | 2.6 b | 2.7 b |
| Dande’a | | 10.0 c | 13.3 c | 9.0 c | 12.6 c | 2.3 c | 2.5 c |”
“| PG 150% GR | 253.4 d | 133.6 b | 119.8 d | 7.2 e | 34.9 a | 47.8 a | 17.3 a |
| PG 200% GR | 192.7 e | 147.4 a | 45.3 e | 5.1 f | 35.0 a | 47.9 a | 17.1 a |”
· after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 7
“Phosphogypsum application significantly improved soil structural stability by reducing DC, NDC, and CROSS while increasing FC.”
Source · p. 8
“| PG/G 0% GR | 516.7 a | 58.7 e | 458.0 a | 17.2 a | 33.8 b | 48.1 a | 18.1 a |
| PG 50% GR | 444.6 b | 80.5 d | 364.1 b | 14.1 b | 34.5 b | 47.9 a | 17.6 a |
| PG 100% GR | 314.5 c | 111.6 c | 202.9 c | 9.6 d | 34.7 ba | 47.5 a | 17.8 a |”
Source · p. 7
“Phosphogypsum application significantly improved soil structural stability by reducing DC, NDC, and CROSS while increasing FC.”
Source · p. 8
“| PG/G 0% GR | 516.7 a | 58.7 e | 458.0 a | 17.2 a | 33.8 b | 48.1 a | 18.1 a |
| PG 50% GR | 444.6 b | 80.5 d | 364.1 b | 14.1 b | 34.5 b | 47.9 a | 17.6 a |
| PG 100% GR | 314.5 c | 111.6 c | 202.9 c | 9.6 d | 34.7 ba | 47.5 a | 17.8 a |”
· after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 7
“Phosphogypsum application significantly improved soil structural stability by reducing DC, NDC, and CROSS while increasing FC.”
Source · p. 8
“| PG/G 0% GR | 516.7 a | 58.7 e | 458.0 a | 17.2 a | 33.8 b | 48.1 a | 18.1 a |
| PG 150% GR | 253.4 d | 133.6 b | 119.8 d | 7.2 e | 34.9 a | 47.8 a | 17.3 a |”
· after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 8
“Phosphogypsum application also significantly reduced CROSS after wheat cultivation.”
· after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 8
“Application of phosphogypsum significantly reduced soil pH and ESP”
Source · p. 9
“| PG/G | 0% GR | 8.45 a | 6.5 c | 23.3 e | 26.5 a | 19.2 e | 22.2 f |”
Source · p. 9
“| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
treatment 8.9 vs. control 26.5 % (-66.42 %) · after second harvest2023/24 · PG200%GR versus0%GR; averaged cultivars
Source · p. 8
“Application of phosphogypsum significantly reduced soil pH and ESP”
Source · p. 9
“| PG/G | 0% GR | 8.45 a | 6.5 c | 23.3 e | 26.5 a | 19.2 e | 22.2 f |”
Source · p. 9
“| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
“| PG 150% | GR | 8.02 e | 6.8 b | 31.6 b | 11.7 e | 31.6 b | 53.4 b |
| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
“| PG/G | 0% GR | 8.45 a | 6.5 c | 23.3 e | 26.5 a | 19.2 e | 22.2 f |”
Source · p. 9
“| PG 150% | GR | 8.02 e | 6.8 b | 31.6 b | 11.7 e | 31.6 b | 53.4 b |
| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
Source · p. 9
“Compared with the control, phosphogypsum application increased available P”
Source · p. 9
“| PG/G | 0% GR | 8.45 a | 6.5 c | 23.3 e | 26.5 a | 19.2 e | 22.2 f |”
Source · p. 9
“| PG 150% | GR | 8.02 e | 6.8 b | 31.6 b | 11.7 e | 31.6 b | 53.4 b |
| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
Source · p. 15
“Our results further showed that phosphogypsum application significantly increased soil available P and SO42-”
Source · p. 9
“| PG/G | 0% GR | 8.45 a | 6.5 c | 23.3 e | 26.5 a | 19.2 e | 22.2 f |”
Source · p. 9
“| PG 150% | GR | 8.02 e | 6.8 b | 31.6 b | 11.7 e | 31.6 b | 53.4 b |
| PG 200% | GR | 7.93 f | 7.0 a | 37.4 a | 8.9 f | 33.4 a | 57.8 a |”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 72.2 vs. control 54.3 % (+32.97 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 70.3 vs. control 53.9 % (+30.43 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 72.8 vs. control 54.3 % (+34.07 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 66.7 vs. control 46.5 % (+43.44 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 69.9 vs. control 46 % (+51.96 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 68.9 vs. control 46.5 % (+48.17 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 71.3 vs. control 46 % (+55 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 10
“Increasing the phosphogypsum application rate from 50% to 200% GR enhanced RWC”
Source · p. 16
“phosphogypsum application improved leaf RWC and transpiration rate across the three wheat varieties”
treatment 4.6 vs. control 3.7 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+24.32 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 6.8 vs. control 3.6 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+88.89 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4.8 vs. control 3.7 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+29.73 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.2 vs. control 3.6 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+100 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4.4 vs. control 2.6 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+69.23 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 6.4 vs. control 3 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+113.3 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4.7 vs. control 2.6 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+80.77 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 6.7 vs. control 3 mmol H2O m-2 s-1 (+123.3 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 10
“As the phosphogypsum application rate increased, the transpiration rate rose across all varieties”
Source · p. 16
“phosphogypsum application improved leaf RWC and transpiration rate across the three wheat varieties”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 10 vs. control 5.2 cm (+92.31 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.9 vs. control 5.6 cm (+76.79 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 10.1 vs. control 5.2 cm (+94.23 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.1 vs. control 4.9 cm (+85.71 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.4 vs. control 2.7 cm (+248.1 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.8 vs. control 4.9 cm (+100 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 9.3 vs. control 2.7 cm (+244.4 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 12
“Increasing phosphogypsum application rates from 50% to 200% GR further enhanced these traits.”
