The Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences · 2020
Effect of silicon fertilization and crop establishment methods on yield, soil quality and silicon uptake of rice (Oryza sativa)
BAJIYA, R., SINGH, Y. V., SHARMA, D. K., DASS, A., MEENA, M. C., ABRAHAM, G., BANA, R. S., LAKHRAN, H.
Export
Effect of silicon fertilization and crop establishment metho…
Abstract
A field experiment was carried out at ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi during kharif 2015 and 2016 to determine the effects of rice establishment method, silicon application levels and silicon solubilizing bacteria on silicon concentrations and uptake by rice (Oryza sativa) and soil microbial parameters in rice-wheat cropping system. The experiment was laid out in split-split plot design and replicated thrice. The experiment was conducted with 24 treatment combinations including rice establishment methods in main plot, silicon level in sub plot and silicon solubilizing microbes in sub-sub plot. Silicon concentration in grain and straw was highest in crop establishment of aerobic rice and lowest in TPR methods during both the years. Tested aerobic rice establishment methods significantly influenced the microbial biomass carbon (278.2 and 289.3 μg/g soil), soil dehydrogenase activity (202.3 and 198.3 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (222.5 and 255.9 × 102 cfu/g soil) compared to SRI and TPR and the highest silicon concentration and uptake, microbial biomass carbon (285.9 μg/g soil), dehydrogenase activity (189.7 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (239.6 102 cfu/g soil) was recorded with silicon application 120 kg/ha which at par with 80 kg/ha but statistically superior over to control and 40 kg/ha in terms of nutrient uptake in grain and straw and soil quality parameters during both years of study.
Show all
A field experiment was carried out at ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi during kharif 2015 and 2016 to determine the effects of rice establishment method, silicon application levels and silicon solubilizing bacteria on silicon concentrations and uptake by rice (Oryza sativa) and soil microbial parameters in rice-wheat cropping system. The experiment was laid out in split-split plot design and replicated thrice. The experiment was conducted with 24 treatment combinations including rice establishment methods in main plot, silicon level in sub plot and silicon solubilizing microbes in sub-sub plot. Silicon concentration in grain and straw was highest in crop establishment of aerobic rice and lowest in TPR methods during both the years. Tested aerobic rice establishment methods significantly influenced the microbial biomass carbon (278.2 and 289.3 μg/g soil), soil dehydrogenase activity (202.3 and 198.3 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (222.5 and 255.9 × 102 cfu/g soil) compared to SRI and TPR and the highest silicon concentration and uptake, microbial biomass carbon (285.9 μg/g soil), dehydrogenase activity (189.7 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (239.6 102 cfu/g soil) was recorded with silicon application 120 kg/ha which at par with 80 kg/ha but statistically superior over to control and 40 kg/ha in terms of nutrient uptake in grain and straw and soil quality parameters during both years of study.
A field experiment was carried out at ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi during kharif 2015 and 2016 to determine the effects of rice establishment method, silicon application levels and silicon solubilizing bacteria on silicon concentrations and uptake by rice (Oryza sativa) and soil microbial parameters in rice-wheat cropping system. The experiment was laid out in split-split plot design and replicated thrice. The experiment was conducted with 24 treatment combinations including rice establishment methods in main plot, silicon level in sub plot and silicon solubilizing microbes in sub-sub plot. Silicon concentration in grain and straw was highest in crop establishment of aerobic rice and lowest in TPR methods during both the years. Tested aerobic rice establishment methods significantly influenced the microbial biomass carbon (278.2 and 289.3 μg/g soil), soil dehydrogenase activity (202.3 and 198.3 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (222.5 and 255.9 × 102 cfu/g soil) compared to SRI and TPR and the highest silicon concentration and uptake, microbial biomass carbon (285.9 μg/g soil), dehydrogenase activity (189.7 μg TPF/g soil/day) and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria (239.6 102 cfu/g soil) was recorded with silicon application 120 kg/ha which at par with 80 kg/ha but statistically superior over to control and 40 kg/ha in terms of nutrient uptake in grain and straw and soil quality parameters during both years of study.
