The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of meat and bone meal (MBM) on cultivation of winter triticale, winter oilseed rape, winter wheat and maize. The average annual yields and protein yield achieved in crop rotation were studied. The field trials were carried out in north-eastern Poland in 2006–2010. The factor was dose of MBM: 1.0, 1.5, 2.0 and 2.5 t ha-1 year-1 or 2.0, 3.0, 4.0 and 5.0 t ha-1 every other year. The four-year experiment has proven that MBM is a valuable nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer in cultivation of cereals and oilseed rape. By amendment of the tested meal into the soil it produced crop yield and protein yield similar to that achieved by mineral fertilization. However, the crude fat yield of rape was significantly higher under the influence of all the MBM doses. The yield-stimulating effect of MBM did not depend on the frequency of its application; therefore it is more convenient to apply it once every two years. Increasing MBM from 1.5 to 2.5 t ha-1 did not significantly increase any of the four crop yields, therefore for soils that had satisfactory nutrients content, 1 or 1.5 t ha-1 MBM is enough and increasing MBM will only increase economic burden for farmers and environmental risks.
Show all
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of meat and bone meal (MBM) on cultivation of winter triticale, winter oilseed rape, winter wheat and maize. The average annual yields and protein yield achieved in crop rotation were studied. The field trials were carried out in north-eastern Poland in 2006–2010. The factor was dose of MBM: 1.0, 1.5, 2.0 and 2.5 t ha-1 year-1 or 2.0, 3.0, 4.0 and 5.0 t ha-1 every other year. The four-year experiment has proven that MBM is a valuable nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer in cultivation of cereals and oilseed rape. By amendment of the tested meal into the soil it produced crop yield and protein yield similar to that achieved by mineral fertilization. However, the crude fat yield of rape was significantly higher under the influence of all the MBM doses. The yield-stimulating effect of MBM did not depend on the frequency of its application; therefore it is more convenient to apply it once every two years. Increasing MBM from 1.5 to 2.5 t ha-1 did not significantly increase any of the four crop yields, therefore for soils that had satisfactory nutrients content, 1 or 1.5 t ha-1 MBM is enough and increasing MBM will only increase economic burden for farmers and environmental risks.
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property.
crop yield
↑ 1↓ 2= 36
↓decrease
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKsignificant · 2006/7 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter triticale; annual 1.0/2.5 and biennial 2/3/4/5 t MBM+K; actual a versus NPK b, not all rates
Numbers
treatment 4.38 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-23.02 %) · triticale annual1.0
treatment 4.33 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-23.9 %) · triticale annual2.5
treatment 4.02 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-29.35 %) · triticale biennial2
treatment 3.7 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-34.97 %) · triticale biennial3
treatment 4.03 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-29.17 %) · triticale biennial4
treatment 4.33 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-23.9 %) · triticale biennial5
Source · p. 5
“increasing MBM did not significantly increase grain yield, on the contrary often decreased grain yield.”
Source · p. 5
“Control NPK | | 5.69 b | 3.00 a | 4.88 | 20.4 ab”
=no effect
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKnot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Triticale annual1.5/2.0; wheat all8; maize all8; rape annual2.0/2.5 and biennial4.0. Other variants excluded: Table3 pairwise letters contradict blanket equivalence.
