Summer cover crop utilization by no-till vegetable farms is essential for continuous soil protection, especially in the southern United States where intense storms are likely to occur in hot and humid summer months. A field experiment was conducted at the National Soil Dynamics Laboratory in Auburn, AL, USA, between the summers of 2015 and 2017 to determine the effectiveness of an experimental roller/crimper in mechanically terminating summer cover crops. Iron clay peas (Vigna unguiculata, L.) planted on a sandy loam and pearl millet (Penninsetum glaucum, L.) planted on clay soil were selected to determine termination rate effectiveness in single, double, and triple rolling/crimping over the same area. Overall, termination rates for both cover crops were higher for rolling three times (71%) compared to rolling once (55%) or twice (63%). However, cover crop termination was inhibited due to rainfalls on the experimental area during the three-week evaluation period. In 2016, drought conditions and high temperatures (32.6 °C) caused biomass reduction, especially for pearl millet, of over 31% to 39% compared to 2017 and 2015. Rolling provided higher soil-water conservation compared with the non-rolled control due the cover crop mulch layer blocking sunlight, keeping the soil surface cooler and preventing water evaporation. Recurrent rolling did not cause soil compaction above the 2.0 MPa level that inhibits root growth, but changes in soil strength were dependent on the soil moisture content.
Show all
Summer cover crop utilization by no-till vegetable farms is essential for continuous soil protection, especially in the southern United States where intense storms are likely to occur in hot and humid summer months. A field experiment was conducted at the National Soil Dynamics Laboratory in Auburn, AL, USA, between the summers of 2015 and 2017 to determine the effectiveness of an experimental roller/crimper in mechanically terminating summer cover crops. Iron clay peas (Vigna unguiculata, L.) planted on a sandy loam and pearl millet (Penninsetum glaucum, L.) planted on clay soil were selected to determine termination rate effectiveness in single, double, and triple rolling/crimping over the same area. Overall, termination rates for both cover crops were higher for rolling three times (71%) compared to rolling once (55%) or twice (63%). However, cover crop termination was inhibited due to rainfalls on the experimental area during the three-week evaluation period. In 2016, drought conditions and high temperatures (32.6 °C) caused biomass reduction, especially for pearl millet, of over 31% to 39% compared to 2017 and 2015. Rolling provided higher soil-water conservation compared with the non-rolled control due the cover crop mulch layer blocking sunlight, keeping the soil surface cooler and preventing water evaporation. Recurrent rolling did not cause soil compaction above the 2.0 MPa level that inhibits root growth, but changes in soil strength were dependent on the soil moisture content.
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property.
cover crop termination rate
↑ 13
↑increase
two rolling/crimping passes vs. one rolling/crimping passsignificance not stated · 2015–2017 · NSDL Hiwassee sandy loam soil bin · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · Overall means across years and weeks; whole-study direction, no pairwise test printed for these averages. Species/date tests include NS exceptions, particularly millet2015 and ICP21DAR2015/2016.
Numbers
treatment 61 vs. control 51 % (+19.61 %) · iron clay pea, site-1; whole-study mean
treatment 65 vs. control 60 % (+8.333 %) · pearl millet, site-2; whole-study mean
Source · p. 16
“Results have shown that rolling twice or three times over the same cover crop area increased cover crop termination rates compared to rolling once.”
↑increase
three rolling/crimping passes vs. one rolling/crimping passsignificance not stated · 2015–2017 · NSDL Hiwassee sandy loam soil bin · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · Overall means across years and weeks; whole-study direction, no pairwise test printed for these averages. Table5/6 datewise LSD.10 mostly supports direction, but millet2015 shares a. No omnibus p assigned to average pair.
Numbers
treatment 72 vs. control 51 % (+41.18 %) · iron clay pea, site-1; whole-study mean
treatment 70 vs. control 60 % (+16.67 %) · pearl millet, site-2; whole-study mean
Source · p. 16
“Results have shown that rolling twice or three times over the same cover crop area increased cover crop termination rates compared to rolling once.”
↑increase
rolled cover crops, one/two/three passes vs. non-rolled cover cropsignificant · 2015-2017; 7,14,21 days after rolling · NSDL Hiwassee sandy loam soil bin · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · Iron clay pea on sandy loam (site-1) and pearl millet on clay (site-2). One,two,three passes each compared individually with non-rolled cover crop; original Tables5/6 disjoint letters and every difference exceeds its dated Fisher LSD, alpha .10. All post-treatment dates merged; day0 baseline excluded. No pooled contrast or species comparison.