Findings
What changed what, as the paper reports it. Grouped by the measured property. The largest groups are open; open the others as you need them.
grain yield
↑ 1↓ 1= 13
- decrease
AR vs. TPRsignificant · kharif 2015 and 2016, two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Marginal establishment means across Si rates and two bacterial inoculants.
Numbers
- treatment 4.31 vs. control 4.92 t/ha (-12.4 %)
Source · p. 2 “both of these methods showed”
Source · p. 2 “significantly higher grain yield than aerobic rice.”
- no effect
SRI vs. TPRnot significant · kharif 2015 and 2016, two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Marginal establishment means, LSD.31; 4.84vs4.92.
Numbers
- treatment 4.84 vs. control 4.92 t/ha (-1.626 %)
Source · p. 2 “The differences in grain yield due to TPR and SRI were statistically at par”
- increase
40, 80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 40/80/120 versus0 individually, marginal over other factors; LSD.21.
Numbers
- treatment 4.61 vs. control 4.36 t/ha (+5.734 %) · 40 kg Si/ha
- treatment 4.85 vs. control 4.36 t/ha (+11.24 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 4.94 vs. control 4.36 t/ha (+13.3 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “application of 80 and 120 kg silicon/ha gave significantly higher yield over control and 40 kg silicon/ha during both the years.”
Source · p. 2 “Control 254.0 4.36 251.7 166.8 211.2 40 263.5 4.61 266.9 178.0 223.5”
Si concentration in grain
↑ 2↓ 13
- increase
AR vs. TPRsignificant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Grain Si; marginal establishment means; LSD.10.
Numbers
- treatment 1.58 vs. control 1.43 % (+10.49 %)
Source · p. 3 “The highest Si concentration in grain and straw was registered with aerobic rice and lowest with TPR during the both years of study.”
- decrease
SRI vs. TPRsignificant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Grain Si; SRI actually belowTPR, .11>LSD.10; overrides abstract/text lowestTPR claim.
Numbers
- treatment 1.32 vs. control 1.43 % (-7.692 %)
Source · p. 3 “SRI 1.32 3.84 65.9 244.9 62.7”
Source · p. 3 “TPR 1.43 3.71 70.9 239.7 72.5”
- increase
80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 80/120 versus0 separate marginal comparisons; grain concentration LSD.06.
Numbers
- treatment 1.54 vs. control 1.3 % (+18.46 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 1.58 vs. control 1.3 % (+21.54 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “application of 80 and 120 kg silicon/ha gave significantly higher Si concentration in grain and straw over control and 40 kg silicon/ha during both the years”
number of panicles per meter square
↑ 1↓ 12
- decrease
AR vs. TPRsignificant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Marginal establishment means; LSD16.5.
Numbers
- treatment 240.5 vs. control 280.5 m-2 (-14.26 %)
Source · p. 2 “TPR 280.5 4.92 252.0 161.3 210.0 AR 240.5 4.31 283.8 200.3 239.2”
- increase
80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 80/120 versus0 individually, marginal over establishment/inoculants; LSD11.
Numbers
- treatment 276.5 vs. control 254 m-2 (+8.858 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 279 vs. control 254 m-2 (+9.843 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 2 “Control 254.0 4.36 251.7 166.8 211.2 40 263.5 4.61 266.9 178.0 223.5 80 276.5 4.85 280.5 186.8 235.2 120 279.0 4.94 285.9 189.7 239.6”
microbial biomass carbon
↑ 22
- increase
AR and SRI, agreeing individual biological comparisons vs. TPRsignificant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots; AR and SRI individual marginal tests vsTPR; LSD18.
Numbers
- treatment 283.8 vs. control 252 μg/g soil (+12.62 %) · AR
- treatment 278 vs. control 252 μg/g soil (+10.32 %) · SRI
Source · p. 3 “the highest and lowest MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria levels were recorded with aerobic rice and TPR, respectively during both years of experimentation.”
Source · p. 2 “SRI 284.0 4.84 278.0 179.4 232.9”
- increase
40, 80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots;40/80/120 versus0 individual marginal comparisons; LSD12.1.