Source · p. 16
“phosphogypsum application significantly mitigated the negative impacts of sodicity stress on key yield components, including panicle length, number of seeds per spike, grain yield, and aboveground biomass across all three wheat varieties.”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 35.5 vs. control 10.9 (+225.7 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 31.4 vs. control 9.7 (+223.7 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 36 vs. control 10.9 (+230.3 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 28.2 vs. control 7.1 (+297.2 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 35.1 vs. control 4.9 (+616.3 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 30.8 vs. control 7.1 (+333.8 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 35.4 vs. control 4.9 (+622.4 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 16
“phosphogypsum application significantly mitigated the negative impacts of sodicity stress on key yield components, including panicle length, number of seeds per spike, grain yield, and aboveground biomass across all three wheat varieties.”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 8.2 vs. control 2.2 g pot-1 (+272.7 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.1 vs. control 2 g pot-1 (+255 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.5 vs. control 2.2 g pot-1 (+240.9 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4.8 vs. control 1.2 g pot-1 (+300 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 7.5 vs. control 1.5 g pot-1 (+400 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 6.6 vs. control 1.2 g pot-1 (+450 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 6.5 vs. control 1.5 g pot-1 (+333.3 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 12
“Phosphogypsum application consistently increased grain yield, with the salt-tolerant variety ETBW-5879 exhibiting the greatest response.”
Source · p. 16
“phosphogypsum application significantly mitigated the negative impacts of sodicity stress on key yield components, including panicle length, number of seeds per spike, grain yield, and aboveground biomass across all three wheat varieties.”
· 2023/24 · ETBW-5879; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 32.1 vs. control 4.4 mg pot-1 (+629.5 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 40 vs. control 6.7 mg pot-1 (+497 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 43.7 vs. control 4.4 mg pot-1 (+893.2 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 43.5 vs. control 6.7 mg pot-1 (+549.3 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 25.3 vs. control 1.6 mg pot-1 (+1,481 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 34.8 vs. control 3.6 mg pot-1 (+866.7 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 38.7 vs. control 1.6 mg pot-1 (+2,319 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 37.8 vs. control 3.6 mg pot-1 (+950 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 17
“applying phosphogypsum to saline-sodic soils significantly increased total P uptake and P concentrations in both wheat grain and straw”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 3,727 vs. control 2,259 mg kg-1 (+65.01 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,830 vs. control 1,838 mg kg-1 (+162.7 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,360 vs. control 2,259 mg kg-1 (+93 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 3,662 vs. control 1,118 mg kg-1 (+227.6 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 3,656 vs. control 1,882 mg kg-1 (+94.2 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,581 vs. control 1,118 mg kg-1 (+309.8 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 4,310 vs. control 1,882 mg kg-1 (+129 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 17
“applying phosphogypsum to saline-sodic soils significantly increased total P uptake and P concentrations in both wheat grain and straw”
· 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 399.1 vs. control 206.7 mg kg-1 (+93.08 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 527.7 vs. control 107.7 mg kg-1 (+390 %) · 2022/23 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 452.8 vs. control 206.7 mg kg-1 (+119.1 %) · 2023/24 · Gamboo; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 456.1 vs. control 93.3 mg kg-1 (+388.9 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 391.8 vs. control 182.3 mg kg-1 (+114.9 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG150%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 497 vs. control 93.3 mg kg-1 (+432.7 %) · 2022/23 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
treatment 447.1 vs. control 182.3 mg kg-1 (+145.3 %) · 2023/24 · Dande’a; PG200%GR versus matched0%GR
Source · p. 17
“applying phosphogypsum to saline-sodic soils significantly increased total P uptake and P concentrations in both wheat grain and straw”
Apparent recovery of applied P: difference in grain-plus-straw P uptake between amended and untreated soil divided by P applied via phosphogypsum, multiplied by100 (equation12).