Numbers
treatment 73 vs. control 13.9 % (+425.2 %) · 2015;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 53.4 vs. control 21.8 % (+145 %) · 2015;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 73.8 vs. control 22.8 % (+223.7 %) · 2015;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 87.9 vs. control 13.9 % (+532.4 %) · 2015;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 69.1 vs. control 21.8 % (+217 %) · 2015;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 77.7 vs. control 22.8 % (+240.8 %) · 2015;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 99.5 vs. control 13.9 % (+615.8 %) · 2015;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 77.8 vs. control 21.8 % (+256.9 %) · 2015;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 86.3 vs. control 22.8 % (+278.5 %) · 2015;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 52.6 vs. control 33.6 % (+56.55 %)
soil strength/cone index
↑ 2↓ 13
↑increase
three rolling/crimping passes vs. one or two passes, agreeing reference variantssignificant · 0–15 cm · 2015 and2017 · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · 2015 three versus both one and two passes;2017 three versus one only (three/two share a). Below2MPa; Table12 LSD.10. Broad conclusion of no compaction does not erase these measured differences.
Numbers
treatment 1.25 vs. control 0.98 MPa (+27.55 %) · 2015 · three versus one
treatment 1.25 vs. control 1.04 MPa (+20.19 %) · 2015 · three versus two
treatment 0.83 vs. control 0.69 MPa (+20.29 %) · 2017 · three versus one
Source · p. 15
“no difference in soil strength was detected between rolling once (0.98 MPa and twice (1.04 MPa) compared to higher soil strength (1.25 MPa) for rolling three times.”
volumetric soil moisture content
1
↑increase
rolled cover crops, one/two/three passes vs. non-rolled cover cropsignificance not stated · 0–12 cm · 2015–2017; 7–21 days after rolling · NSDL Hiwassee sandy loam soil bin · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · Whole-study qualitative water-conservation conclusion, not every dated pair. Tables8/9 include NS and reversed ICP pairs; no aggregate pairwise test assigned. Observations are explicitly printed rolling-group averages, not computed from individual levels; erroneous2017ICP7DAR and2016millet7DAR prose averages omitted.
Numbers
treatment 13.8 vs. control 10.3 % (+33.98 %) · 2015,7DAR · ICP; published average of three rolling treatments
treatment 7 vs. control 4.4 % (+59.09 %) · 2017,14DAR · ICP; published average of three rolling treatments
treatment 14.7 vs. control 9.7 % (+51.55 %) · 2015,14DAR · millet; published average of three rolling treatments
treatment 67.8 vs. control 30.6 % (+121.6 %) · 2016;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 77.7 vs. control 62.8 % (+23.73 %) · 2016;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 75.3 vs. control 33.6 % (+124.1 %) · 2016;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 86.6 vs. control 30.6 % (+183 %) · 2016;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 83.3 vs. control 62.8 % (+32.64 %) · 2016;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 93.5 vs. control 33.6 % (+178.3 %) · 2016;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 95.3 vs. control 30.6 % (+211.4 %) · 2016;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 95.2 vs. control 62.8 % (+51.59 %) · 2016;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 55.7 vs. control 13.8 % (+303.6 %) · 2017;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 63.3 vs. control 11 % (+475.5 %) · 2017;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 59 vs. control 33.6 % (+75.6 %) · 2017;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;one pass
treatment 69.5 vs. control 13.8 % (+403.6 %) · 2017;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 76.7 vs. control 11 % (+597.3 %) · 2017;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 77.3 vs. control 33.6 % (+130.1 %) · 2017;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;two passes
treatment 95.2 vs. control 13.8 % (+589.9 %) · 2017;7DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 89.1 vs. control 11 % (+710 %) · 2017;14DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 90.9 vs. control 33.6 % (+170.5 %) · 2017;21DAR · iron clay pea,site-1;three passes
