Agronomy · 2022
Sugarcane Ratoon Yield and Soil Phosphorus Availability in Response to Enhanced Efficiency Phosphate Fertilizer
Oliveira, C. L. B. D., Cassimiro, J. B., Lira, M. V. D. S., Boni, A. D. S., Donato, N. D. L., Reis, R. D. A., Heinrichs, R.
Export
Sugarcane Ratoon Yield and Soil Phosphorus Availability in R…
Abstract
The low availability of phosphorus in most Brazilian soils causes a heavy dependence of agricultural production on phosphate fertilizers, which are generally agronomically inefficient in tropical soils. Breeding for increased longevity of sugarcane ratoons is extremely important, but understanding how the efficiency of phosphate fertilization can be improved is equally necessary. The objective of this research was to evaluate the effects of phosphate fertilizers with and without polymer coating on the productivity and nutritional status of sugarcane ratoons and phosphorus availability in the soil. The experiment was carried out on a commercial sugarcane field on a dystrophic Ultisol over two growing seasons in a randomized complete block design with four replications. Two phosphorus sources (monoammonium phosphate (MAP) and MAP + Policote) were tested at four rates (20, 40, 60 and 80 kg P2O5 ha−1) in addition to the control (no P fertilization). The Policote-coated phosphate fertilizer induced higher stalk and TRS yields in the first experimental year, while the same effect was not observed in the second year. Nevertheless, with the reapplication of the treatments in the second study year, the mean stalk yield was high in response to the application of 20 kg P2O5 ha−1 of coated fertilizer and very different from that of the higher rates of the same fertilizer, which yielded 88 Mg ha−1, i.e., 8 Mg ha−1 more than the mean of the other rates.
Show all
The low availability of phosphorus in most Brazilian soils causes a heavy dependence of agricultural production on phosphate fertilizers, which are generally agronomically inefficient in tropical soils. Breeding for increased longevity of sugarcane ratoons is extremely important, but understanding how the efficiency of phosphate fertilization can be improved is equally necessary. The objective of this research was to evaluate the effects of phosphate fertilizers with and without polymer coating on the productivity and nutritional status of sugarcane ratoons and phosphorus availability in the soil. The experiment was carried out on a commercial sugarcane field on a dystrophic Ultisol over two growing seasons in a randomized complete block design with four replications. Two phosphorus sources (monoammonium phosphate (MAP) and MAP + Policote) were tested at four rates (20, 40, 60 and 80 kg P2O5 ha−1) in addition to the control (no P fertilization). The Policote-coated phosphate fertilizer induced higher stalk and TRS yields in the first experimental year, while the same effect was not observed in the second year. Nevertheless, with the reapplication of the treatments in the second study year, the mean stalk yield was high in response to the application of 20 kg P2O5 ha−1 of coated fertilizer and very different from that of the higher rates of the same fertilizer, which yielded 88 Mg ha−1, i.e., 8 Mg ha−1 more than the mean of the other rates.
The low availability of phosphorus in most Brazilian soils causes a heavy dependence of agricultural production on phosphate fertilizers, which are generally agronomically inefficient in tropical soils. Breeding for increased longevity of sugarcane ratoons is extremely important, but understanding how the efficiency of phosphate fertilization can be improved is equally necessary. The objective of this research was to evaluate the effects of phosphate fertilizers with and without polymer coating on the productivity and nutritional status of sugarcane ratoons and phosphorus availability in the soil. The experiment was carried out on a commercial sugarcane field on a dystrophic Ultisol over two growing seasons in a randomized complete block design with four replications. Two phosphorus sources (monoammonium phosphate (MAP) and MAP + Policote) were tested at four rates (20, 40, 60 and 80 kg P2O5 ha−1) in addition to the control (no P fertilization). The Policote-coated phosphate fertilizer induced higher stalk and TRS yields in the first experimental year, while the same effect was not observed in the second year. Nevertheless, with the reapplication of the treatments in the second study year, the mean stalk yield was high in response to the application of 20 kg P2O5 ha−1 of coated fertilizer and very different from that of the higher rates of the same fertilizer, which yielded 88 Mg ha−1, i.e., 8 Mg ha−1 more than the mean of the other rates.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
P-Mehlich1
↑ 4= 16
- increase
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPsignificant · 10–20 cm · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · 10–20cm; source main effect across20–80kgP2O5/ha; exact sourcep=.0018,.0001 respectively; Tukeyletters/commonbound.05; shallowfirstyear differs
Numbers
- treatment 19.9 vs. control 17.36 mg/dm3 (+14.63 %) · 10–20 cm · 2018/19
- treatment 18.79 vs. control 16.65 mg/dm3 (+12.85 %) · 10–20 cm · 2019/20
Source · p. 7 “results in soil P contents were positive in response to Policote-coated fertilizer in the 0–0.10 m layer in the third ratoon and the 0.10–0.20 m layer in both years (Table 2).”