Numbers
treatment 4.89 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-14.06 %) · triticale annual1.5;2006/7
treatment 4.45 vs. control 5.69 t ha-1 (-21.79 %) · triticale annual2;2006/7
treatment 3.73 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+24.33 %) · rape annual2;2007/8
treatment 3.71 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+23.67 %) · rape annual2.5 and biennial4;2007/8 (same printed means)
treatment 4.08 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (-16.39 %) · wheat annual1;2008/9
treatment 5.06 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+3.689 %) · wheat annual1.5;2008/9
treatment 4.93 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+1.025 %) · wheat annual2;2008/9
treatment 5.66 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+15.98 %) · wheat annual2.5;2008/9
treatment 5.4 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+10.66 %) · wheat biennial2;2008/9
treatment 6.49 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+32.99 %) · wheat biennial3;2008/9
treatment 6.07 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+24.39 %) · wheat biennial4;2008/9
treatment 6.74 vs. control 4.88 t ha-1 (+38.11 %)
↑increase
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKsignificant · 2007/8 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter rape; annual1.0/1.5 and biennial2.0/3.0/5.0; b versus NPK a
Numbers
treatment 3.96 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+32 %) · rape annual1
treatment 4.2 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+40 %) · rape annual1.5
treatment 3.97 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+32.33 %) · rape biennial2
treatment 4.15 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+38.33 %) · rape biennial3
treatment 3.74 vs. control 3 t ha-1 (+24.67 %) · rape biennial5
Source · p. 5
“For winter rape, the highest seed yield (4.2 t ha-1) was obtained also at 1.5 t ha-1 MBM fertilization, whereas most of the MBM fertilization rates also produced significant difference”
↓decrease
2.5 t MBM+K yearly vs. 1.5 t MBM+K yearlysignificant · 2006/7 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter triticale, annual2.5 versus1.5 t/ha; Table3 a versus b overrides abstract blanket null
Numbers
treatment 4.33 vs. control 4.89 t ha-1 (-11.45 %)
Source · p. 5
“increasing MBM did not significantly increase grain yield, on the contrary often decreased grain yield.”
=no effect
2.5 t MBM+K yearly vs. 1.5 t MBM+K yearlynot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Annual2.5 versus1.5 t/ha; rape2007/8, wheat2008/9 and maize2010; not triticale
Numbers
treatment 3.71 vs. control 4.2 t ha-1 (-11.67 %) · rape2007/8 annual2.5vs1.5
treatment 5.66 vs. control 5.06 t ha-1 (+11.86 %) · wheat2008/9 annual2.5vs1.5
treatment 20.5 vs. control 20 t ha-1 (+2.5 %) · maize2010 annual2.5vs1.5
Source · p. 8
“Increasing rate of MBM from 1 to 2.5 t ha-1 in many cases did not significantly increase yield”
Source · p. 5
“Grain yield of winter wheat was rather good (ranged from 4.08 to 6.74 t ha-1) and increased along with the increase of MBM rate, however, the difference was not significant”
=no effect
MBM+K every two years vs. MBM+K yearlynot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Rape2007/8 and maize2010; corresponding doses2vs1,3vs1.5,4vs2,5vs2.5 t/ha; every biennial/annual pair shares letters
Numbers
treatment 3.97 vs. control 3.96 t ha-1 (+0.2525 %) · rape biennial2vsannual1
treatment 4.15 vs. control 4.2 t ha-1 (-1.19 %) · rape biennial3vsannual1.5
treatment 3.71 vs. control 3.73 t ha-1 (-0.5362 %) · rape biennial4vsannual2
treatment 3.74 vs. control 3.71 t ha-1 (+0.8086 %) · rape biennial5vsannual2.5
treatment 20.2 vs. control 17.9 t ha-1 (+12.85 %) · maize biennial2vsannual1
treatment 22.7 vs. control 20 t ha-1 (+13.5 %) · maize biennial3vsannual1.5
treatment 19 vs. control 21.4 t ha-1 (-11.21 %) · maize biennial4vsannual2
treatment 21.5 vs. control 20.5 t ha-1 (+4.878 %) · maize biennial5vsannual2.5
Source · p. 7
“During the second and fourth year, the residual effect of MBM was tested and no significant difference was found between yearly and every two years application.”
protein yield
↑ 1↓ 2= 36
=no effect
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKnot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Triticale, rape, wheat: all8 variants; maize: annual1.0/1.5 and biennial3/4/5 share NPK letters. Excludes significant maize pairs.
Numbers
treatment 165.2 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (-6.296 %) · triticale annual1
treatment 192 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+8.905 %) · triticale annual1.5
treatment 186.4 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+5.729 %) · triticale annual2
treatment 187.1 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+6.126 %) · triticale annual2.5
crude fat yield of winter oilseed rape
↑ 1= 23
↑increase
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKsignificant · 2007/8 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter rape; yearly MBM+K 1.0,1.5,2.0,2.5 t/ha and residual effects of 2.0,3.0,4.0,5.0 t/ha applied every two years, versus mineral NPK. Fig1: all MBM b versus NPK a, Tukey .05. Printed ca.30% is the average across all rates, not an effect assigned to an individual dose.