treatment 76.6 vs. control 10.9 % (+602.8 %) · 2015;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 90.4 vs. control 15.3 % (+490.8 %) · 2015;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 93.4 vs. control 18.7 % (+399.5 %) · 2015;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 80.3 vs. control 10.9 % (+636.7 %) · 2015;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 94 vs. control 15.3 % (+514.4 %) · 2015;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 95 vs. control 18.7 % (+408 %) · 2015;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 84 vs. control 10.9 % (+670.6 %) · 2015;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 97.7 vs. control 15.3 % (+538.6 %) · 2015;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 98.2 vs. control 18.7 % (+425.1 %) · 2015;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 60 vs. control 18.8 % (+219.1 %) · 2016;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 63.9 vs. control 20.5 % (+211.7 %) · 2016;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 79.4 vs. control 20.9 % (+279.9 %) · 2016;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 72.8 vs. control 18.8 % (+287.2 %) · 2016;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 73.3 vs. control 20.5 % (+257.6 %) · 2016;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 86.7 vs. control 20.9 % (+314.8 %) · 2016;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 75.6 vs. control 18.8 % (+302.1 %) · 2016;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 84.4 vs. control 20.5 % (+311.7 %) · 2016;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 90.9 vs. control 20.9 % (+334.9 %) · 2016;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 70.9 vs. control 12.3 % (+476.4 %) · 2017;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 76.3 vs. control 13.9 % (+448.9 %) · 2017;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 74.4 vs. control 20.7 % (+259.4 %) · 2017;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;one pass
treatment 82.7 vs. control 12.3 % (+572.4 %) · 2017;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 83 vs. control 13.9 % (+497.1 %) · 2017;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 80.8 vs. control 20.7 % (+290.3 %) · 2017;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;two passes
treatment 89.9 vs. control 12.3 % (+630.9 %) · 2017;7DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 89.7 vs. control 13.9 % (+545.3 %) · 2017;14DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
treatment 86.7 vs. control 20.7 % (+318.8 %) · 2017;21DAR · pearl millet,site-2;three passes
Source · p. 9
“At 14 DAR, significant differences occurred between no rolling and rolling treatments”
Source · p. 10
“At 21 DAR, a significantly lower termination rate was found for the control (18.7%) compared to rates for rolling once (93.4%), rolling twice (95.0%) and rolling three times (98.2%)”
Source · p. 9
“Iron clay peas termination rates (%) by rolling treatment during 2015, 2016, and 2017 growing seasons.”
Source · p. 10
“Pearl millet termination rates (%) by rolling treatment during 2015, 2016, and 2017 growing seasons.”
Source · p. 16
“lower soil strength was reported for the control and rolling once (0.69 MPa) compared to rolling twice (0.81 MPa and three times (0.83 MPa).”
↑increase
rolled cover crops, one/two/three passes vs. non-rolled cover cropsignificant · 0–15 cm · 2015 and2017 · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · 2015 one/two/three passes individually versus unrolled;2017 two/three passes only (one shares b with control). Below2MPa. Table12 LSD.10;2016 omnibus NS not projected onto pairs.
Numbers
treatment 0.98 vs. control 0.8 MPa (+22.5 %) · 2015 · one pass
treatment 1.04 vs. control 0.8 MPa (+30 %) · 2015 · two passes
treatment 1.25 vs. control 0.8 MPa (+56.25 %) · 2015 · three passes
treatment 0.81 vs. control 0.72 MPa (+12.5 %) · 2017 · two passes
treatment 0.83 vs. control 0.72 MPa (+15.28 %) · 2017 · three passes
Source · p. 16
“Control 0.80 c 1.09 1.83 2.00 0.72 b 0.69 a Rolled once 0.98 b 1.16 2.11 1.87 0.69 b 0.55 c Rolled twice 1.04 b 1.20 2.18 1.85 0.81 a 0.60 bc Rolled three times 1.25 a 1.31 2.19 1.64 0.83 a 0.66 ab”
↓decrease
one or two passes, agreeing deeper-soil comparisons vs. non-rolled cover cropsignificant · 15–30 cm · 2017 · NSDL Davidson clay soil bin · One/two passes individually versus unrolled; Table12 LSD.074 alpha.10. Three passes shares a with unrolled and is excluded; broad prose is not evidence of every pair.
Numbers
treatment 0.55 vs. control 0.69 MPa (-20.29 %) · one pass
treatment 0.6 vs. control 0.69 MPa (-13.04 %) · two passes
Source · p. 16
“the control (0.69 MPa) and rolling three times (0.66 MPa) had higher soil strength compared to lower soil strength of 0.55 MPa and 0.60 MPa for rolling once and twice, respectively.”
· 2015,21DAR · millet; published average of three rolling treatments
treatment 14.1 vs. control 9.6 % (+46.88 %) · 2017,21DAR · millet; published average of three rolling treatments
Source · p. 16
“Compared with the control (non-rolled cover crops), rolling down and crimping resulted in increased soil volumetric soil moisture (VMC), indicating improved soil-water conservation for both cover crops”
Source · p. 13
“At 7 and 14 DAR, VMC for all rolling treatments was significantly higher compared to the control”