Applied Engineering in Agriculture · 2026
Conventional Versus Conservation Tillage for Sprinkler-Irrigated Arizona Cotton Production
Thorp, K. R., Bandaru, P., Bronson, K., Smith, D. R.
Export
Conventional Versus Conservation Tillage for Sprinkler-Irrig…
Abstract
Highlights Four spring tillage treatments were evaluated prior to cotton production with sprinkler irrigation in Arizona. Conventional tillage yielded 8% greater but was not statistically different than no tillage with a winter cover crop. No tillage with a winter cover crop significantly improved emergence, early season crop vigor, and crop growth. Strip tillage with a winter cover crop did not provide favorable cotton production outcomes. Abstract. Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) production in central Arizona has traditionally relied on intensive tillage to break up the root-zone subsoil, laser leveling to improve surface irrigation efficiency, and cotton planting on raised beds with surface irrigation in adjacent furrows. Adoption of overhead sprinkler irrigation technology increases opportunities for reducing tillage operations; however, the effects of conservation practices on Arizona cotton production remain uncertain. The objective of this study was to compare four spring tillage management practices for sprinkler-irrigated cotton in Arizona: 1) conventional tillage with cotton planted on raised beds, 2) conventional tillage with cotton planted on flat ground, 3) no tillage with cotton planted directly into a terminated barley cover crop, and 4) strip tillage with cotton planted into tilled strips within a terminated barley cover crop. The four tillage treatments were replicated three times in a sprinkler-irrigated cotton field during the 2023 cotton season at Maricopa, Arizona. Measurements of cotton emergence, stand density, canopy height, soil water content, and fiber yield and quality were obtained. Additionally, images from a small unoccupied aircraft system (sUAS) were used to quantify fractional crop cover through canopy closure. Cotton fiber yield was 1650 kg ha -1 when planted on raised beds with conventional tillage, but this management practice demonstrated substantial spatial yield variability. Cotton planted on flat ground with conventional tillage had favorable emergence and stand density, while fiber yield was 1657 kg ha -1 and was not significantly different (p > 0.05) from yield of cotton planted on beds. No-till cotton demonstrated promising early-season vigor and crop growth, but mean fiber yield was reduced by 8% (1513 kg ha -1 ) compared to conventional tillage (p > 0.05), possibly due to no-till planter performance issues. Strip tillage did not provide favorable cotton fiber yield, with a 25% reduction (1237 kg ha -1 ) compared to conventional tillage (p < 0.05), likely due to water pooling in the tilled strips. Sprinkler-irrigated cotton in Arizona can be planted on conventionally tilled and leveled ground without a yield penalty compared to planting on raised beds, while no-till cotton should be prioritized for research as a promising conservation alternative. Keywords: Cotton, Cover Crop, Irrigation, Management, Tillage, Water.
Highlights Four spring tillage treatments were evaluated prior to cotton production with sprinkler irrigation in Arizona. Conventional tillage yielded 8% greater but was not statistically different than no tillage with a winter cover crop. No tillage with a winter cover crop significantly improved emergence, early season crop vigor, and crop growth. Strip tillage with a winter cover crop did not provide favorable cotton production outcomes. Abstract. Cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) production in central Arizona has traditionally relied on intensive tillage to break up the root-zone subsoil, laser leveling to improve surface irrigation efficiency, and cotton planting on raised beds with surface irrigation in adjacent furrows. Adoption of overhead sprinkler irrigation technology increases opportunities for reducing tillage operations; however, the effects of conservation practices on Arizona cotton production remain uncertain. The objective of this study was to compare four spring tillage management practices for sprinkler-irrigated cotton in Arizona: 1) conventional tillage with cotton planted on raised beds, 2) conventional tillage with cotton planted on flat ground, 3) no tillage with cotton planted directly into a terminated barley cover crop, and 4) strip tillage with cotton planted into tilled strips within a terminated barley cover crop. The four tillage treatments were replicated three times in a sprinkler-irrigated cotton field during the 2023 cotton season at Maricopa, Arizona. Measurements of cotton emergence, stand density, canopy height, soil water content, and fiber yield and quality were obtained. Additionally, images from a small unoccupied aircraft system (sUAS) were used to quantify fractional crop cover through canopy closure. Cotton fiber yield was 1650 kg ha -1 when planted on raised beds with conventional tillage, but this management practice demonstrated substantial spatial yield variability. Cotton planted on flat ground with conventional tillage had favorable emergence and stand density, while fiber yield was 1657 kg ha -1 and was not significantly different (p > 0.05) from yield of cotton planted on beds. No-till cotton demonstrated promising early-season vigor and crop growth, but mean fiber yield was reduced by 8% (1513 kg ha -1 ) compared to conventional tillage (p > 0.05), possibly due to no-till planter performance issues. Strip tillage did not provide favorable cotton fiber yield, with a 25% reduction (1237 kg ha -1 ) compared to conventional tillage (p < 0.05), likely due to water pooling in the tilled strips. Sprinkler-irrigated cotton in Arizona can be planted on conventionally tilled and leveled ground without a yield penalty compared to planting on raised beds, while no-till cotton should be prioritized for research as a promising conservation alternative. Keywords: Cotton, Cover Crop, Irrigation, Management, Tillage, Water.
Similar papers
Tillage Effects on Cotton Performance and Soil Quality in an Irrigated Arid Cropping System
Idowu et al. · 2020 · Agriculture
6 shared concepts
5 findings1 site
Impact of Different Barley-Based Cropping Systems on Soil Physicochemical Properties and Barley Growth under Conventional and Conservation Tillage Systems
Naeem et al. · 2020 · Agronomy
7 shared concepts
16 findings1 site
Establishment of Crops under Minimal Soil Disturbance and Crop Residue Retention in Rice-Based Cropping System: Yield Advantage, Soil Health Improvement, and Economic Benefit
Salahin et al. · 2021 · Land
8 shared concepts