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 0–10 cm · 2018/2019 second ratoon · Ouro Verde · 0–10cm source main effect averaged overrates; explicit Table2p=.332NS, not inferred frominteraction
Numbers
- treatment 18.61 vs. control 17.24 mg/dm3 (+7.947 %) · 0–10 cm
Source · p. 7 “p-value 0.0149 * 0.332 ns”
Source · p. 9 “no difference was identified between the sources in both layers and the two evaluated years”
- increase
along P2O5 application ratesignificant · 0–10 cm · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · 0–10cm; measureddose0–80kgP2O5/ha, pooledsource response; deep2019/20 differs
Source · p. 7 “an isolated effect for the two factors, with a linear response to P rates in the two evaluated years and two layers (Figure 3b,d,f)”
Source · p. 9 “the methods P-Resin and Mehlich-1 detected increasing concentrations with increasing rates.”
- rises then falls
along P2O5 application ratesignificant · 10–20 cm · 2019/2020 third ratoon · Ouro Verde · 10–20cm, measureddose0–80kgP2O5/ha; actualFigure3h Ushape with intermediate40low/high80; no fittedoptimum or concentrations
Source · p. 7 “0.10–0.20 m layer in the second year when a quadratic response was observed (Figure 3h).”
Source · p. 9 “The soil P contents determined by Mehlich-1 were significantly influenced by the rates (Figure 3b,d,f,h)”
- increase
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPp = 0.0001 · 0–10 cm · 2019/20 · Ouro Verde · 0–10cm; coated versus uncoated MAP source main effect across20–80kgP2O5/ha, exacttwolevelp=.0001; same comparison null here2018/19
Numbers
- treatment 24.26 vs. control 18.19 mg/dm3 (+33.37 %) · 0–10 cm · 2019/20
Source · p. 7 “results in soil P contents were positive in response to Policote-coated fertilizer in the 0–0.10 m layer in the third ratoon and the 0.10–0.20 m layer in both years (Table 2).”
- increase
along P2O5 application ratesignificant · 10–20 cm · 2018/19 · Ouro Verde · 10–20cm; measureddose0–80kgP2O5/ha pooledsources, Figure3d; same depth2019/20Ushape separately
Source · p. 7 “an isolated effect for the two factors, with a linear response to P rates in the two evaluated years and two layers (Figure 3b,d,f)”
Source · p. 9 “the methods P-Resin and Mehlich-1 detected increasing concentrations with increasing rates.”
stalk yield
↓ 13
- decrease
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPsignificant · 2019/2020 third ratoon · Ouro Verde · Source means over20–80kgP2O5/ha, Figure4b bvs a; no individualrate tests
Numbers
- treatment 69.9 vs. control 79.1 Mg/ha (-11.63 %)
Source · p. 10 “only the difference in the mean of the sources was verified, with higher stalk yield in response to the application of uncoated fertilizer.”
Source · p. 8 “Figure 4(b): Uncoated MAP y = 79.10 a; MAP + Policote y = 69.90 b.”
- increase
along P2O5 application ratesignificance not stated · 2018/2019 second ratoon · Ouro Verde · Measured field dose response,0-80kgP2O5/ha under uncoated MAP; positive linear response in originalFig4a PDFp8. No curve-specific significance test reported; no predicted maximum or treatment-pair test inferred.
Source · p. 7 “The second ratoon stalk yield (Figure 4a) shows that the response to uncoated fertilizer increased linearly up to the rate of 80 kg P 2O5 ha”
- rises then falls
along P2O5 application ratesignificance not stated · 2018/2019 second ratoon · Ouro Verde · Measured field dose response,0-80kgP2O5/ha under MAP+Policote; optimum pattern in originalFig4a PDFp8. No curve-specific test reported; fitted optimal rate and predicted maximum excluded.
Source · p. 7 “In turn, the response to the Policote-coated phosphate source fitted a quadratic model”
total recoverable sugar yield
= 13
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2019/2020 third ratoon · Ouro Verde · TRS yield Mg/ha, source means over20–80kgP2O5/ha; Figure4d bothNS; distinct from TRSkg/tconcentration
Numbers
- treatment 10.42 vs. control 11.59 Mg/ha (-10.09 %)
Source · p. 8 “Figure 4(d): Uncoated MAP y = 11.59 ns; MAP + Policote y = 10.42 ns.”
Source · p. 11 “The Policote-coated phosphate fertilizer induced higher stalk and TRS yields in the first experimental year, while the same effect was not observed in the second year.”
- increase
along P2O5 application ratesignificance not stated · 2018/2019 second ratoon · Ouro Verde · Measured field dose response,0-80kgP2O5/ha under uncoated MAP; positive linear TRS yield response in originalFig4c PDFp8. Sugar yield Mg/ha,distinct from TRSkg/t. No curve-specific test reported or fitted predictions entered.
Source · p. 10 “The response to the uncoated monoammonium phosphate source fitted a linear model”
Source · p. 8 “yield had a similar pattern to that observed for stalk yield (Figure 4c).”