Numbers
- treatment 266.9 vs. control 251.7 μg/g soil (+6.039 %) · 40 kg Si/ha
- treatment 280.5 vs. control 251.7 μg/g soil (+11.44 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 285.9 vs. control 251.7 μg/g soil (+13.59 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “Application of 80 and 120 kg/ha had significantly higher MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria over control and 40 kg silicon/ ha during both the years.”
Source · p. 2 “Control 254.0 4.36 251.7 166.8 211.2 40 263.5 4.61 266.9 178.0 223.5”
dehydrogenase activity
↑ 22
- increase
AR and SRI, agreeing individual biological comparisons vs. TPRsignificant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots; separate AR/SRI marginal tests; LSD11.7.
Numbers
- treatment 200.3 vs. control 161.3 µg TPF/g soil/day (+24.18 %) · AR
- treatment 179.4 vs. control 161.3 µg TPF/g soil/day (+11.22 %) · SRI
Source · p. 3 “the highest and lowest MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria levels were recorded with aerobic rice and TPR, respectively during both years of experimentation.”
Source · p. 2 “SRI 284.0 4.84 278.0 179.4 232.9”
- increase
40, 80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots;40/80/120 versus0 individual marginal comparisons; LSD7.6.
Numbers
- treatment 178 vs. control 166.8 µg TPF/g soil/day (+6.715 %) · 40 kg Si/ha
- treatment 186.8 vs. control 166.8 µg TPF/g soil/day (+11.99 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 189.7 vs. control 166.8 µg TPF/g soil/day (+13.73 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “Application of 80 and 120 kg/ha had significantly higher MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria over control and 40 kg silicon/ ha during both the years.”
Source · p. 2 “Control 254.0 4.36 251.7 166.8 211.2 40 263.5 4.61 266.9 178.0 223.5”
total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria
↑ 22
- increase
AR and SRI, agreeing individual biological comparisons vs. TPRsignificant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots; AR/SRI each versusTPR; LSD15.
Numbers
- treatment 239.2 vs. control 210 10^2 cfu/g soil (+13.9 %) · AR
- treatment 232.9 vs. control 210 10^2 cfu/g soil (+10.9 %) · SRI
Source · p. 3 “the highest and lowest MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria levels were recorded with aerobic rice and TPR, respectively during both years of experimentation.”
Source · p. 2 “SRI 284.0 4.84 278.0 179.4 232.9”
- increase
40, 80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 0–15 cm · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 0–15cm near roots;40/80/120 versus0 individual marginal comparisons; LSD10.1.
Numbers
- treatment 223.5 vs. control 211.2 10^2 cfu/g soil (+5.824 %) · 40 kg Si/ha
- treatment 235.2 vs. control 211.2 10^2 cfu/g soil (+11.36 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 239.6 vs. control 211.2 10^2 cfu/g soil (+13.45 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “Application of 80 and 120 kg/ha had significantly higher MBC, dehydrogenase activity and total count of silicon solubilizing bacteria over control and 40 kg silicon/ ha during both the years.”
Source · p. 2 “Control 254.0 4.36 251.7 166.8 211.2 40 263.5 4.61 266.9 178.0 223.5”
Si concentration in straw
↑ 22
- increase
AR vs. TPRsignificant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · Harvested straw Si; marginal establishment means; LSD.24.
Numbers
- treatment 4.03 vs. control 3.71 % (+8.625 %)
Source · p. 3 “The highest Si concentration in grain and straw was registered with aerobic rice and lowest with TPR during the both years of study.”
- increase
80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 80/120 versus0 separate marginal comparisons; straw concentration LSD.16.
Numbers
- treatment 3.97 vs. control 3.69 % (+7.588 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 3.99 vs. control 3.69 % (+8.13 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 3 “application of 80 and 120 kg silicon/ha gave significantly higher Si concentration in grain and straw over control and 40 kg silicon/ha during both the years”
Si uptake by grain
↑ 11
- increase
40, 80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 40/80/120 versus0 separate marginal comparisons; grain uptake LSD5.7.