Numbers
percent_change 30 · 2007/8 · Paper's approximate average across all MBM rates/application frequencies
Source · p. 6
“Crude fat yield (t ha-1) produced from seeds of winter rape was observed to significantly increase upon the use of meat-bone meal, irrespective of the frequency of its application, as compared to mineral fertilization”
treatment 17.9 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (-12.25 %) · maize annual1;2010
treatment 20 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (-1.961 %) · maize annual1.5;2010
treatment 21.4 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (+4.902 %) · maize annual2;2010
treatment 20.5 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (+0.4902 %) · maize annual2.5;2010
treatment 20.2 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (-0.9804 %) · maize biennial2;2010
treatment 22.7 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (+11.27 %) · maize biennial3;2010
treatment 19 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (-6.863 %) · maize biennial4;2010
treatment 21.5 vs. control 20.4 t ha-1 (+5.392 %) · maize biennial5;2010
Source · p. 7
“Comparing MBM and NPK fertilizer at the same N rate, no significant differences were found in crop yields.”
Source · p. 5
“Grain yield of winter wheat fertilized with NPK as also did not differ significantly from that fertilized with MBM”
treatment 170.3 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (-3.403 %) · triticale biennial2
treatment 203.1 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+15.2 %) · triticale biennial3
treatment 187.5 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+6.353 %) · triticale biennial4
treatment 189.2 vs. control 176.3 kg ha-1 (+7.317 %) · triticale biennial5
treatment 159.4 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (-7.164 %) · rape annual1
treatment 180.6 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (+5.183 %) · rape annual1.5
treatment 170.4 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (-0.7571 %) · rape annual2
treatment 177.4 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (+3.32 %) · rape annual2.5
treatment 173 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (+0.7571 %) · rape biennial2
treatment 181.2 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (+5.533 %) · rape biennial3 and5(same means)
treatment 165.1 vs. control 171.7 kg ha-1 (-3.844 %) · rape biennial4
treatment 198 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-2.463 %) · wheat annual1
treatment 192.2 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-5.32 %) · wheat annual1.5
treatment 194 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-4.433 %) · wheat annual2
treatment 201.9 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-0.5419 %) · wheat annual2.5
treatment 199.4 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-1.773 %) · wheat biennial2
treatment 195.6 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-3.645 %) · wheat biennial3
treatment 200.8 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (-1.084 %) · wheat biennial4
treatment 208.7 vs. control 203 kg ha-1 (+2.808 %) · wheat biennial5
treatment 65.3 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (+3.323 %) · maize annual1
treatment 60.8 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (-3.797 %) · maize annual1.5
treatment 62.6 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (-0.9494 %) · maize biennial3 and4(same means)
treatment 57.8 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (-8.544 %) · maize biennial5
Source · p. 6
“Increasing doses of MBM, irrespective of application frequency, did not differentiate the protein yield for winter triticale, winter rape and winter wheat. Protein yield from crops grown on MBM-fertilized plots was similar to the control.”
↑increase
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKsignificant · 2010 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Maize; annual2.0 and2.5 t/ha only, de/e versus NPK bc
Numbers
treatment 70.6 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (+11.71 %) · annual2.0
treatment 73.9 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (+16.93 %) · annual2.5
Source · p. 6
“the protein yield of maize was significantly higher under MBM fertilization than NPK.”
↓decrease
MBM+K, agreeing variants vs. Control NPKsignificant · 2010 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Maize; biennial2.0 t/ha only, a versus NPK bc
Numbers
treatment 55.7 vs. control 63.2 kg ha-1 (-11.87 %)
Source · p. 6
“In our experiment, only protein yield of maize differed significantly at different rates of MBM”
Source · p. 6
“2.0 t MBM+K | 170.3 | 173.0 | 199.4 | 55.7 a”
Source · p. 6
“Control NPK | | 176.3 | 171.7 | 203.0 | 63.2 bc”
=no effect
2.5 t MBM+K yearly vs. 1.5 t MBM+K yearlynot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Triticale, rape and wheat; annual2.5 versus1.5 t/ha
Numbers
treatment 187.1 vs. control 192 kg ha-1 (-2.552 %) · triticale annual2.5vs1.5
treatment 177.4 vs. control 180.6 kg ha-1 (-1.772 %) · rape annual2.5vs1.5
treatment 201.9 vs. control 192.2 kg ha-1 (+5.047 %) · wheat annual2.5vs1.5
Source · p. 6
“Increasing doses of MBM, irrespective of application frequency, did not differentiate the protein yield for winter triticale, winter rape and winter wheat.”