- rises then falls
along P2O5 application ratesignificance not stated · 2018/2019 second ratoon · Ouro Verde · Measured field dose response,0-80kgP2O5/ha under MAP+Policote; optimum TRS yield pattern in originalFig4c PDFp8. Sugar yield Mg/ha. No curve-specific test reported; fitted optimal rate,predicted maximum and computed efficiency excluded.
Source · p. 8 “yield had a similar pattern to that observed for stalk yield (Figure 4c).”
Source · p. 10 “An important parameter in the evaluation of sugarcane fertilization is the production of total reducing sugars, for which the same pattern as for stalk yield was observed”
P-Resin
↑ 22
- increase
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPp = 0.0149 · 0–10 cm · 2019/2020 third ratoon · Ouro Verde · 0–10cm; source effect averaged over20–80kgP2O5/ha; exact two-level source F-test p=.0149
Numbers
- treatment 12.72 vs. control 10.89 mg/dm3 (+16.8 %) · 0–10 cm
Source · p. 5 “Comparing the sources, MAP + Policote made the highest levels of nutrients available (12.72 mg P dm”
- increase
along P2O5 application ratesignificant · 0–20 cm · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · 0–20cm; dose0–80kgP2O5/ha; both MAPsources; measuredexperiment dose response, no fittedprediction values
Source · p. 5 “Soil phosphorus levels varied in response to the P sources and rates applied to sugarcane (p \< 0.05).”
Source · p. 9 “In response to soil application of the two phosphorus sources, the methods P-Resin and Mehlich-1 detected increasing concentrations with increasing rates.”
leaf N content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect, not individual P rate comparisons
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
leaf P content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
leaf K content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
leaf Ca content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
leaf Mg content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
leaf S content
= 11
- no effect
MAP + Policote vs. uncoated MAPnot significant · 2018/19–2019/20 · Ouro Verde · diagnostic leaf+1; source main effect
Source · p. 7 “The phosphorus rates and sources had no effect on the nutritional status of sugarcane (p \> 0.05).”
Source · p. 11 “Leaf contents did not vary in response to phosphate fertilization.”
Set-up
Treatments
- phosphate fertilizer sourcePhosphate fertilizer
- MAP + PolicoteMonoammonium phosphate fertilizeruncoated MAPMonoammonium phosphate fertilizer
Measured
- P-ResinAvailable phosphorus
- Unit
- mg/dm3
- P-Mehlich1Available phosphorus
- Unit
- mg/dm3
- leaf N contentPlant N content
- Unit
- g/kg
- Method
- Kjeldahl
- leaf P contentPlant P content
- Unit
- g/kg
- leaf K contentPlant K content
- Unit
- g/kg
- leaf Ca contentPlant Ca content
- Unit
- g/kg
- leaf Mg contentPlant Mg content
- Unit
- g/kg
- leaf S contentPlant S content
- Unit
- g/kg
- P2O5 application ratePhosphate fertilizer
- Unit
- kg P2O5/ha
- stalk yieldYield
- Unit
- Mg/ha
- total recoverable sugar yieldYield
- Unit
- Mg/ha
- Method
- TRS concentration times stalk yield; sugar yield, not stalk mass or TRSkg/t
Sites
Ouro Verde
- Location
- Ouro Verde, São Paulo State, Brazil21.55° S, 51.73° W
- Climate
- Aw1,366 mm annual precipitation
- Soil
- Ultisol (dystrophic) · USDA
- Land use
- commercial sugarcane plantationArable land
- Management on the whole site
- sugarcane RB92579Sugar cane/Saccharum officinarum, limestoneLime, common nitrogen and potassium fertilizationUrea fertilizer
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0–10 cm | sandy | 13.2 % (from g/kg) | 4.99 | – | – |
| 10–20 cm | sandy | 12.2 % (from g/kg) | 4.86 | – | – |
| 20–40 cm | sandy | 12.3 % (from g/kg) | 5.59 | – | – |
Similar papers
Effects of Lime and Phosphorus Applications on Soil Chemical Composition, Growth and Nutrient Uptake of Maize (Zea mays L.) in an Acid Soil of Gununo, Southern Ethiopia
Beyene · 2021 · Journal of Science and Development
9 shared concepts
30 findings1 site
Growth and nutrient contents in lowland rice due to phosphorus and potassium fertilization
Reis et al. · 2018 · Pesquisa Agropecuária Tropical
8 shared concepts
28 findings3 sites
INFLUENCE OF LIMING ON FERTILIZER-INDUCED SOIL ACIDITY AND NUTRIENT UPTAKE BY MAIZE (ZEA MAYS L.) IN ALFISOLS
D et al. · 2025 · Plant Archives
8 shared concepts
17 findings1 site
Influence of earthworms on some soil chemical and physical properties, and the growth of ryegrass on a soil after topsoil stripping - a pot experiment
McColl, Hart & Cook · 1982 · New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research
7 shared concepts
49 findings1 site
Fertigation of arugula crops grown in saline soils
Torres et al. · 2024 · Comunicata Scientiae
6 shared concepts
16 findings1 site