Numbers
- treatment 62.7 vs. control 56.8 kg/ha (+10.39 %) · 40 kg Si/ha
- treatment 74.1 vs. control 56.8 kg/ha (+30.46 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 78.2 vs. control 56.8 kg/ha (+37.68 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 4 “application of 80 and 120 silicon kg/ha gave significantly higher Si-uptake by grain, straw and its total uptake over control and 40 kg silicon/ha during both the years.”
Source · p. 3 “Control 1.30 3.69 56.8 214.6 52.4 40 1.36 3.79 62.7 232.8 57.8”
Si uptake by straw
↑ 11
- increase
80 and 120 kg Si/ha vs. Control (0 Si)significant · 2015–2016 two-year mean · ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm · 80/120 versus0 separate marginal comparisons; straw uptake LSD20.4; total uptake column corrupt and excluded.
Numbers
- treatment 255.9 vs. control 214.6 kg/ha (+19.25 %) · 80 kg Si/ha
- treatment 262.3 vs. control 214.6 kg/ha (+22.23 %) · 120 kg Si/ha
Source · p. 4 “application of 80 and 120 silicon kg/ha gave significantly higher Si-uptake by grain, straw and its total uptake over control and 40 kg silicon/ha during both the years.”
Set-up
Treatments
- rice establishment methodSowing method
- TPRTransplantingARAerobic riceSRISystem of rice intensificationAR and SRI, agreeing individual biological comparisonsSowing method
- silicon application levelSilicate fertilizer
- Control (0 Si)No silicate fertilizer80 and 120 kg Si/haSilicate fertilizer40, 80 and 120 kg Si/haSilicate fertilizer
Measured
- grain yieldYield
- Unit
- t/ha
- number of panicles per meter squareEar number per area
- Unit
- m-2
- microbial biomass carbon
- Unit
- μg/g soil
- dehydrogenase activityDehydrogenase
- Unit
- µg TPF/g soil/day
- total count of silicon solubilizing bacteriaBacteria
- Unit
- 10^2 cfu/g soil
- Method
- Selective culture using Aaleksandrov medium
- Si concentration in grainPlant Si content
- Unit
- %
- Method
- Spectrophotometric method, Ma and Tamai2002
- Si concentration in strawPlant Si content
- Unit
- %
- Method
- Harvested straw (grain excluded), spectrophotometric method
- Si uptake by grainAboveground plant Si uptake
- Unit
- kg/ha
- Si uptake by strawAboveground plant Si uptake
- Unit
- kg/ha
- Method
- Harvested straw excludes grain
Sites
ICAR-Indian Agricultural Research Institute research farm
- Location
- New Delhi, India28.63° N, 77.17° E
- Land use
- rice-wheat cropping systemRice fields
- Management on the whole site
- Pusa Basmati 1509 riceAsian rice/Oryza sativa, ureaUrea fertilizer, di-ammonium phosphateDiammonium phosphate fertilizer, muriate of potashPotassium chloride fertilizer
| Depth | Texture | Clay | pH | Organic C | Bulk density |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| initial soil (depth not stated) | sandy clay loam | – | 8.32 | 0.55 % | – |
Similar papers
Effect of Nitrogen and Silicon Fertilization on Growth and Productivity of Rice under Red and Laterite Soil
Paul et al. · 2026 · Silicon
8 shared concepts
22 findings1 site
Co-fertilization of Silicon and Phosphorus Influences the Dry Matter Accumulation, Grain Yield, Nutrient Uptake, and Nutrient-Use Efficiencies of Aerobic Rice
Jinger et al. · 2021 · Silicon
8 shared concepts
30 findings1 site
Enhancement of agronomic traits and yield of rice var. ADT 43 grown in typic ustifluvent soil through silicon fertilization
V et al. · 2021 · Journal of Applied and Natural Science
6 shared concepts
16 findings1 site
Growth and nutrient contents in lowland rice due to phosphorus and potassium fertilization
Reis et al. · 2018 · Pesquisa Agropecuária Tropical
6 shared concepts
28 findings3 sites
Crop and Residue Management Improves Productivity and Profitability of Rice–Maize System in Salt-Affected Rainfed Lowlands of East India
Sarangi et al. · 2020 · Agronomy
5 shared concepts
4 findings1 site