↓decrease
MBM+K every two years vs. MBM+K yearlysignificant · 2010 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Maize; biennial2vsannual1,4vs2,5vs2.5; Table4 disjoint letters. Biennial3vsannual1.5 excluded from decrease.
Numbers
treatment 55.7 vs. control 65.3 kg ha-1 (-14.7 %) · maize biennial2vsannual1
treatment 62.6 vs. control 70.6 kg ha-1 (-11.33 %) · maize biennial4vsannual2
treatment 57.8 vs. control 73.9 kg ha-1 (-21.79 %) · maize biennial5vsannual2.5
Source · p. 8
“Only maize produced 12% lower yield at the residual than the direct effect of MBM.”
Source · p. 6
“2.0 t MBM+K | 170.3 | 173.0 | 199.4 | 55.7 a”
Source · p. 6
“1.0 t MBM+K | 165.2 | 159.4 | 198.0 | 65.3 cd”
=no effect
MBM+K every two years vs. MBM+K yearlynot significant · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Triticale, rape and wheat; corresponding annual/biennial rates. Maize only biennial3vsannual1.5 (abc/abc).
Numbers
treatment 170.3 vs. control 165.2 kg ha-1 (+3.087 %) · triticale biennial2vsannual1
treatment 203.1 vs. control 192 kg ha-1 (+5.781 %) · triticale biennial3vsannual1.5
treatment 187.5 vs. control 186.4 kg ha-1 (+0.5901 %) · triticale biennial4vsannual2
treatment 189.2 vs. control 187.1 kg ha-1 (+1.122 %) · triticale biennial5vsannual2.5
treatment 173 vs. control 159.4 kg ha-1 (+8.532 %) · rape biennial2vsannual1
treatment 181.2 vs. control 180.6 kg ha-1 (+0.3322 %) · rape biennial3vsannual1.5
treatment 165.1 vs. control 170.4 kg ha-1 (-3.11 %) · rape biennial4vsannual2
treatment 181.2 vs. control 177.4 kg ha-1 (+2.142 %) · rape biennial5vsannual2.5
treatment 199.4 vs. control 198 kg ha-1 (+0.7071 %) · wheat biennial2vsannual1
treatment 195.6 vs. control 192.2 kg ha-1 (+1.769 %) · wheat biennial3vsannual1.5
treatment 200.8 vs. control 194 kg ha-1 (+3.505 %) · wheat biennial4vsannual2
treatment 208.7 vs. control 201.9 kg ha-1 (+3.368 %) · wheat biennial5vsannual2.5
treatment 62.6 vs. control 60.8 kg ha-1 (+2.961 %) · maize biennial3vsannual1.5
Source · p. 8
“In the four-year rotation crop system, similar protein yields were obtained as a result of both the direct and residual effects of MBM irrespective of the rate of MBM”
Source · p. 6
“Increasing doses of MBM, irrespective of application frequency, did not differentiate the protein yield for winter triticale, winter rape and winter wheat.”
Source · p. 7
“Yield of crude fat (t ha-1) of winter oilseed rape.”
=no effect
MBM+K every two years vs. MBM+K yearlynot significant · 2007/8 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter rape; corresponding biennial versus annual MBM+K rates 2/1,3/1.5,4/2,5/2.5 t/ha. Direct annual and residual biennial treatments all share b in original Fig1, Tukey .05. No chart-derived means.
Source · p. 8
“A similar yield-stimulating effectiveness of the meal was proved in the direct and residual effect”
Source · p. 7
“Yield of crude fat (t ha-1) of winter oilseed rape.”
=no effect
2.5 t MBM+K yearly vs. 1.5 t MBM+K yearlynot significant · 2007/8 · Research and Experimental Station in Bałdy · Winter rape; annual 2.5 versus 1.5 t MBM+K/ha. Fig1 original PDFp7: both b, Tukey .05. Conclusion's dose-absence result restricted to the existing named annual comparison; no chart-derived means.
Source · p. 8
“Increasing rate of MBM from 1 to 2.5 t ha-1 in many cases did not significantly increase yield, protein yield of crops and crude fat of oilseed rape seeds”
Source · p. 7
“Yield of crude fat (t ha-1) of winter oilseed rape.”