Vadose Zone Journal · 2012
Clay Dispersibility and Soil Friability-Testing the Soil Clay-to-Carbon Saturation Concept
Schjønning, P., de Jonge, L., Munkholm, L., Moldrup, P., Christensen, B., Olesen, J.
Export
Clay Dispersibility and Soil Friability-Testing the Soil Cla…
Abstract
Soil organic carbon (OC) influences clay dispersibility, which affects soil tilth conditions and the risk of vertical migration of clay colloids. No universal lower threshold of OC has been identified for satisfactory stabilization of soil structure. We tested the concept of clay saturation with OC as a predictor of clay dispersibility and soil friability. Soil was sampled 3 yr in a field varying in clay content (∼100 to ∼220 g kg −1 soil) and grown with different crop rotations. Clay dispersibility was measured after end‐over‐end shaking of field‐moist soil and 1‐ to 2‐mm sized aggregates either air‐dried or rewetted to −100 hPa matric potential. Tensile strength of 1‐ to 2‐, 2‐ to 4‐, 4‐ to 8‐, and 8‐ to 16‐mm air‐dried aggregates was calculated from their compressive strength, and soil friability estimated from the strength–volume relation. Crop rotation characteristics gave only minor effects on clay dispersibility and no detectable effects on soil friability. Dispersed clay correlated to soil content of clay, but the correlation increased if subtracting a fraction assumed protected by OC. This trend was less convincing for soil tensile strength and friability. Increased clay dispersibility and reduced soil friability for 1 yr of measurements could be ascribed to wet conditions for potato ( Solanum tuberosum L.) harvest and tillage the preceding year. Literature data indicate soils' content of clay and silt (Fines20) to be a better predictor of specific surface area than clay. We conclude that a clay/OC ratio of 10 and a Fines20/OC ratio of 20 may serve as corresponding thresholds for clay dispersibility, the latter probably best reflecting organo‐mineral interactions of importance to the soil physical properties.
Show all
Soil organic carbon (OC) influences clay dispersibility, which affects soil tilth conditions and the risk of vertical migration of clay colloids. No universal lower threshold of OC has been identified for satisfactory stabilization of soil structure. We tested the concept of clay saturation with OC as a predictor of clay dispersibility and soil friability. Soil was sampled 3 yr in a field varying in clay content (∼100 to ∼220 g kg −1 soil) and grown with different crop rotations. Clay dispersibility was measured after end‐over‐end shaking of field‐moist soil and 1‐ to 2‐mm sized aggregates either air‐dried or rewetted to −100 hPa matric potential. Tensile strength of 1‐ to 2‐, 2‐ to 4‐, 4‐ to 8‐, and 8‐ to 16‐mm air‐dried aggregates was calculated from their compressive strength, and soil friability estimated from the strength–volume relation. Crop rotation characteristics gave only minor effects on clay dispersibility and no detectable effects on soil friability. Dispersed clay correlated to soil content of clay, but the correlation increased if subtracting a fraction assumed protected by OC. This trend was less convincing for soil tensile strength and friability. Increased clay dispersibility and reduced soil friability for 1 yr of measurements could be ascribed to wet conditions for potato ( Solanum tuberosum L.) harvest and tillage the preceding year. Literature data indicate soils' content of clay and silt (Fines20) to be a better predictor of specific surface area than clay. We conclude that a clay/OC ratio of 10 and a Fines20/OC ratio of 20 may serve as corresponding thresholds for clay dispersibility, the latter probably best reflecting organo‐mineral interactions of importance to the soil physical properties.
Soil organic carbon (OC) influences clay dispersibility, which affects soil tilth conditions and the risk of vertical migration of clay colloids. No universal lower threshold of OC has been identified for satisfactory stabilization of soil structure. We tested the concept of clay saturation with OC as a predictor of clay dispersibility and soil friability. Soil was sampled 3 yr in a field varying in clay content (∼100 to ∼220 g kg −1 soil) and grown with different crop rotations. Clay dispersibility was measured after end‐over‐end shaking of field‐moist soil and 1‐ to 2‐mm sized aggregates either air‐dried or rewetted to −100 hPa matric potential. Tensile strength of 1‐ to 2‐, 2‐ to 4‐, 4‐ to 8‐, and 8‐ to 16‐mm air‐dried aggregates was calculated from their compressive strength, and soil friability estimated from the strength–volume relation. Crop rotation characteristics gave only minor effects on clay dispersibility and no detectable effects on soil friability. Dispersed clay correlated to soil content of clay, but the correlation increased if subtracting a fraction assumed protected by OC. This trend was less convincing for soil tensile strength and friability. Increased clay dispersibility and reduced soil friability for 1 yr of measurements could be ascribed to wet conditions for potato ( Solanum tuberosum L.) harvest and tillage the preceding year. Literature data indicate soils' content of clay and silt (Fines20) to be a better predictor of specific surface area than clay. We conclude that a clay/OC ratio of 10 and a Fines20/OC ratio of 20 may serve as corresponding thresholds for clay dispersibility, the latter probably best reflecting organo‐mineral interactions of importance to the soil physical properties.
Similar papers
Eleven Years' Effect of Conservation Practices for Temperate Sandy Loams: I. Soil Physical Properties and Topsoil Carbon Content
Abdollahi, Getahun & Munkholm · 2017 · Soil Science Society of America Journal
5 shared concepts
17 findings2 sites
Long-term tillage and irrigation effects on aggregation and soil organic carbon stabilization mechanisms
Dal Ferro et al. · 2023 · Geoderma
4 shared concepts
28 findings1 site
Long-term manure and cropping systems effect on soil water vapour sorption characteristics is controlled by soil texture
Yan et al. · 2023 · Geoderma
5 shared concepts
